Loading ...
Sorry, an error occurred while loading the content.

3949Re: When did Jazz die?

Expand Messages
  • Robert Greenwood
    Mar 17, 2007
      -Patrice, you wrote:
      "... you won't force the African-American audience to support styles that were clearly
      related to
      segregation, prohibition, depression and misery, and the most incredible
      unequality - this is purely intellectual nostalgia which only wealthy
      intellectual whites can afford, just like regretting the good old times of
      hard work from sun to sun on the Mississippi Delta plantations which
      produced such fascinating blues!"

      I'm never sure what people mean when they link the jazz of the past with "segregation,
      prohibition, depression and misery, and the most incredible unequality" It's true, of
      course, to say that the musicians who produced the music had to live under these
      intolerable conditions, but surely they produced music of such genius and beauty that it
      represents an heroic transcendence of those conditions? Would it not rather be purely
      "intellectual" for someone hearing, say, the Jelly Roll Morton Red Hot Peppers recordings,
      or the Louis Hot Fives & Sevens, only to "hear" in them the evidence of segregation,
      prohibition, depression and misery? I, for one, do not believe that anyone, without some
      effort of will, like some whining adolescent determined to make themselves profoundly
      miserable, could sincerely hear all that in the music. If they do, then this is yet another
      example of white, middle class self-loathing and self-flagellation that surely dishonours
      the music and the people who produced it.
      Robert Greenwood
    • Show all 30 messages in this topic