JPost - Int'l groups say Israel not living up to Gaza promises
- JPost - Thu, Dec 2, 2010
The Jerusalem Post
Int'l groups say Israel not living up to Gaza promises
By DAN IZENBERG
Gov't responds: The claims of the organizations, as they appear in the
report, are biased and distorted and therefore mislead the public.
Five months after Israel promised to introduce measures to ease the
blockade of the Gaza Strip, there are few signs of real improvement on
the ground, 22 international human rights and humanitarian organizations
charged in a report issued early Tuesday morning.
While the report accused Israel of failing to fulfill the promises it
had made to relax the blockade, it argued at the same time that any
easing of restrictions would be insufficient and that the only solution
to the hardships of the Palestinian population was to lift it altogether.
“The ‘easing’ has left the foundations of the illegal blockade policy
intact,” the organizations charged. “In order to have a positive impact
on the daily lives of the 1.5 million Palestinians in Gaza, half of whom
are children, Israel must fully lift its blockade of the Gaza Strip.”
According to the report, Israel proposed to expand and accelerate the
influx of construction materials for international projects. In fact,
however, “it has so far only approved 7 percent of the building plan for
UNRWA’s projects in Gaza, and of that 7%, only a small fraction of the
necessary construction material has been allowed to enter for projects
including schools and health centers.”
As a result, the report charged, not a single one of the 25 projects is
currently being built.
The organizations pointed out that 40,000 children in Gaza were turned
away from UNRWA schools this past fall for lack of space in the existing
schools and UNRWA’s inability to build new ones.
As a result, the children must study in Hamas-run schools.
Israel promised to cancel the list of goods permitted to enter Gaza that
had been in force until June and replace it with an explicit list of
goods that are forbidden. As a result, imports, mainly food, have
increased from 20% to 35%.
However, the organizations charged, the list of forbidden goods extends
far beyond the international definition of dual-use items. Furthermore,
many of the items that are not on the forbidden list still require
special approval and many do not receive it.
Israel promised to expand the operations and capacity of the border
crossings into Gaza to enable processing of a significantly greater
volume of goods. According to the report, “the crossings’ operation is
still far from sufficient.”
For example, Israel said it would increase the number of trucks passing
through the Kerem Shalom crossing daily from 86 prior to the “ease,” to
250 in the first stage and to 400 later on. Today, an average of 183
trucks enter the crossing each day.
Israel promised to streamline entry and exit permits to Palestinian
civilians for humanitarian and medical reasons and to aid workers.
According to the report, the sweeping ban remains and the number of
permits granted is currently 1% of the level in 2000. Furthermore, the
number of permits approved for local UN humanitarian staff has dropped
in the past five months.
According to the report, the blockade is responsible for the situation
in which 80% of the Gaza population is dependent on international aid,
61% has no food security, the unemployment rate is 39%, 60% of the
population receives running water once every four or five days for six
to eight hours at a time, about 90% of the water supplied to Gaza
residents is unsuitable for drinking and 78% of the homes severely
damaged during Operation Cast Lead have not been rebuilt.
The organizations that published the report included Amnesty
International, Christian Aid, the Norwegian Refugee Council, Oxfam
International and Save the Children UK.
The spokesman for the Coordinator of Activities in the Territories
issued the following response to the charges.
“We regret the manner by which the organizations have chosen to present
their claims through the media, without providing Israel with the
opportunity to respond to the report.
“The claims of the organizations, as they appear in the report, are
biased and distorted and therefore mislead the public. The changes in
the civilian situation in the Gaza Strip are clearly described in
reports carried out by international organizations, for example, the
World Monetary Fund, the Summary of the AHLC Conference and during
official visits to Israel by figures such as Special Envoy to the Middle
East Senator George Mitchell; Envoy of the Quartet Sir Tony Blair; and
High Representative for Foreign Affairs of the European Union Catherine
“Israel is fully committed to implementing civilian policy toward the
Gaza Strip as decided by the Israeli cabinet in June 2010. The
implementation will continue with the coordination and cooperation of
the international community and the involvement of the PA.
“Israel will not allow any party with a hidden agenda to disrupt the
process to which both the government of Israel and the international
community are fully committed.”
Despite the descriptions in the report, it is important to highlight
that since the cabinet’s decision, the number of truckloads entering the
Gaza Strip everyday via the Kerem Shalom crossing has increased by 92%.
Though Israel has increased the capacity so that 250 trucks can enter
Gaza every day, the Palestinians themselves are not yet able to handle
this volume. From the beginning of August, the average number of
truckloads entering Gaza each day stands at 176.
Meanwhile, exports from the Gaza Strip are intrinsically connected to
security and logistical concerns at the Kerem Shalom crossing.
Israel has therefore started a process of infrastructure renovation and
development with the aim of widening the capacity of the crossing. This
process should be finished by the middle of 2011.
Regarding the claims about the prevention of building material from
entering the Gaza Strip, it is important to note that in accordance with
the security cabinet decision, building material for specified projects
that were approved by the PA can enter under the supervision of the
The simple reason for this is to prevent the trickling of material into
the Gaza Strip that can be used by terrorist organizations for hostile
activities or other military purposes.
Since the cabinet decision Israel has approved 64 new projects, in
addition to 14 that were approved prior to June 2010 – 26 of them were
approved for UNRWA. To date, 1,052 truckloads of building material have