Re: [RedHotJazz] Anyone know why the main site is down?
- I personally wish this discussion to be over, but since (for once) I started
replying to a query regarding the RHJ site, here we go :
The most important thing (which I already mentioned) is, I think, that we
can expect the site to keep working at least until December 2011.
The have been so many temporary failures over the years that I suppose the
safest thing, now that we've lost concact with Scott, is to wait until
things are settled.
Another comment is that I think one of the reasons why Scott chose the
realaudio format was that he simply did not want his files to be downloaded.
Plenty of things have changed since then, not only the actual downloading
facility offered by the latest version of the Realplayer, but also the
amazing number of free downloads now offered all over the web, with the more
or less valid excuse of public domain status.
Keeping a streaming protocol, rather than dowloadable mp3's with better
sound quality is, among other things, a way to expressly support the efforts
of the few small records companies which still remaster, publish, and of
course, expect to sell pre-war music. I suppose I do not have to elaborate
any further about this.
Another, very important thing is that Scott's labor of love cannot be
compared to large streaming websites supported by ads and/or some related
commercial activities, which can afford to pay for broadcasting music. We
did fear, a couple of years ago, that new directives regarding online
radios in the US might kill the Archives for good, I do not know much about
these questions but if I consider the crazy ambiguities of French law, I
assume the risk is still pending.
This is why I've always tried to be as discreet as possible about
downloading, and I encourage everyone here to do the same. Of course I am
not candid, the possibility of capturing online music has always existed, be
it only by recording what comes out of your soundcard.
I am not exerting any censorship here, but please remember that discussing
some questions privately with other members you know or trust is still a
possibility, and sometimes a more efficient one than making them public. Up
to your judgement, and I must add that this group is the only one I've known
or run where there are nearly no "moderating" problems, because of
From: Richard Lund
Sent: Saturday, December 04, 2010 9:04 PM
Subject: Re: [RedHotJazz] Anyone know why the main site is down?
Well, after 3 days of experimenting I had to finally give up on
downloading/archiving the site...
Apart from the fact that I received at least 2 dozen "file not found"
errors, I could not find a program that would allow me to batch download
the over 9,000 (!!!) song files...
I was able to get the URLs from the header files and combine them into
one text file, but there is no reliable program out there that will a)
load a list of URLs, b) download the old PNM protocol and c) work
without crashing randomly...
In fact, Streambox was the only program that came close, but it crashes
to frequently that the work I'd have to put into keeping it going would
not make it worth the little time I have available.
I can only hope that Scott finally will answer again and let us know of
If he should contact someone, I would like to offer an alternate
technology for serving the audio files - they could be stored in better
quality as MP3 files and played through a Flash interface (which is a
lot more common to find pre-installed than Real Player). Hopefully he
kept the original quality sound bites archived somewhere...
Anyway, that's neither here nor there until he surfaces again.
In any case, except for some "file not found" errors, the few audio
files that the program tried to download were downloaded successfully,
so it would seem that at least most of the site is still intact.
- -----Message d'origine-----
>TheRE have been so many temporary failures over the years that I supposeI meant to add "next time the site is down".
> safest thing (...) is to wait until things are settled.
- Sorry, I guess I went a little overboard with this, partially because
of my fear that the site might disappear some day...
If this wasn't a realistic possibility, I would never have said anything
publicly, and now after reading your last message I will stop talking
about it - done.
One clarification: MP3s when played through a Flash interface are not
particularly easy to download either unless you know a few tricks.