Loading ...
Sorry, an error occurred while loading the content.

Re: [Marbling] Paper in Turkey

Expand Messages
  • irisnevins
    Susanne....just so you know, two years ago and maybe up to 1 1/2 years ago, the German paper I was using, particularly Hahnemuelle Natur Text, yes, it was
    Message 1 of 13 , Feb 20, 2011
    View Source
    • 0 Attachment
      Susanne....just so you know, two years ago and maybe up to 1 1/2 years ago, the German paper I was using, particularly Hahnemuelle Natur Text, yes, it was buffered, and it did work just fine. It was buffered. The problem is TOO MUCH buffering agent. Via my distributor, we had a three way dialog going on for a good while, and it was determined that at that point they started using MORE buffering agent, calcium carbonate. The PH had gong up to 8+ too. I wouldn't exactly say a paper cannot be buffered at all, but it can reach archival standards by being buffered just enough to make it archival, not further. Why they went further, who knows. They said it is what it is now, in effect. I could have a whole run made or the old formula, which would amount to 44,000 sheets. I would get a test sheet, or a few sheets of varying amounts. They will not make an unbuffered paper. The issues with that, is as I mentioned....how do I know I am going to get exactly what the test sheets were. What if someone was tired that day and threw in too much CC. This isn't something you can see. The costs for that much paper plus the shipping was prohibitive. Plus I'd worry about storage. Or damage. I really can't risk it.

      We will figure it out I am certain, and marbling will continue, it's just very frustrating. I make my own paints too, and have tweaked the formulas, which are different for each pigment, in hopes it may alter the adhesion, which it didn't. The natural earth colors adhere better than others to any paper, and sometimes if I were to use just some ochres and a lamp black I can use overbuffered paper and it stays on. The other issue, with the thousands of sheets of Classic Linen I still have from the batch after they started to over CC it, is that using so much of the CC, in place of wood pulp or other ingredients, is that it shortens the fibers of the papers and they tear easily on the line when wet or with handling.

      French Paper Company http://www.frenchpaper.com/Index.asp<http://www.frenchpaper.com/Index.asp> makes buffered papers that actually work. their 19 X 25 Durotone works well, sometimes even without Alum, esp. earth colors. Their 70lb text weight however is very thin, more than other 70lb I have ever had. the next step up is too heavy. I have the ivory and it does work, you have to handle it carefully when you alum though, it can crease up if you sponge it. I think it will be less a problem in this weight in a smaller sheet honestly but my customers want a large sheet. Other than that it works well. http://www.frenchpaper.com/results.asp?cat=35<http://www.frenchpaper.com/results.asp?cat=35> is the link to Durotne. They will send a sample book and you can try the swatches. nice colors too. Always, after you find anything works, ask for test sheets, even if you have to pay for them, and insist, in writing, they are from current inventory that will be shipped to you, and also in writing, that if it behaves differently than the test sheets you can return it. Not just for French, but for all paper companies. I don't trust them to understand marbling, they really don't get it, so you have to cover yourself.

      There also seems to be no amount of alum that overtakes the CC either. I have looked into using inkjet coating instead, but it is very pricey!! I found a recipe to make it too at home, and it failed to help and ruined the size.

      Iris Nevins
      www.marblingpaper.com<http://www.marblingpaper.com/>

      ----- Original Message -----
      From: hamburgerbuntpapier_de<mailto:studio@...>
      To: Marbling@yahoogroups.com<mailto:Marbling@yahoogroups.com>
      Sent: Sunday, February 20, 2011 4:13 AM
      Subject: [Marbling] Paper in Turkey


      Two years ago, Hikmet Barutcugil was invited to the Frankfurt Book Fair to demonstrate ebru. I sent him several papers from my stock to test, and he opted for a European paper that answers to German archival standards, meaning amongst others that it is buffered. He worked with it without alum and everything was perfect. Several of the sheets he made during the fair, basics as well as flowers, are still in my hands and have been used ever since for lectures and courses, they behave perfectly well although they are handled all the time.

      My non-marblers rationality says that it cannot be the paper alone evoking problems, there must be something in the other materials, too; namely in the way the paints are prepared. Hikmet makes all his own paints, and in the traditional Turkish way. He brought his tools, paints and powdered size (not the usual tragacantha, though) along, the water was ordinary Frankfurt tap water, the paper made in Germany and bought in Hamburg from my main supplier.

      Susanne Krause

      P.S. I don't read Turkish, but from all I know Ebru Sanati means The Art of Ebru.





      ------------------------------------

      Yahoo! Groups Links





      [Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
    • jemiljan
      A reply to Susanne... ... Two years ago, Hikmet Barutcugil was invited to the Frankfurt Book Fair to demonstrate ebru. I sent him several papers from my stock
      Message 2 of 13 , Feb 20, 2011
      View Source
      • 0 Attachment
        A reply to Susanne...

        --- In Marbling@yahoogroups.com, "hamburgerbuntpapier_de" <studio@...> wrote:

        "Two years ago, Hikmet Barutcugil was invited to the Frankfurt Book Fair to demonstrate ebru. I sent him several papers from my stock to test, and he opted for a European paper that answers to German archival standards, meaning amongst others that it is buffered."

        Buffered, yes, but was that paper merely buffered with a small percentage of calcium carbonate? Or was it loaded with PCC fillers as so many papers here in the US? I referring to papers loaded with PCC fillers, which is what Iris has been describing, which contain more calcium than actual pulp!

        "He worked with it without alum and everything was perfect. Several of the sheets he made during the fair, basics as well as flowers, are still in my hands and have been used ever since for lectures and courses, they behave perfectly well although they are handled all the time."

        Yet if you were to rub the colors directly, are they truly fixed? I rather doubt this, as I have many papers in my own collections, including those made by Hikmet, and they are not so durable. Gentle handling is one thing, abrasion resistance- a real durability test-is another. While they are not immediately friable and "falling off" the sheet, they are also not totally fixed the way a mordanted paper is.

        "My non-marblers rationality says that it cannot be the paper alone evoking problems, there must be something in the other materials, too; namely in the way the paints are prepared. Hikmet makes all his own paints, and in the traditional Turkish way. He brought his tools, paints and powdered size (not the usual tragacantha, though) along, the water was ordinary Frankfurt tap water, the paper made in Germany and bought in Hamburg from my main supplier."

        Yes, these are factor. As I mentioned, the tragacanth contains polysaccharides that form a more complex network adhering the pigment particles, in conjunction with the thickened form of gall. Iron oxides adhere very well in the process. The "lahuri çivit", which is really a synthetic indigo dye, also bonds well... to a point. They do not have the durability of papers that are mordanted. Again, historically speaking in Turkey (and Iran India, and elsewhere) if the papers were to be used for bookbinding and calligraphy, they were routinely coated with ahar solution and then burnished.

        Jake
      • hamburgerbuntpapier_de
        Jake- got out the papers, licked my finger, wiped: everything okay. No time now to call the firm and find out which additive they use. Susanne
        Message 3 of 13 , Feb 20, 2011
        View Source
        • 0 Attachment
          Jake-

          got out the papers, licked my finger, wiped: everything okay.

          No time now to call the firm and find out which additive they use.

          Susanne
        • irisnevins
          what paper is it. Why lick and wipe...is that something for paste paper? If it is older stock of Hahnemuelle for example, the newer paper may be different. I
          Message 4 of 13 , Feb 21, 2011
          View Source
          • 0 Attachment
            what paper is it. Why lick and wipe...is that something for paste paper?

            If it is older stock of Hahnemuelle for example, the newer paper may be different. I suspect paste paper will work where marbling won't. At least Hahnemuelle will speak to you and give you information! Others in my experience will not. My finding is that when it was about PH7.5 it worked, when it went closer to PH8 it didn't.

            Iris Nevins
            www.marblingpaper.com<http://www.marblingpaper.com/>

            ----- Original Message -----
            From: hamburgerbuntpapier_de<mailto:studio@...>
            To: Marbling@yahoogroups.com<mailto:Marbling@yahoogroups.com>
            Sent: Monday, February 21, 2011 2:51 AM
            Subject: [Marbling] Re: Paper in Turkey


            Jake-

            got out the papers, licked my finger, wiped: everything okay.

            No time now to call the firm and find out which additive they use.

            Susanne




            ------------------------------------

            Yahoo! Groups Links





            [Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
          • hamburgerbuntpapier_de
            Lick and wipe is the hard test for any colour that s meant to stay on the paper when required to, nothing special for paste paper, and anyway I did it with one
            Message 5 of 13 , Feb 21, 2011
            View Source
            • 0 Attachment
              Lick and wipe is the hard test for any colour that's meant to stay on the paper when required to, nothing special for paste paper, and anyway I did it with one of Hikmet's (to prove that the colours stay on the paper indeed, no matter what Jake says).

              And no, it's not Hahnemühle. I've stopped using Hahnemühle years ago, too heavy, too voluminous, too stiff, doesn't agree with sprinkled papers.

              If you're interested I can ask my supplier about a dealer in USA.

              Susanne Krause
            • irisnevins
              Hi Susanne... we all used to do the tongue test, which in my first book I believe I recommended, if it stuck a bit, the paper nearly always worked. Things in
              Message 6 of 13 , Feb 21, 2011
              View Source
              • 0 Attachment
                Hi Susanne... we all used to do the tongue test, which in my first book I believe I recommended, if it stuck a bit, the paper nearly always worked. Things in marbling are not so simple anymore. the only test like that I can use now, is after aluming, does the paper taste sweet. If not, it has been neutralized and the color will nearly always run. I'd try any paper anywhere at this point! I would need a 19 X 25 preferably long grain sheet about 70-80lb text weight. Would appreciate it...you can email me privately if you like...though others may like to know!

                I still am confused on lick and wipe. Do you paint the paper first, then lick and wipe, or is it just the plain paper before any paint on it? If no paint is one, what do we look for the lick and wipe to do?

                thanks,

                Iris Nevins
                www.marblingpaper.com<http://www.marblingpaper.com/>
                ----- Original Message -----
                From: hamburgerbuntpapier_de<mailto:studio@...>
                To: Marbling@yahoogroups.com<mailto:Marbling@yahoogroups.com>
                Sent: Monday, February 21, 2011 11:11 AM
                Subject: [Marbling] Re: Paper in Turkey/for Iris


                Lick and wipe is the hard test for any colour that's meant to stay on the paper when required to, nothing special for paste paper, and anyway I did it with one of Hikmet's (to prove that the colours stay on the paper indeed, no matter what Jake says).

                And no, it's not Hahnemühle. I've stopped using Hahnemühle years ago, too heavy, too voluminous, too stiff, doesn't agree with sprinkled papers.

                If you're interested I can ask my supplier about a dealer in USA.

                Susanne Krause




                ------------------------------------

                Yahoo! Groups Links





                [Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
              • jemiljan
                Susanne... It seems you are fortunate to possess what is my experience, exceptional examples. Should you ever visit me, I would be happy to show you the many
                Message 7 of 13 , Feb 21, 2011
                View Source
                • 0 Attachment
                  Susanne... It seems you are fortunate to possess what is my experience, exceptional examples. Should you ever visit me, I would be happy to show you the many papers I've collected from Turkey over the years, and why I must keep them in archival sleeves, in order to prevent their smudging. It seems to me that whatever paper you gave to Hikmet is likely a better quality one, and so the marbling adhered better to those sheets than the examples of his work that I obtained in Turkey. Maybe you could share with us just what that paper is? It may be a useful tip for all of us.

                  Yes, the colors can adhere better to an non-mordanted paper if thinly applied (the paler background of a flower, for example); and if the paper is well made, with good fiber, and little (if any) buffer, as Iris mentioned). Incidentally, Halfer describes why pigments adhere without alum in his chapter on Tragacanth in "Die Fortschritte...", and much as Iris noted, he specifically mentions that earth colors are especially conducive. That said, most all of the densely saturated patterned papers (standard battals, gelgits, and so on) that I obtained in Turkey from many different marblers do have a certain tendency to smear, including earth colors, and it seems to me that the quality of the paper is a major factor. Older papers executed on handmade or mould-made sheets - even those which are not coated with the traditional Ahar- do not seem to exhibit this problem. Then again, even when using a mordanted paper, indigo has a tendency to smudge, a problem that I believe Iris can describe in detail.

                  Jake

                  --- In Marbling@yahoogroups.com, "hamburgerbuntpapier_de" <studio@...> wrote:
                  >
                  > Jake-
                  >
                  > got out the papers, licked my finger, wiped: everything okay.
                  >
                  > No time now to call the firm and find out which additive they use.
                  >
                  > Susanne
                  >
                • irisnevins
                  Jake we could go on forever on this. I love traditional styled marbling and much of my life has been devoted to it, but I will not be a slave to tradition when
                  Message 8 of 13 , Feb 21, 2011
                  View Source
                  • 0 Attachment
                    Jake we could go on forever on this. I love traditional styled marbling and much of my life has been devoted to it, but I will not be a slave to tradition when something works better. Indigo is one example. Yes it smears, even when I treat it like other pigments I make paints from. All the chemical "why" about it didn't concern me as much as the "how" to make it work, and I couldn't. I had a few annoyed customers at one point over it and it was terribly embarrassing too. So I make a similar color from black and blue. Close enough, no smear. People think I am a purist, but don't make me give up my plastic squeeze bottles!!

                    As for paper I learned something very distressing today in a long ongoing email dialog with a papermaker I have been having, who may prefer to not be named. Recycled paper... good, green, cool, wonderful... well....maybe not for us. Did you ever get a batch of paper that was recycled, and it worked. You order again, the color comes off. You order yet another time, it works again. Why... the papers they recycle FROM, there is no telling how much calcium carbonate is in them. They come from many different makers. Thus, there is NO CONTROL over the amount of the dreadful stuff is in each particular batch of recyclable material they get in. Pretty scary.... I said "now I've heard everything". What next. So I was advised to never recommend a recycled paper for marbling at all, because of this inconsistency. It makes me think way back to Ink & Gall days, Jake, if you recall...I did an article on recyled paper....and this was over 20 years ago. My feeling was that all the papers I tested were sub-par and basically said I didn't care how cool it was to recycle, I wouldn't use them. Well.... some of us know what happened next but I was not writing for the magazine anymore after that. We'll leave that one go!

                    I have learned to allow myself a backlog of 800-1000 sheets of paper that work, so I can function while looking for yet another paper. I am very intrigued by the inkjet coatings, and that you can skip the alum. Has to be the best quality. I have not bothered to try the larger sizes than 11 X 14 I think... I suspect the light weight at 18 X 24 with make it rip when wet. It's not cheap. Talas paper is good, but I still want to find a solution of some sort in general if there is one. I have thousands of sheets of paper that used to work, and then I received buffered cartons. No notice, not that they should care so much about marblers.

                    What I need to do when there is time (laugh track inserted) is buy a bottle of the coating and see if it can be diluted down to watery, and used like alum, and see if I can use up the darned 2000+ buffered papers I was not allowed to return over the past five years! Maybe someday!

                    Well.... tired of thinking about this today.
                    Iris Nevins
                    www.marblingpaper.com<http://www.marblingpaper.com/>


                    ----- Original Message -----
                    From: jemiljan<mailto:jemiljan@...>
                    To: Marbling@yahoogroups.com<mailto:Marbling@yahoogroups.com>
                    Sent: Monday, February 21, 2011 10:57 PM
                    Subject: [Marbling] Re: Paper in Turkey


                    Susanne... It seems you are fortunate to possess what is my experience, exceptional examples. Should you ever visit me, I would be happy to show you the many papers I've collected from Turkey over the years, and why I must keep them in archival sleeves, in order to prevent their smudging. It seems to me that whatever paper you gave to Hikmet is likely a better quality one, and so the marbling adhered better to those sheets than the examples of his work that I obtained in Turkey. Maybe you could share with us just what that paper is? It may be a useful tip for all of us.

                    Yes, the colors can adhere better to an non-mordanted paper if thinly applied (the paler background of a flower, for example); and if the paper is well made, with good fiber, and little (if any) buffer, as Iris mentioned). Incidentally, Halfer describes why pigments adhere without alum in his chapter on Tragacanth in "Die Fortschritte...", and much as Iris noted, he specifically mentions that earth colors are especially conducive. That said, most all of the densely saturated patterned papers (standard battals, gelgits, and so on) that I obtained in Turkey from many different marblers do have a certain tendency to smear, including earth colors, and it seems to me that the quality of the paper is a major factor. Older papers executed on handmade or mould-made sheets - even those which are not coated with the traditional Ahar- do not seem to exhibit this problem. Then again, even when using a mordanted paper, indigo has a tendency to smudge, a problem that I believe Iris can describe
                    in detail.

                    Jake

                    --- In Marbling@yahoogroups.com<mailto:Marbling@yahoogroups.com>, "hamburgerbuntpapier_de" <studio@...> wrote:
                    >
                    > Jake-
                    >
                    > got out the papers, licked my finger, wiped: everything okay.
                    >
                    > No time now to call the firm and find out which additive they use.
                    >
                    > Susanne
                    >




                    ------------------------------------

                    Yahoo! Groups Links





                    [Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
                  • hamburgerbuntpapier_de
                    Sorry for this, I hit the send key by accident. I can only second this: never use recycled paper for quality work. Recycling is an honourable and most
                    Message 9 of 13 , Feb 22, 2011
                    View Source
                    • 0 Attachment
                      Sorry for this, I hit the send key by accident.


                      I can only second this: never use recycled paper for quality work. Recycling is an honourable and most necessary task but it has its limits. Professional paper decorating beyond short living items such as gift wrappers is one of them.

                      And I'm also seconding this: For reconstruction work, we need to reconstruct an impression, and we need to do this with materials answering to state-of-the-art archival and restoration requirements. It is most interesting to know what was used for the
                      original and definitely very important for restoration/conservation and research. However, it is not what counts in reconstruction. Everything we can use today is 200 or 300 years younger than the original. Even if we go and dig coloured earth in the same place, the earth cannot be the same. I'm afraid it's wishful thinking that by the simple method of using some material with the original name we can get closer to the original product.

                      As to paper: all my papers are made in Europe. I phoned around but none of my suppliers has a branch in the Americas. Sending paper overseas is always possible (and they're ready to do it if required) but costs a small fortune.

                      Susanne Krause
                    • irisnevins
                      Thanks for checking Susanne! Iris Nevins www.marblingpaper.com ... From:
                      Message 10 of 13 , Feb 22, 2011
                      View Source
                      • 0 Attachment
                        Thanks for checking Susanne!
                        Iris Nevins
                        www.marblingpaper.com<http://www.marblingpaper.com/>
                        ----- Original Message -----
                        From: hamburgerbuntpapier_de<mailto:studio@...>
                        To: Marbling@yahoogroups.com<mailto:Marbling@yahoogroups.com>
                        Sent: Tuesday, February 22, 2011 4:33 AM
                        Subject: [Marbling] Re: Paper in Turkey, last input from Hamburg



                        I can only second this: never use recycled paper for quality work.

                        And also this: For reconstruction work, we need to reconstruct an impression, and we need to do this with materials answering to state-of-the-art archival and restoration requirements. It is most interesting to know what was used for the original and definitely very important for restoration/conservation and research. However, it is not what counts in reconstruction. Everything we can use today is 200 or 300 years older than the original. Even if we go and dig coloured earth in the same place, the earth cannot be the same. I'm afraid it's wishful thinking that by the simple method of using something with the same label we can get closer to the original.

                        As to paper: all my papers are made in Europe. I phoned around but none of my suppliers has a branch in the Americas. Sending paper overseas is always possible (and they're ready to do it if required) but costs a small fortune.

                        Susanne Krause




                        ------------------------------------

                        Yahoo! Groups Links





                        [Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
                      Your message has been successfully submitted and would be delivered to recipients shortly.