Points & "proof"
- The bodkin points thread has come up at just the right time! I was
talking to a friend of mine in Caid recently, and the discussion came
around to combat archery. I guess out in Caid (I'm in Shire of
Oakheart, in Calontir), there is a ruling that "plate is proof"
against combat arrows. Now, as I understand it, historically, a
footed arrow with a bodkin point, shot from a war bow of a trained
archer, should be able to pierce plate mail, should it not? Thus, it
doesn't make sense to me that plate mail should automatically be
completely impervious to combat archers' arrows. I mean, in theory
it could be argued that not every archer on the field is going to be
a trained longbowman of the Hundred Years War era. Likewise,
however, the same argument could be made of fighters on the field,
that not every one of them would be dressed in full plate with the
sloping breastplate that could possibly deflect arrows, or of the
high level of craftsmanship achieved at the height of the art. Thus,
I figure it would break about even, with both sides being in equal
peril on the field. So, my question here is if there is any
documentable proof, especially modern tests done of replica longbows,
that prove that plate is or isn't proof, or something of the like in
period documentation. I seem to recall that there is documentation
supporting the ability of the longbow, at least, being able to pierce
plate mail of its time, but I can't recall it or find it among the
books I have. Anyone up to the challenge? It may not change
anything, but who cares? I just have a hard time as an archer
letting that assertion go unchallenged.
Yours on the line,
mka Ben Reeder
- Right you are. I'm on both lists and lost track of which one I was reading.
At 12:48 PM 2/3/2005, you wrote:
> > Many of those discussions were on this list and should be in the
> archives here.
> > Carolus
>Actually, most of them were on the SCA-MissileCombat mailing list ...
>and are archived there. But if you really want to read 'it all',
>you've got at least 2 years of catching up reading to do.
No virus found in this outgoing message.
Checked by AVG Anti-Virus.
Version: 7.0.300 / Virus Database: 265.8.3 - Release Date: 1/31/2005