Re: [SOCM-FORUM] Re: New Constitution & the future
- The 1934 contistitution is made one-sided and most of the clauses
are not clear. There are double meaning in most clauses. Eg.
The universal synod. Which one is that ?? Now Adv.K. George is
saying that it consists of all churches - Copitic - Ethyopian
Armenian et c. etc. For jacobites that is not acceptable.
A church constitution is to be written very clearly.
----- Original Message -----
Sent: Wednesday, July 10, 2002 11:13 PM
Subject: [SOCM-FORUM] Re: New Constitution & the future
> What is wrong with the existing constitution?
- IANS [ SATURDAY, AUGUST 24, 2002 9:45:22 PM ]
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM: A row between two groups of the Malankara Syrian
Church in Kerala could snowball into violence, with one planning to
forcefully enter a church synonymous with the rival faction.
The Orthodox faction is set to enter the famous St. Mary's Church at
Manarcaud, seven km from Kottayam on August 31. The church, however,
is considered a prestigious symbol of the Patriarch faction.
This was decided at a diocesan level meeting held at the headquarters
of the Orthodox church in Kottayam Friday.
The faithful belonging to the Orthodox faction are to give a mammoth
reception to Baselios Mar Thoma II, the supreme head of the church,
at Kottayam and then lead him and other bishops in a vehicle
procession to Manarcaud.
The metropolitan is to offer prayers at the St. Mary's Church in the
St. Mary's Church has always been the citadel of the Patriarch
faction and never has a priest from the Orthodox faction been able to
officially enter it.
"We will not allow such a thing to happen and this act is meant to
destroy whatever little peace is left between the two factions. If
they try to enter the church, there will be severe law and order
problems," said a staunch member of the Patriarch faction.
The newly ordained supreme head of the Patriarch faction Baselios
Thomas I has gone on record to say that if anyone tries encroach upon
churches under its control, the move will be dealt with accordingly.
But hardliners in the Orthodox faction are determined that unless
some "action" is taken, the government will not act.
"The Patriarch faction wants the state government to act according to
a Supreme Court verdict that says the supreme head of the church is
Baselios Mar Thoma II and all the properties belong to him," said an
Orthodox faction devotee.
Trouble has already broken out in Ernakulam and in some parts of
Trissur where the Patriarch faction has an edge and controls most
Ugly scenes were witnessed on two occasions in the last week when the
Patriarch faction followers objected to the last rites of two people
belonging to the Orthodox faction. Finally police had to intervene.
The funeral of Fr. Joseph Vendrapally, an Orthodox priest at St
Mary's church Vadvacode in Ernakulam district, Friday took place
after several rounds of discussion between the district
administration, the police and the two factions.
The church is fully under the control of the Patriarch faction.
Senior bishops of the Orthodox faction were not allowed to enter the
church and they performed the last rites at another place even before
the body was brought to the church at Vadvacode for burial.
Despite the presence of several churches in the state for different
sections of Christians, none has made efforts to broker peace between
the Orthodox and Patriarch factions.
When asked about the feud and the damage it could do to Christians in
Kerala, the supreme head of the Mar Thoma Church, Phillipose Mar
Chrysostom, evaded an answer.
In February this year, the Supreme Court had asked the Malankara
Association to elect the Malankara metropolitan to facilitate
reconciliation between the factions. Until 1970, the two groups were
The Patriarch faction, constituting around 35 percent of the
Malankara Syrian Church, did not find the Supreme Court judgment to
its liking and did not take part in preparing the electoral rolls for
In March the association meeting held at Parumala saw the election of
Baselios Mar Thoma II as the catholicos and the new metropolitan.
But the last vestiges of unity ended in June when the Patriarch of
Antioch in Damascus ordained Thomas Mar Dinonysius as Catholicos
Baselios Thomas I, the supreme head of the new church.
THE TIMES OF INDIA
SUNDAY, AUGUST 25, 2002