"Justice," by Frank Crane
- Below is "Justice," one of Frank Crane's "Four Minute Essays." These
essays were originally published as a syndicated newspaper column,
but were republished as a ten-volume collection in 1919.
I have just put it online at:
I think it captures the spirit of the Georgist approach rather nicely.
THERE are many earnest souls occupied in trying to do people good.
There are nine million societies, more or less, organized to improve
and to ameliorate.
There are preachers, missionaries, evangelists, reformers, exhorters,
viewers-with-pride, and pointers-with-alarm without number
wrestling with sinners.
All forms of industry are booming these days in the U. S. A., but the
uplift business is still several laps ahead.
It seems ungracious to say a word to any enthusiastic person who is
engaged in so laudable an enterprise as that of rescuing the perishing,
feeding the hungry, and healing the sick.
And yet, when you take time to think right through to the bottom of
things, you must come to the conclusion that there is but one real,
radical and effective way to help your fellow-men, and that is the way
If I want to redeem the world I can come nearer my object, and do less
harm, by being just toward myself and just toward everybody else,
than by "doing good" to people.
The only untainted charity is justice.
Often our ostensible charities serve but to obscure and palliate great
Conventional charity drops pennies in the beggar's cup, carries bread
to the starving, distributes clothing to the naked. Real charity, which
is justice, sets about removing the conditions that make beggary,
starvation, and nakedness.
Conventional charity plays Lady Bountiful; justice tries to establish
such laws as shall give employment to all, so that they need no
Charity makes the Old Man of the Sea feed sugar-plums to the poor
devil he is riding and choking; justice would make him get off his
Conventional charity piously accepts things as they are, and helps the
unfortunate; justice goes to the legislature and changes things.
Charity swats the fly; justice takes away the dung-heaps that breed
Charity gives quinine in the malarial tropics; justice drains the
Charity sends surgeons and ambulances and trained nurses to the war;
justice struggles to secure that internationalism that will prevent war.
Charity works among slum wrecks; justice dreams and plans that
there be no more slums.
Charity scrapes the soil's surface; justice subsoils.
Charity is affected by symptoms; justice by causes.
Charity assumes evil institutions and customs to be a part of "Divine
Providence," and tearfully works away at taking care of the wreckage;
justice regards injustice everywhere, custom-buttressed and
respectable or not, as the work of the devil, and vigorously attacks it.
Charity is timid and is always passing the collection-box; justice is
unafraid and asks no alms, no patrons, no benevolent support.
"It is presumed," says Henry Seton Merriman, "that the majority of
people are willing enough to seek the happiness of others; which
desire leads the individual to interfere with his neighbor's affairs,
while it burdens society with a thousand associations for the welfare
of mankind or the raising of the masses."
The best part of the human race does not want help, nor favor, nor
charity; it wants a fair chance and a square deal.
Charity is man's kindness.
Justice is God's.
------- End of forwarded message -------