Papua police ban on new magazine breaks Indonesian press laws
Papua police ban on new magazine breaks Indonesian press lawsFidelis Jeminta, chief editor of "Pelita Papua" magazine, said police action would again deter freedom of the press in West Papua
Katarina Lita / PortalKBR / PFFPolice actions to stop distribution of a new magazine in West Papua break press laws of Indonesia and must be condemned, says the Pacific Freedom Forum.
"Press freedom is not a vague constitutional promise in Indonesia," says Titi Gabi, Chair of the Pacific Freedom Forum.
"There are specific laws that back press freedom and expressly prohibit police from banning media organisations."
Pacific Freedom Forum joins the Indonesian Press Council in criticising police for their actions against the magazine, Papua Pelita.
The magazine had dedicated its first issue to reporting on the OPM, the Organisation of Papua Freedom, with a cover featuring the West Papua pro-independence flag - which is banned by authorities in West Papua, but not anywhere else in Indonesia.
Indonesia Press Council member Imam Wahdyudi said that blocking the press is defined as the forceful or unlawful prohibition of publishing, distributing and/or broadcast of information, under Press Law No. 40/1999.
Imam Wahdyudi said that if police do not approve of the contents of a publication then the only legal option available to them was to complain to the Press Council.
"If the police really did come and prohibit the distribution of information, that is a form of blocking the press," said Imam Wahdyudi.
Magazine publishers had already distributed 2,000 copies of the 64-page inaugural edition when police arrived and instructed them not to distribute any further copies.
They also confiscated half a dozen copies for inspection.
Fidelis Jeminta, chief editor of Pelita Papua in Jayapura, said he was disappointed at the police action and that this case would again restrict freedom of the press in Papua.
"We feel we are being treated unjustly. Out there, many media outlets show pictures of the Bintang Kejora (symbol of the independence movement) but are not examined by the police," he said.
PFF co-Chair Monica Miller said that the police action was undoubtedly illegal and was a further illustration of the breakdown of rule of law in West Papua.
"Continued failure by Jakarta to rein in their police and security forces is unacceptable and must be condemned", said Miller.
"We join our colleagues at Alliance of Independent Journalists in expressing common concern at a rise in violent and other actions against journalists in West Papua."
Police denied there was any ban.
"It was just a check up, to see if there was any seditious material", said Papua Regional Police Commissioner Gede Sumerta Jaya.
Nine cases so far this year to June 2013 relate to freedom and independence of the press, according to AJI, the Alliance of Independent Journalists in Papua.
members working in this country 2
- Most covered free expression issues in this country
Key reports and information
The Dark Side of Green Growth - Human Rights Impacts of Weak Governance in Indonesia's Forestry Sector
The government has enacted unnecessary restrictions on access to information about forest concessions and land claims. Authorities have harassed and intimidated local activists who have been bringing attention to forest sector abuses, and a number of environmentalists and activists have been arrested or prosecuted in recent months over plantation disputes.
Coffins delivered to media organisations in an attempt to intimidate journalists
Indonesian journalists cover corruption at great risk
"At least two journalists were killed, five kidnapped and 18 assaulted in 2011"
Direct and indirect suppression of speech, books, music and other materials considered morally, politically or otherwise objectionable.
Key reports and information
Burma is at a crossroads. The period of transition since 2010 has opened up the space for freedom of expression to an extent unpredicted by even the most optimistic in the country. Yet this space is highly contingent on a number of volatile factors.
ARTICLE 19, Access, English PEN and PEN International welcome the opportunity to contribute to the second cycle of the UPR process of Viet Nam.
The media landscape in Burma is more open than ever, as President Thein Sein releases imprisoned journalists and abolishes the former censorship regime. But many threats and obstacles to truly unfettered reporting remain, including restrictive laws held over from the previous military regime. The wider government’s commitment to a more open reporting environment is in doubt.
- Most covered countries for this issue
Subscribe to This Week
A seven-day snapshot of free expression news from around the world
Also, sign up for the IFEX Daily Digest