Loading ...
Sorry, an error occurred while loading the content.
 

The army's kashrut stamp

Expand Messages
  • MEW
    The army s kashrut stamp http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/458089.html By Nehemia Strasler A document dealing with the ethics of fighting terror recently
    Message 1 of 1 , Aug 1, 2004
      The army's kashrut stamp
      http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/458089.html
      By Nehemia Strasler

      A document dealing with the ethics of fighting terror recently reached the
      chief of staff's desk. The document was written by Professor Asa Kasher and
      a team of officers, lawyers and advisors.

      The authors produced a remarkable document, which says that force should
      not be used against terror unless it is necessary to protect the citizens
      of the state. The document makes it the soldiers' responsibility to protect
      the security of Palestinians who are not involved in terror and to warn the
      Palestinians in advance when necessary so that they are not harmed.

      The document states that the army may not exact vengeance or punishment; it
      may only defend the citizens of the state. Therefore, no closures or
      curfews should be imposed on civilian populations as punishment and no
      trees should be uprooted or houses demolished for the purpose of revenge.
      Furthermore, when deciding on a military action in the territories, the
      army must take into account the negative impact that killing and
      destruction will have on local and international public opinion.

      Read it and weep. What army are they talking about? To which reality are
      they referring? How impervious can they be? A week does not go by without
      innocent Palestinians, whether men, women or children, being killed. Not a
      week goes by without houses being demolished, trees being uprooted,
      humiliation and abuse at the checkpoints. But the chief of staff is silent,
      and so is the prime minister. Do they need a document to tell them what is
      kosher and what is not?

      The brutality of the occupation did not begin yesterday, but it sometimes
      escalates a level. The troubling images that emerged in mid-May from the
      miserable refugee camp of Rafah shocked anyone in the world with a
      conscience. That Israel Defense Forces operation killed 52 Palestinians -
      some of them innocent civilians, including two teens whose only crime was
      feeding their pigeons on the roof. If the public has grown used to the
      killing, it will evidently also grow used to the house demolitions: the
      little children leaving their homes with bags on their back, the
      shell-shocked old women searching in the rubble of their homes in an effort
      to save something - an old jacket, a notebook, a photo.

      On July 12, Ibrahim Halfalla, a wheelchair-bound father of seven, was
      crushed to death under the rubble of his house. It happened when the IDF
      demolished his house in Khan Yunis in the middle of the night. The soldiers
      did not check to find out whether someone was at home - and the bulldozer
      buried the man alive. That same week, published photos taken at the Hawara
      checkpoint showed a soldier handcuffing a Palestinian and then beating him
      in front of his wife and two children. Their only crime was wanting to get
      home.

      A week earlier, on July 6, Dr. Khaled Salah, a lecturer in electrical
      engineering at A-Najah University, was killed in his home by snipers. His
      16-year-old son, Mohammed, was also shot and lay on the floor of the family
      apartment for hours before dying. When the mother shouted to the soldiers
      that her son was still alive and they should let an ambulance through, they
      laughed in her face while her son bled to death in front of her. Not only
      was the family not involved in terror, Khaled Salah was a member of the
      university's Palestine-Israel peace committee. And as if that were not
      enough, after the murder, the soldiers entered the house and destroyed what
      remained. They shot at clothing, towels, books, the television, the
      computer, the refrigerator and thoroughly vandalized the apartment. And
      these were not "problematic" soldiers, but the elite of the elite, the
      naval commandos, exacting vengeance on innocent civilians because one of
      their officers was killed in the operation. They apparently did not have
      time to read the document on ethics.

      The IDF has rampaged through Beit Hanun over the past month. Soldiers march
      into residential apartments, turn them into forts and expel the tenants.
      Last Thursday, a bulldozer demolished a packing house that was used by
      1,000 farmers, for no reason. Just like that, out of an evil desire for
      vengeance. Everything was demolished. The sorting machinery, the washing
      and packing machinery, the refrigerators, the packing material. A thousand
      farmers were left unemployed.

      These acts of destruction (which are prohibited by the document) only raise
      the walls of hatred higher and make the conflict insoluble, because every
      teenager whose home has been demolished and whose parents have been
      humiliated will want to take his own vengeance - and then we will say there
      is nobody to talk to. An army and state that behave in such an immoral
      way - harming civilians, demolishing, taking vengeance on the innocent - do
      not deter the other side, but strengthen it, and particularly its
      extremists. Harming the innocent proves that it is not worthwhile to be
      moderate: Either way, the bullet or the bulldozer will get them.

      Such actions weaken Israel's position in the world and endanger the
      existence of the state. Israel depends on international public opinion, and
      certainly on American public opinion. Such actions erode the public's own
      resilience, increase emigration from Israel and weaken the army - because
      without a moral justification, even the most well-equipped army in the
      world cannot win.
    Your message has been successfully submitted and would be delivered to recipients shortly.