Loading ...
Sorry, an error occurred while loading the content.

924Re: [MexicoDNAProject] Updated DNA results

Expand Messages
  • Edward Romero
    Jan 19, 2014
      Hi, it looks like you have to contact FTDNA directly, they are the only ones that can answer your question. They have a contact box on their web site at the very right.
      I hope this helps  you. Ed

      On Sunday, January 19, 2014 9:27 AM, JOEL SR <hrjoel3@...> wrote:

      I suggest you read the article by Dr. Jonathan Marks and  Bret Lee Shelton tiled
      "Genetic "Markers"-Not a Valid Test of Native Identity".

      The theory that Native American genetic markers is not exclusive to Native Americans, but greater frequency.

      Mitochondrial analysis for Native American marker genes that the number of ancestors invisible to this test increases enormously.

      Y-chromosome analysis for Native American markers; this test only traces one line of ancestry and misses most of the subjects ancestry because the vast majority of the ancestors are invisible to the test.

      The test yield false negatives and the test also yield false positives. This especially interesting with the uncertainty because scientist have not tested all native people , so they do not know for sure that Native Americans only have the markers they have identified, if their maternal or fraternal  bloodline does not include a non-Indian.

      I think this would apply to other ethnicities as well as Native Americans.

      It is an interesting article that will make one think as to the accuracy of the how the DNA tests presently are and the objective conclusions made.

       Dr. Marks is a geneticist at University of North Carolina   
      From: "sangerjaime@..." <sangerjaime@...>
      To: MexicoDNAProject@yahoogroups.com
      Sent: Sunday, January 19, 2014 11:33 AM
      Subject: Re: [MexicoDNAProject] Updated DNA results
      Can some one tell me when FTDNA plans to update their Fact Finder and Population Finder tests?  I recently had both my wife and my mother in law tested by FTDNA and both of them came out with different population results, although they both are each others closest relative with 3600 cms.  So this in itself rules out that their vials were mixed up.  The big admixture discrepancy that has me scratching my head is that my wife (Mexican) shows 49.99 Western European, 20% Middle East, 30% Native American with no Russian admixture and my mother in law shows 60% Eastern European (Russian), 16.89% Middle East and 23.48% Native American? One would think if this is correct my spouse would at least show some Russian admixture.  I have come to understand that each parent contributes 50% , and that this 50% recombines unequally each time at conception.  However, these percentages tell me that FTDNA's data base or test appears to be either confused, antiquated and  needs to be updated........ Help anyone!!!

      Jaime Hernandez 

      -----Original Message-----From: Gregory Pisano <goyosan1@...>To: mexicodnaproject <mexicodnaproject@yahoogroups.com>Sent: Thu, Jan 16, 2014 8:10 pmSubject: [MexicoDNAProject] Updated DNA results
      My Family Tree Y-DNA test indicates my haplogroup as Q-M242. New 23andMe analysis indicates I am Q1a3*.  Can someone describe a comparison between the two and what the asterisk means?
      Gregory Pisaño
      (805) 748-5502

    • Show all 23 messages in this topic