Loading ...
Sorry, an error occurred while loading the content.

Metropolitan Hilarion of Volokolamsk: Allegations about a 'breakthrough' in Orthodox-Catholic dialogue are untrue

Expand Messages
  • emrys@globe.net.nz
    Metropolitan Hilarion of Volokolamsk: Allegations about a breakthrough in Orthodox-Catholic dialogue are untrue 27.09.2010 · DECR Chairman
    Message 1 of 1 , Sep 30, 2010
    • 0 Attachment
      Metropolitan Hilarion of Volokolamsk: Allegations about a 'breakthrough' in
      Orthodox-Catholic dialogue are untrue

      27.09.2010 · DECR Chairman


      As has been stressed by the chairman of the Moscow Patriarchate's department
      for external church relations, Metropolitan Hilarion of Volokolamsk, the
      working document of the Joint International Commission for Orthodox-Catholic
      Dialogue, publicized so widely by some media, does not reflect the attitude
      of the Orthodox side to the problem of primacy of the bishop of Rome and can
      be viewed only as a purely auxiliary paper for further work.

      Contrary to allegations in the press, the Orthodox-Catholic Commission
      meeting in Vienna has made no 'breakthrough' whatsoever. The entire meeting
      was devoted to a discussion on the role of the bishop of Rome in the first
      millennium. The Commission's coordinating committee had drafted a document
      on this issue, which was discussed last year in Cyprus. A rough draft of
      this document 'leaked' into the mass media and was published.

      It was planned to finalize the discussion on this draft in Vienna. However,
      something different happened as the discussion on the status of this draft
      took too much time. The Orthodox participants, from the very beginning of
      the meeting, insisted that 'Crete Document' could not be officially
      published on behalf of the Commission, nor could it be signed by its
      members. From our point of view, this draft has to be considerably revised,
      but even after the revision it only could have the status of 'working
      document', that is, auxiliary material (instrumentum laboris) which could be
      used in preparing subsequent documents and could have no official status.

      'The Crete Document' is purely historical and, speaking of the role of the
      bishop of Rome, it makes almost no mention of bishops of other Local
      Churches in the first millennium, thus creating a wrong impression of how
      powers were distributed in the Early Church. Besides, the document is
      lacking any clear statement that the jurisdiction of the bishop of Rome did
      not extend to the East in the first millennium. It is hoped that these gaps
      and omissions will be made up in revising the text.

      After a long discussion, the Commission agreed that this document should be
      improved and that a final decision on its status should be made at the next
      plenary session of the Commission, that is, presumably in two-year's time.
      By this time a new draft document will have been elaborated to deal with the
      same problem but from the theological perspective.

      For the Orthodox participants, it is clear that in the first millennium the
      jurisdiction of the bishop of Rome was exercised only in the West, while in
      the East, the territories were divided between four Patriarchs - those of
      Constantinople, Alexandria, Antioch and Jerusalem. The bishop of Rome did
      not exercise any direct jurisdiction in the East in spite of the fact that
      in some cases Eastern hierarchs appealed to him as arbiter in theological
      disputes. These appeals were not systematic and can in no way be interpreted
      in the sense that the bishop of Rome was seen in the East as the supreme
      authority in the whole Universal Church.

      It is hoped that at the next meetings of the Commission, the Catholic side
      will agree with this position which is confirmed by numerous historical

      DECR Communication Service
    Your message has been successfully submitted and would be delivered to recipients shortly.