Loading ...
Sorry, an error occurred while loading the content.

Hudna is a Palestinian affair

Expand Messages
  • Paul
    Sun., Jun. 1, 2003 Ha`aretz Hudna is a Palestinian affair By Zvi Bar el http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/pages/ShArt.jhtml?itemNo=298861 Hudna has become such a
    Message 1 of 1 , Jun 1, 2003
    • 0 Attachment
      Sun., Jun. 1, 2003 Ha`aretz
      Hudna is a Palestinian affair By Zvi Bar'el

      Hudna has become such a household word that soon we will probably hear of
      hudna ice cream in five flavors and that the hudna furniture store will be
      open on Saturdays too. Hudna is a well-known process in tribal law: It's the
      stage at which the heads of feuding families decide to halt the chase for
      bloody vengeance temporarily until a peace agreement is achieved between
      them - a sulha. If a sulha is not reached, the hudna is voided and the
      vendetta is resumed.

      When Palestinian Prime Minister Mahmoud Abbas is asked if he managed to
      achieve a hudna with Hamas and Islamic Jihad, he replies that an agreement
      to this effect has not been signed yet, but that there are talks and
      understandings. A senior Hamas representative, Ismail Abu Shnab, said that
      "if Abu Mazen reaches an agreement with Israel, we will not embarrass him."
      In other words, Hamas will give Abbas a chance to reach an agreement. The
      hudna is therefore perceived, rightfully, as an internal Palestinian affair.

      Achieving the hudna is not and should not be an Israeli demand. Israel is
      not and should not be negotiating separately with Hamas or Islamic Jihad, or
      any other organization that is not the Palestinian Authority. Abbas is not
      being tested for his ability to mediate between Israel and these
      organizations. They are his problem. The principle he is acting on - "one
      authority and one strong Palestinian army" - is proof that he acknowledges

      This principle already encompasses what Israel calls "war against the terror
      infrastructure." To implement it, Israel will probably have to give up the
      spectacle of Palestinian brigades killing Hamas activists and demolishing
      their houses as proof of war on the "infrastructure." This was a deceptive
      spectacle anyway, not only because it does not guarantee success, and Israel
      can testify to that, but because it is the last thing Israel should be
      interested in, if only for purely security reasons - a Palestinian civil

      A ruling authority wishing to gain broad legitimacy from its own public does
      not destroy the homes of its people. Hamas and Islamic Jihad are not a
      foreign body in the Palestinian society. Although they hold a radical
      pan-Islamic ideology, they are, first and foremost, Palestinian

      Therefore, the dialogue with those organizations that Abbas speaks of is, in
      fact, one of the correct ways of fighting terror - neutralizing their
      motivation to sabotage the PA's political moves, for national reasons.

      Abbas wishes to achieve this goal by creating circumstances for the advent
      of Palestinian public pressure against whoever obstructs the idea of the
      Palestinian state, rehabilitating its economy and building its civilian
      society - hence, the great importance that Abbas attributes to the release
      of detainees, to giving Palestinians permits to work in Israel and to
      rehabilitating the economy.

      These are not merely personal achievements he wishes to score, but a formula
      that can deprive the extreme organizations of the mainstream's legitimacy to
      continue the terrorist attacks.

      Such public pressure has already proved itself in a few other places. The
      Lebanese public began applying similar pressure on Hezbollah after Israel's
      withdrawal; the Egyptian public has denounced the radical organizations; and
      when the Oslo agreement was still valid, the Palestinian public in Gaza
      acted against Hamas' attempt to dictate a radical religious way of life.

      Such public pressure, which followed the Israel Defense Forces' strong-arm
      policy in the territories, gave legitimacy to Abbas' appointment and to his
      political conception - that the violent intifada must be dropped in favor of
      a political struggle.

      This is the first Palestinian attempt to translate the intifada into a
      political victory for the Palestinians and to get out of a dead-end
      predicament. Israel must support this endeavor if it really intends to fight
      the "terror infrastructure."
    Your message has been successfully submitted and would be delivered to recipients shortly.