169University of California sued for discriminating against Christian courses
- Sep 7, 2005http://www.answersingenesis.org/docs2005/0906uc.asp
University of California sued for discriminating against Christian courses
Some college-prep classes deemed too religious
by Pam Sheppard, staff writer, AiGUSA
September 6, 2005
For high school seniors, applying for college should be an exciting timeeven more so for those
with outstanding academic and extracurricular records. For these students, the sky should be the
limit when it comes to choice. Sadly, that wont be the case for six high school students whose
acceptance to the University of California (UC) system1 has already been decided, even though they
havent even applied.
Unless they choose to take other college-prep classes that use textbooks deemed acceptable by
UC, these students applications will most likely be denied. The reason: the Christian textbooks
used in several new college-prep courses at their high school were considered too religious to
be accepted for college-entrance credit at UC.
On August 25, these six students, along with their school, Calvary Chapel Christian School in
Murrieta, California and the Association of Christian Schools International (ACSI),2 filed a
federal lawsuit against the University of California where, according to the LA Times (August 27),
admissions officials have been accused of discriminating against high schools that teach
creationism and other conservative Christian viewpoints.
According to the Times article, UCs board of admissions advised the school that it would not
approve biology and science courses that relied primarily on textbooks published by Bob Jones
University Press and A Beka Books. Some of the schools Christian-oriented courses were too
narrow to be acceptable, university officials wrote in letters to Calvary Chapel.
Wendell R. Bird, an Atlanta lawyer who is representing the ACSI in the suit summed up the
situation in the Inside Higher Ed article (August 29) when he said, All viewpoints are perfectly
acceptable until they are Christian.
Bird goes on to say that the university system approves courses and offers its own courses from
Buddhist, Jewish, feminist and other viewpoints. This is picking one viewpoint and banning it for
According to an ACSI Legal Legislative Update (Fall 2005), in a May 2004 meeting between Christian
school personnel, UC personnel and attorneys from both sides of the issue, the UC representatives
indicated that there was no problem with the material facts in the BJU physics textbookthat if
the Scripture verses that begin each chapter were removed the textbook would likely be approved
for the science lab course requirement.
The Update article goes on to say that as the discussion continued about the biology books, it
became evident that they were rejected because they appeared to state the perspective that the
Bible is revelation and along with faith is more authoritative than the observations of science,
especially if there were a conflict over a factual scientific issue.
As reported by the Inside Higher Ed, the science courses that have been rejected teach not only
creationism or intelligent design, but also teach the standard content of evolution, even if the
teachers do not believe the content.
Other courses rejected by UC officials, according to the Times article (August 27), include
Christianitys Influence in American History, Christianity and Morality in American Literature
and Special Providence: American Government.
Not surprisingly, professors at the University of California praised the University for requiring
applicants to have been taught evolution.
If you dont understand evolution, you dont understand biology, Albert F. Bennett, chair of
ecology and evolutionary biology at the universitys Irvine campus said in the Inside Higher Ed
article. If you dont understand biology, you dont understand modern science. A student
ill-versed in science is poorly prepared for university-level work.
AiG has pointed out numerous times that a belief in molecules-to-man evolution contributes nothing
to a persons understanding of empirical science and plays no essential role in biomedical
research or education (for examples, see A Philly story), as stated by Ph.D. cell biologist and
AiG speaker Dr. David Menton.
While California may be the only state in the nation that has taken such actions against Christian
schools, according to the Times, what does this lawsuit say about the future?
If California, which is more hostile towards Christians than other states, isnt stopped, this
kind of discrimination will spread. This is really a foretaste of things to come, said Jonathan
McCants, attorney with law firm of Bird & Loechl, who (along with the southern California public
interest law firm Advocates for Faith and Freedom) will represent the plaintiffs.
McCants isnt alone in his concern. ACSI is concerned that this secular intolerance might spread
to other institutions and to other states saying in the Update that, It appears to [them] that it
is only a matter of time before all schools using these textbooks will find that they no longer
meet the requirements for UC course approval.
McCants said that UC has been deliberate in their reach of their policies, noting that at first
only new courses were affected, but by 2006, they reserve the right to review all courses
And when it comes to academic freedom, ACSI representatives were quick to point out the double
standard set forth by the university. Isnt it surprising that, as everyone knows, public
university personnel adamantly defend their right to academic freedomyet these same people seem
to be denying equal freedom to California Christian high schools and to those who attend these
If organizations as ACSI aren't willing to stand up to this kind of discrimination, it will
affect everybody, said McCants.
The bias shown by UC has most certainly affected these six students and their families. Answers in
Genesis applauds their boldness, along with ACSI, in standing up for the authority of the Word of
The University of California (USA) represents 10 university campuses such as UCLA, UC Berkeley and
UC San Diego. Return to text.
ACSI represents more than 800 religious schools in the state and 4,000 nationwide. Return to text.
Christopher W. Ashcraft
Northwest Creation Network