Re: Marbling Q & A
- Dear Susanne,
Thanks for you taking the time to read the Q & A, and to post your comments. I should
mention in response that it is a constant struggle for me to be inclusive of others who DO
NOT work on paper, or create "decorated papers" as I do. I find that definition too narrow,
though it is my own "natural" focus, working in the conservation and restoration of books.
I often see in some of the criiticism posted that some compare "apples to oranges".
Knowing the intent, context, and application makes all the difference. I'm looking to build
bridges here, not burn them!
That said, I would welcome others to post their thoughts on what I've posted and these
comments. I'm not trying to be unreasonable, nor an absolutist. Nor am I trying to
denigrate "craft", becuase I prefer to use "Fine Craft" to describe what I do. Yet I do see
that "craft" is one facet of this method, in my own humble opininon.
Additionally, I it helps to provide constructive, objective criticism, and provide suggestions
for alternative wording. Several have done so off-list already, as I did have many
grammatical and a few spelling errors. I probably should have slept on it before posting.
That said, it's a rough draft, and I posted it here simply becuase I knew that it would help
all of us to think about how we define marbling.
So, I think I should change it to say that "marbling is a method of surface design".
Would that be a more acceptable term that cogently describes this process (whether art or
craft?). Frankly I wasn't looking to get into the art vs craft discussion, YET AGAIN. We
have discussed this before in the group at length- please search the archives...
Thanks to all of you who have sent me suggestions. I will revise the draft in a few days
and this time post it to the files section of the group website as a Microsoft Word rtf file.
This will preseve my original formatting and allow you to post any comments in another
color. This method is very helpful for editing...
with warm regards,
--- In Marbling@yahoogroups.com, "hamburgerbuntpapier_de"
> there is one thing I would like to draw your attention to.
> In the very first paragraph, you describe marbling as the artistic application of colours
> the way - is it really colours you talk about here? Not paints?) to a surface. This seemsto
> me very treacherous grounds. Basically, marbling is neither more nor less than one ofthe
> many techniques of decorating paper, i.e. a craft. Marbling techniques can be used tomost
> create a piece of art, but then the result is graphics or marble-graphics or whatever you
> want to call it, but not decorated paper. Please avoid the pitfall of mixing up a technique
> (such as marbling) with a possible result (e.g. art). Sooner or later you'll be facing the
> confusing mess, and we have enough of that already.cut
> Making decorated paper of any kind is repetition, and decorated paper is meant to be
> up and become a part of something else. Art is unique.
> Susanne Krause
> --- In Marbling@yahoogroups.com, Jake Benson <handbindery@b...> wrote:
> > Hello Everyone,
> > Here's a basic marbling Q & A that I have drafted to mount on the
> > Society of Marbling web site. I would love to hear any constructive
> > comments, suggestions, or possible additions from any of you. Suffice
> > it to say that between unlawful reproduction and Martha Stewart, we
> > need something like this for general public consumption. In time, I
> > may revise this, as sections of the site expand. For instance, the
> > mention of some historical info could well be worked into a page by
> > itself.. I would also like to illustrate this, but I need to start
> > simply and over time it can be revised and expanded.
> > Jake Benson
> > Q: What is marbling?
> > Marbling, occasionally referred to, as marbleizing is an artistic
> > application of color to a surface. A common factor in all type of
> > marbling involve first suspending colors on a liquid. In some methods
> > these floating colors are manipulated using a variety of tools and
> > movements. Then a material such as a sheet of paper is then laid over
> > top, capturing the design.
> > [Non-text portions of this message have been removed]