Jerusalem and Religions Who’s minding the mosque?
- Jerusalem and Religions
Who’s minding the mosque?
New freedoms, differing standards amid the Arab Spring complicates the
job of government censors monitoring mosque sermons.
Whether as a conduit for government policy or the headquarters for
insurgencies, mosques have always played an important political role in
political events. But the Arab Spring is playing havoc with the simple
rules that once prevailed and complicating the jobs of government
On Sunday, the Kuwaiti daily Al-Watan reported that preachers who speak
out against Syrian President Bashar Assad are bring arrested, whereas
sermons targeting the Libyan dictator Muammar Gaddafi are permitted and
even encouraged. "This is a political decision," an unnamed source in
Kuwait’s Ministry of Religious Endowments told the daily. "The
Endowments Ministry receives its orders from the Foreign Ministry."
Friday sermons are the linchpin of the weekly service, when Muslims
gather in the mosque for communal prayer. The preacher, or khatib, is
often a government appointee – subject to censorship or pushed to
self-censorship. The outbreak of the Arab Spring has upset the system,
enabling preachers to speak freely in some countries while in others
upsetting the messages governments want the faithful to hear.
Although mosques have often taken a backseat to Facebook and other
social media in many countries this year, for many in the Arab world the
Internet isn’t accessible and politics is governed by religions. For
activists in Syria, where the government has shut down communications,
the mosques have taken on their traditional role.
But the government, which is struggling to quell widening protests
across the country against the regime, still tries to keep sermons on
message. When US Ambassador Robert Ford angered Damascus by visiting the
rebel stronghold of Hama earlier this month, Syria’s preachers were
ready with a response.
They denounced the ambassador’s visit without prior permission, calling
it interference in Syria’s internal affairs, according to the
state-controlled Syrian Arab News Agency. In his Friday sermon at
Damascus’ historic Umayyad Mosque, Sheikh Mohammad Said Ramadan Al-Bouti
warned against foreign interference in the events witnessed in Syria,
stressing that the Koran warns against making mistakes during such
critical times. Some ignore these warnings, he was reported to have said.
In Saudi Arabia, which sees itself as a bulwark against the change
taking place in the Arab world, government-appointed clerics have
condemned Arab demonstrations as un-Islamic acts of rebellion against
leaders. But even that has changed this year to some extent.
"Preachers follow the government line," Abdullah Jaber, a Saudi
political cartoonist, told The Media Line. "I don’t remember Arab
revolutions ever mentioned in Friday sermons."
The Saudi government has remained silent on demonstrations in Syria and
Bahrain, Jaber added, and as a consequence mosque preachers have
remained silent as well. The exception to that rule, he said, is Libya.
"During the Tunisian revolution no one spoke, nor during the Egyptian
revolution. But when Libya revolted, the Imam began speaking about the
citizens of Misrata and the oppression applied against the protesters."
In Jordan, where King Abdullah has faced increasing vociferous protests
against corruption and the absence of democracy, preachers must be
authorized by Jordan’s General Intelligence Directorate (GID), and the
text of Friday’s sermon must be sent to the Ministry of Endowments ahead
of time. So far, the government hasn’t relaxed its stricture.
"Generally speaking, political sermons are banned in Jordan," Fatima
Al-Smadi, a Jordanian media professor and columnist for the daily
Al-Arab Al-Yawm, told The Media Line. "The Ministry of Endowments, which
controls the mosques, won’t allow it."
Jordan didn’t always exercise such tight control over sermons, Smadi
said. That began to change after the 9/11 attacks on the World Trade
Center created worries about Islamic fundamentalists. She said that
historically Muslim Brotherhood preachers dominated mosque pulpits, but
today they are almost completely absent. The clampdown has intensified
over the past five years, but Smadi said it has done little to affect
"Most Jordanians supported the revolutions in Egypt and Tunisia, but the
Friday sermons opposed them, arguing they caused fitna (social chaos),"
she said. "What is said on the pulpit does not represent the majority of
Kuwait, an oil-rich Gulf emirate so far unscathed by social unrest
experienced in other Arab countries, controls mosque sermons through its
Ministry of Religious Endowments and Islamic Affairs. In 2009, the
government published a "Mosque Charter" outlining the role of the mosque
in society, and that of its leader, the imam.
"The imam must maintain an atmosphere of submission, calm and peace in
the mosque. He must not allow any activity that arouses disunity or
confusion, corrupting the spirit of submission. He should not discuss
matters he does not understand," the charter reads.
Nabil Al-Awadi, a well known Kuwaiti preacher, was recently expelled
from the pulpit for four months after criticizing the Syrian president
in violation of the Mosque Charter, local media reported this week.
But in Egypt, where popular demonstrations succeeded in toppling former
president Husni Mubarak last February, preachers have found new
freedoms, Ali Khafagy, a youth leader in Egypt’s Muslim Brotherhood,
told The Media Line.
"In the past, sermons in Egypt used to be purely religious, with no one
but the Muslim Brotherhood talking about politics," he said. "Today,
politics is the rule in mosques rather than the exception."
Khafagy said every large mosque in Egypt used to have "supervisors" who
would inform the government of the content of Friday sermons, with
erring imams subject to arrest and torture.
"Today everyone can say anything about any leader," he added. "The
revolution has changed a lot, especially in terms of freedom of speech."
Source : By DAVID E. MILLER, THE MEDIA LINE, July 26, /2011
Wednesday 27 July 2011