Loading ...
Sorry, an error occurred while loading the content.

El-Farouk Khaki responds to Khaled Mouammar's criticism of the MCC

Expand Messages
  • Tarek fatah
    Friends, Last week, Khaled Mouammar, a prominent respected member of the Arab community wrote to Niaz Salimi, the President of the Muslim Canadian Congress: I
    Message 1 of 1 , Oct 4, 2005
    • 0 Attachment
      Friends,

      Last week, Khaled Mouammar, a prominent respected member of the Arab
      community wrote to Niaz Salimi, the President of the Muslim Canadian
      Congress:

      "I wish the MCC would spend less time criticizing other Muslim organizations
      and focus its energies on exposing the Islamophobia and the rising racism in
      Canadian society since 9/11."

      Khaled's message comes in the wake of a fairly widespread character
      assasination of the MCC. We are being portrayed as "Anti-Arab" simply
      because of our criticism of Islamists and Mohammed Elmasry. In addition, our
      criticism of an event where a visiting Syrian Minister was honoured by
      prominent Arab Canadians, is also being presented as evidence of our
      supposed anti-Arab nature.

      Our criticism of the Syrian Minister has rubbed some community leaders the
      wrong way. It seems they have not been able to understand their own
      contradiction of supporting Maher Arar's case on one hand and embracing his
      torturers on the other.

      When the MCC bashes the Iranian governement, no one says we are
      anti-Iranian. When we mock Musharraf, everyone cheers, but if we raise a
      finger at dictatorial Arab regimes, we are taken to task by the Islamists
      and their supposedly secular fans.

      Here is El-Farouk Khaki's response to Khaled Mouammar.

      Tarek
      ----------------------------

      Dear Khaled,

      Niaz Salimi, President of the MCC, forwarded your message to me in my
      capacity as Secretary General of the MCC.

      Dear friend, the premise of your argument is based on the false assumption
      that the MCC is NOT fighting racism.

      The fact is that most of us in the MCC are veterans in the fight against
      racism, homophobia and misogyny; not just for public consumption, but in our
      daily lives.

      The fight against racism does not mean we give up our fight against the most
      homophobic and misogynist groups in Canada. Those who consider women as
      second class citizens, destined forever to sit at the back of the mosques or
      tucked away in basements, will always have to face our criticism.

      Those who consider gays and lesbians worthy of contempt and deserving death
      punishment by stoning, can never be our friends, even if they are Muslims.

      The Left's love-affair with the fundamentalists Muslims can best be
      described as 'the fetishization of exotica'. For the non-Muslim Left, we,
      the MCC, are just not 'exotic' enough to fit their bill of 'progressiveness'
      and 'inclusivity' to be apparent.

      Under no circumstances would the MCC give up criticizing the Muslim
      Brotherhood and other fascist Muslim organisations.

      Just because an organisation is Muslim does not give them some blanket
      protection from critical analysis.

      We are not a group driven by a primitive sense of solidarity based on race
      and religion that propels us to cover up cover up hate, regardless of the
      perpatrators . Most of us come from a background of struggles involving
      human rights, women's rights and gay rights. Others have spent time in
      prisons for their socialist backgrounds and have faced these Islamofacists
      back home.

      Having said that, we all do our bit in fighting Islamophobia. You yourself
      have attended a number of MCC events and shoudl be intimately aware of this
      fact.

      At the same time, however, I believe too many men and women of intellect
      have allowed political Islam to rear its head and devour our societies.
      Others are using the term "Islamophobia" to cover their own hateful agendas.

      Sitting in the comfort of Canada, it is easy to relish Islamic
      fundamentalism as if it is an exotic enterprise.

      Too many - if not Muslim organisations in Canada are promoting sharia and
      social conservatism, bordering fanaticism.

      Instead of denegrating the MCC, I would have hoped that a person of your
      stature would have taken umbrage at the practise of labelling Muslims
      'murtud', accusing Muslims of 'apostasy'; a thinly veiled ncitement to
      commit violence against us.

      But I guess, since charges of apostasy would never adversely affect
      non-Muslims, I can appreciate if they cannot understand the veiled death
      threats that are part and parcel of this technique, which has roots in the
      teachings of Syed Qutb, Maududi and Khomeini.

      I am disturbed that the MCC is being portrayed as anti-Arab by self-serving
      Islamists, simply because we have the courage to attack those who play host
      to representatives of Arab dictators.

      Some of us may not be of Arab origin in the MCC, others are. But ours is not
      a tribal organisation where we defend Palestine purely because it is an Arab
      issue. When we marched in support of the Viet Cong, we didn't march because
      we were Vietnamese; we marched because we were humanists.

      I have spent the better part of my life fighting for Palestinian rights,
      without asking for anything in return. It is with pain and agony that I read
      the accusations that the MCC is anti-Arab. Those making such accusations
      should be ashamed of themselves. They do no service to the Arab or the
      Palestinian cause.

      They merely demonstrate the paucity of intellect that governs Arab discourse
      after the death of Edward Said.

      Perhaps some may wish to live under sharia and that is why they defend the
      proponents of sharia like Mohammad Elmasry. However, I don't. Our colleagues
      escaped sharia and witnessed the murders of tens of thousands by Ayatollah
      Khomeini, the Taliban and the Saudi regime.

      I would urge you to debate an argument based on its merits, not on the basis
      of the race or ethnicity of the people involved.

      Fighting racism, as you ask MCC to do, involves, as a first step,
      aggressively confronting racism within one's own community. I don't stand up
      for people simply because they are of Indian or African descent.

      I would hope you too would first and foremost stand up publicly against any
      expression of racism within our own communities before you ask others to
      work against it.

      Yours,

      El-Farouk Khaki
      Secretary General
      Muslim Canadian Congress
      e-mail: elfin925@...
    Your message has been successfully submitted and would be delivered to recipients shortly.