Re: [Julian-May-discuss] Re: Milieu Companion
- I have a Dune fan forum, www.jacurutu.com and I find it curious that this was mentioned as being a first in dealing with ecological issues (1950). Julian May is one of my favorites, it would be a wonderfull coincidence to find that she was an influence on Frank Herbert (Dune 1965). Especially considering Dune was first published serially by Campbell in his magazine.I haven't read "Dune Roller", would anyone mind giving me a very brief summary?
--- On Sun, 3/22/09, mariposa7b5 <nicolel@...> wrote:
From: mariposa7b5 <nicolel@...>
Subject: [Julian-May-discuss] Re: Milieu Companion
Date: Sunday, March 22, 2009, 12:37 AMHi there,
I've got a copy of 'Dune Roller', it's in a book of short sci-fi stories that is somewhere on my book shelf. Hiding, no doubt. I thought it was a nicely written take on the 'menace from outer space' plot, if I remember rightly.
I couldn't have written something like that when I was 20, anyway. :)
Mod Mom #2
--- In Julian-May-discuss@ yahoogroups. com, "alixnc" <alixnc@...> wrote:
> > One gem I found amongst the PDFs was the Dune Roller short story. I had never read it before and was very keen to sink my teeth(eyes) into it. I wont prejudice any response here (one way or the other) by giving my thoughts just yet. But I was wondering whether anyone else has managed to read the story and what they thought of it?
> > Surely Mod Mom 2 has read it.
> Way to go, Niall!!
> Re "Dune Roller," yes I've read it, and will reserve my own opinion until others have commented, except to add that science fiction critics have generally noted it as the first important work of its kind to deal with ecological issues. Our JM was a 20-year-old college student when it was published.