Loading ...
Sorry, an error occurred while loading the content.

Supplement: Satsang with Byron Katie

Expand Messages
  • umbada@xx.xxxxxxxxx.xxxxxxxxxxx.xxxxx)
    This is a supplement to the regular highlights. It features all of Petros reports on Satsang with Byron Katie. Future ones will be added to the regular
    Message 1 of 1 , Oct 11, 1999
      This is a supplement to the regular highlights. It features
      all of Petros' reports on Satsang with Byron Katie. Future
      ones will be added to the regular Highlights. One thing I
      enjoy doing with digests I get from various lists, is
      printing them out to read at work during breaks or slow
      time; they can be read at any number of places beyond the
      reach of the computer: the bus, the laundromat, any kind of
      waiting room, during a stop on a long walk, in bed, at you
      friend's while hanging out, all kinds of places. I use a
      9-pin or 24-pin printer on draft mode, so the copies are
      cheap. For this purpose alone it is worth spending under $50
      for a good used printer.



      Check out Byron Katie's website at http://www.thework.org
      first for some background on this, then you'll get more out
      of my report.

      Katie's teaching is more psychological in nature than
      metaphysical. It's referred to simply as "the Work" (tm),
      and she has "intensives" and two-week "certification"
      courses rather than satsangs. The intensives are free or
      for donation only, but the longer courses may be expensive.

      This weekend's intensive was held in a hotel ballroom in El
      Segundo, adjacent to LAX for convenience I suppose. It was
      set up like a satsang, with about a hundred chairs facing a
      wide dais with a comfy couch upon which Katie sat. She has
      a very professional organization, with video monitors
      arranged about the room and several wireless microphones
      that volunteer assistants could pass around to people who
      had questions and comments. Katie herself wore a headset
      mike, which meant you didn't have to strain to hear what was
      being said.

      Essentially she asked who was taking "the Work" for the
      first time, and picked someone from the group of raised
      hands to come up and sit beside her on the couch. Prior to
      the start of the meeting everyone who registered was handed
      a piece of paper on which to write down the basic
      self-inquiry questions in the Work which could then be
      discussed on the platform.

      Katie has a soft but very confident and intelligent manner.
      Her whole work consists of encouraging people to "turn
      around" their judgments of others, bring them back to
      themselves, so that they can see clearly how their judgments
      of others merely reflect self-judgment. She says it's best
      to begin by judging others, because we're so good at it!

      After working with one man's particular problem for about
      ten or fifteen minutes, Katie turned to the audience and
      encouraged people to provide feedback; then used this
      feedback itself as a means of showing each person how they
      are really addressing themselves. The exciting part is that
      eventually people "get it," and actually *listen* to
      themselves before saying anything that they wouldn't be able
      to "turn around" and put back on themselves.

      More on "the Work" in my next post.

      When you register at the desk you are handed the "little
      blue book" which contains the written portion of The Work
      (tm.) In a nutshell, this is:
      "Judge your neighbor, write it down, ask four questions,
      turn it around!"

      Also one is handed a clipboard and a printed form which
      contains the same questions, and one is "invited" to fill
      this out prior to the beginning of the intensive. The
      inquiry is as follows:

      1. Who or what don't you like? Who or what irritates you?
      Who or what saddens or disappoints you? (I don't like or am
      angry at ________________, because ___________________.)

      (When one of Katie's volunteers greeted me at the
      registration desk and helped me find a seat I was already a
      little annoyed, as I tend to get very hostile and
      hyper-cynical before anything of this sort. When she asked
      me without any preface, "Who are you angry at?" I thought
      she was reading the expression on my face and was a little
      taken aback until I realized she was just showing me how to
      do the inquiry. I considered saying something like, "People
      who ask stupid questions" but my brain wasn't working fast

      Maybe I'm coming down with a bug or something, but I felt
      rather under-the-weather this morning and the sight of all
      those tanned Californians hugging and kissing each other and
      getting all slimy just made me a little queasy.)

      2. How do you want them to change? What do you want them
      to do? (I want __________ (name) to ____________.)

      3. What is it they should or shouldn't do, be, think or
      feel? What advice could you offer?

      4. Do you need anything from them? What do they need to
      give you or do for you to be happy?

      (Katie says, "Personalities don't love, they want

      5. What do you think of them? Make a list.

      6. What is it that you don't want to experience with that
      person, thing or situation again?

      The "four questions" part is:
      a. Is it true?
      b. Can I really know that it's true?
      c. How do I react when I think this thought?
      d. Who would I be without this thought?

      And the big "shift" comes at the Turn Around portion of the
      Work, which follows in my next post.


      After dialoging with someone form the audience, going
      through the person's six questions and four inquiries, Katie
      works to get the person to turn the judgment around, back
      onto oneself. This is the most important part of the whole
      process, and is where the real shift of awareness comes in.
      This is also why Katie wants us to start work with *others*
      rather than ourselves, since we have so much more practice
      judging others (this is also a good example of her subtle
      humor.) It also creates more of a shift when the turn-around
      takes place.

      For instance. The first person up on the couch with Katie
      was an Australian man who decided to write about a Rajneesh
      therapist he knew by the name of Tirtha. He read from his
      notes that he felt this man was continually bullying him,
      disrespecting him, and had prejudice against him. Katie
      said "turn it around." Thus: "I am continually bullying
      myself, disrespecting myself, and have prejudice against
      myself." The point is *not* to try to get rid of these
      negative attitudes, but to go deeply within and experience

      Quotes from Katie:
      "You cannot fail to be whole. Whatever name you are given,
      you can find within yourself if you go deeply enough. I am
      always discovering new names for myself to make myself more
      whole. For instance, if my husband says I'm an asshole, I
      can go deeply enough inside to find that in me. When he
      says I'm wonderful, if I go deeply enough inside I can find
      that there too."

      "It's not other people's job to acknowledge you or like you;
      that's your job."

      "Thoughts appear. It's not personal. You're not doing it."

      Though the intensive was scheduled from 9:30-4:30 today and
      Sunday, I left after just an hour because I felt I had
      "gotten" what she was saying. I was feeling a lot better
      about everyone there, no more hostility or irritation, so I
      figured that was a good time to leave. Maybe I'll come back
      tomorrow morning.


      You know, I felt after I left the meeting this morning that
      something really important was going on there. There is
      this sense one receives from Byron that there is almost no
      "person" left inside her. Just a precise responsiveness to
      others. Yet I was too asleep or dull to appreciate it until
      hours later. I will come back Sunday morning and sit in on
      another session.


      Quotes from _Losing the Moon: Byron Katie Dialogues on
      Non-Duality, Truth and Other Illusions_.

      "As God, I'm watching my image. It's called you. It's
      called the books over there. It's called the wall.
      Fireplace. Everything. Okay? So I'm watching it, and I
      thought I was that. I thought I was God. Here's how I came
      in as a reversal: I wasn't born this woman for 43 years and
      then awakened -- I was BORN. I was born at what you would
      call age 43. I came from nowhere and nothing. It was wiped
      out. I looked at my hand for the first time. I came in
      through a back door."

      "I'm too beautiful to be nothing and no-one. Give me a
      mirror. Why would I deny my very self?"

      "To wake up forever implies time. To wake up is just a past
      history apparently arising. It's old. It's to keep you
      from the experience now. . .
      . The stories go on, but without attachment to the story.
      And that's what the inquiry leaves us with. The freedom of
      non-attachment. Internal. Detachment from the movie."

      "When you look at, 'What do I get for holding the belief, I
      want to be enlightened,' you see you get to stay stuck in
      what you quote Ramana as saying is the problem ["The only
      obstacle to your enlightenment is the belief that you are
      not enlightened." Ramana Maharshi]. And the inquiry shows
      that beyond a doubt. . . . And who would you be without
      it? That's when you go into that space. And you can
      continue to hold the same concept after investigation, but
      without attachment, which is mostly what I experience you do
      anyway. You can't long for what you don't know. The
      concept is what you say it is."

      "And I could honestly say, 'Nothing is God.' It doesn't even
      exist, it's just one more concept. But when a person has
      'God is good, everything is God,' then everything has to
      fall into that pocket. It's a one-mindedness. .
      . . And it's infinite. So, it's that symbol that I
      suggest to people.
      Everything will fall into it, beautifully. And on the other
      side of it, when all falls into it, you come to see that it
      is nothing."

      "For some of us, to go back to the Self is to ignore what's
      out there -- it's a direction that would exclude. And I
      say, love where you are, because that's my experience."

      "I'm pretending not to be non-duality. Ramana holds the
      place where people can understand that truth. And I pretend
      I don't. And there's no 'I' doing it. It's just an


      I returned to the Byron Katie intensive this afternoon for a
      couple of hours. I was feeling a lot better. I definitely
      confirmed the sense I got yesterday about the quality of
      BK's method of approach and understanding.

      She invited a 12-year old boy up to her couch to dialogue
      about some abuse he had experienced from a stepfather, and
      time he spent in a shelter for single women and their
      children. Katie listened as he read from his "Work sheet"
      the six questions (see my earlier post) and helped him
      through the process of "turning it around." (This process
      of writing it down, going through each inquiry, and "turning
      it around" is called "doing the work.")

      Judgments of other people in our lives are thus clarified
      and turned around, so that we can easily see how we are
      really only ever judging ourselves.

      Negative judgments are inquired into.

      Crucial Katie-isms:
      "Who would I be without this thought? Who would I be
      without this story?"

      "Can you see a reason for keeping this thought? Don't *try*
      to get rid of it! But can you see a reason for keeping it?
      Who would you be without this thought?"

      "Is this judgment true? Can you know that _____________ is

      "Judge your neighbor, write it down, ask four questions,
      turn it around."

      "If you're over in someone else's mind dealing with their
      business, and they're in there dealing with it anyway,
      that's two of you over there, and there's nobody where YOU
      are. No wonder you feel lonely!"

      "Except for the story, there's no reality to it. Ever."

      This process took about half an hour, after which Katie
      opened the dialogue up to the audience for comments,
      questions and general feedback. Most people in the audience
      offerred their support and encouragement to the boy. He
      really did fantastically well. Afterward everyone was
      invited up to the couch to give him a big hug. (His mom



      you mentioned that byron katie is working from a
      psychological rather than metaphyical ground.

      Yes, it comes across as psychological or psychoanalytical,
      but in fact the source is from a much deeper place. I can
      sense it in her dialogues with people. I just bought one of
      her books at the meeting today and in it, she is quite
      explicit about her debt to the teachings of Ramana and
      nonduality in general. More on this later. I can
      understand the tactic of not making this explicit in public
      gatherings, however -- in order to make her teaching more
      accessible to people who may be put off by esoteric concepts
      and Indian terminology. (Katie does this much more so than
      Gangaji, who still makes use of Indian concepts and

      interesting, cause a thought/question crossed my mind after
      the gangaji satsang along these lines. she claimed the
      same-- said she wouldn't use the word enlightenment, or
      ignorance! that hers was not a religion or a denomination.
      the question is-- then why the air of spiritual gathering?
      the pranams, the silence, the lineage. ... i mean-- if
      you're not building a church, why put a steeple on it?

      Interesting question. You should have asked Gangaji

      In my experience, some sort of setup is necessary. The
      "couch" has become practically a religious icon in
      psychotherapy. In satsang, it's the Chair.
      (Though Katie uses a couch on a dais, so that she can have a
      person sit next to her during dialogue and everyone can

      Katie also has some flowers and music, and photos of her can
      be purchased along with audio and video cassettes of prior
      intensives. However, there is no prostration or folding of
      hands (namaste), it's very "western" except for the dais
      arrangement. I mean, anyone (like me) who's been to many
      satangs would immediately see the Indian influence and
      either feel comforted (like me) or put off (if someone had
      bad experiences with "gurus" in the past.)

      would you say that katie is more western in her

      Definitely, except for the details mentioned above. I'll
      post some quotations from her book soon and we can read
      places where she expresses a debt to folks like Ramana
      Maharshi -- but she doesn't have "a" teacher, as far as I

      i'll be interested in hearing if you formulate any more
      thought about her not seeming to have "a person" left inside
      her. .. i do know exactly what you're saying there. ..

      Yes. I feel that there is *almost* no personality left in
      there. I mentioned this to a friend of mine who also
      attended the intensive and he also knew what I was saying
      and agreed. I say "almost," because Katie does have a
      colloquial presentation style and a subtle, ironic humor,
      not to mention a typically Californian warmth that makes her
      accessible to so many people. I might venture to suggest
      that she has kept just enough of a personality to be
      approachable and available to a large number of modern
      Western people.

      If you lose too much "persona" in this part of the world,
      you are not likely to be respected as a Teacher, but just
      end up homeless instead. There's a place for such extremism
      in India, but it is not part of our culture. That's okay,
      because I like it this way.

      Nonduality Salon Website
      Nonduality Salon Email Forum
      Nonduality Salon Chat
      Nonduality Salon List of Nondual People
      Encyclopedia of Nonduality
    Your message has been successfully submitted and would be delivered to recipients shortly.