Re: Big mosaics with Hugn
- Hi Jürgen
Well I too thought PTGui should work, but in fact no matter how I try to align a big mosaic it gives a slightly bulging image, like a full frame fisheye. Whereas with Hugin I can get a perfectly square one. It is as if some part of PTGui is still assuming a single viewpoint. Also, PTGui still needs to be told an artificially large focal length, while Hugin works correctly with the true one.
As for showing more of the surroundings, that is something I am trying to learn to do. But (as in painting) it is a matter of finding opportunities and carefully choosing deceptions, since there is no simple way to combine multiple viewpoints seamlessly. In the Community picture, the vertical corner of the building is a perfect "hinge line" for attaching a rectilinear photo of the front, and the guy on the bicycle helps connect that space to the space in front of the painting. I could (and probably will) rework "Mario Lanza" so the stuff visible above and behind the mural looks more natural. But my basic attitude here is that I'm just documenting the paintings.
--- In PanoToolsNG@yahoogroups.com, "jrgen_schrader" <panorama@...> wrote:
> Good work, Thomas and an interesting project in the city.
> I would have loved to see a bit more from the surroundings like in the community image.
> Could you be a bit more specific regarding your experience with PTGui and why that didn't work for you? I never tried that myself but as most parts of the murals are in the same plane I would have thought that with viewpointcorrection also PTGui should be able to get it done.
> --- In PanoToolsNG@yahoogroups.com, "Thomas" <TKSharpless@> wrote:
> > I've been happily making high resolution mosaics of wall paintings with Hugin. There is a page of them at http://tksharpless.net/PhillyMurals/.
> > They were shot with 15mm, 24mm, and 35mm lenses on APS-C format cameras, from multiple positions about equidistant from the wall, using a pole to get a high point of view. In almost all cases there were poles and wires in the way, but I have been able to 'vanish' most of them just by masking before blending. In a few cases I have resorted to hand painting in Photoshop.
> > It's a bit chancy getting very wide mosaics to align right, one must add plenty of straight line CPs, and take care to delete all CPs not on the plane of the mural (and bogus CP matches, which Hugins CP finder is prone to generate). In some cases I've had to add one image at a time to the optimized pool, after presetting y,p,r,x,y,z to reasonably close values.
> > Anyhow I'm quite pleased with Hugin's ability to do this, which PTGui
> > cannot.
> > Cheers, Tom