Loading ...
Sorry, an error occurred while loading the content.

25590Re: [Janshakti] Fwd: Urgent update and appeal: A resounding NO to the India-Japan nuclear agreement emerges from all corners

Expand Messages
  • Jai Raj Yadav
    Jan 21 6:31 PM
      Only few people in this forum are as arrogant and ill mannered as Sukla is. When he runs out of valid scholarly arguments he starts calling others ignorant.

      Mr Shukla distorts the facts , misquotes as he did recently in case of Teesta and Javed's interim protection which he called "Transit Visa" and "Transit Bail" despite the order of Judge being copied in the post. He further misquoted that judge accepted instances of false cases against Teesta.

      Please amend your way of addressing people and  stop quoting incorrect things out of not understanding it  or doing so deliberately.
      Jairaj Yadav

      From: Rabinder Koul <ravindrakkoul@...>
      To: Janshakti@yahoogroups.com
      Cc: Rabinder Koul <RavindraKKoul@...>
      Sent: Wednesday, 22 January 2014 4:39 AM
      Subject: Re: [Janshakti] Fwd: Urgent update and appeal: A resounding NO to the India-Japan nuclear agreement emerges from all corners

      Nuclear power in the along run is the cheapest source of energy. It has potential dangers, but it is the cheapest source. Its initial infrastructure etc is high, but in the long run it is work horse that delivers. 

      His answer to this is going to be, you guys are ignorant etc, the usual abuse. I have dealt personally with these issues in my past in US.

      Ravindra Koul
      अस्मद्रूपसमाविष्ठ: स्वात्मनात्मानिवारणे 
      शिव: करोतु निजया नम: शक्त्या ततात्मने 

      On Jan 21, 2014, at 1:37 PM, Sukla Sen <sukla.sen@...> wrote:


      Your ignorance is really astounding.

      Nuclear power constitutes less than 3% of total electricity generation capacity of India.
      It's uneconomic, intrinsically hazardous and potentially catastrophic - as demonstrated by Chernobyl and Fukushima.

      A good number of countries have decided not to opt for nuclear power or phase it out.
      In Japan itself, on 14 September 2013 all the 54 reactors were shut down.
      None of these countries have broken up as a consequence. Nor do they exhibit any sign in that direction.

      So no point making absurdly stupid allegations.


      On 21 January 2014 23:47, Jai Raj Yadav <yadavjr@...> wrote:

      Sukla ,

      You and your friends Kumar Sundaram from Coalition for Nuclear Disarmament and Peace are working against Nuclear Power Generator.

      What is your solution and contribution to bridge the power shortage in India ?

      On whose behalf you and your friends are working to Break India ?
      Jairaj Yadav

      From: Sukla Sen <sukla.sen@...>
      To: Janshakti@yahoogroups.com
      Sent: Tuesday, 21 January 2014 9:05 PM
      Subject: [Janshakti] Fwd: Urgent update and appeal: A resounding NO to the India-Japan nuclear agreement emerges from all corners [13 Attachments]


      ---------- Forwarded message ----------
      From: Kumar Sundaram <pksundaram@...>
      Date: 21 January 2014 17:32
      Subject: Urgent update and appeal: A resounding NO to the India-Japan nuclear agreement emerges from all corners

      A resounding NO to the India-Japan nuclear agreement emerges from all corners
      From Japan to Jaitapur to Koodankulam, people say NO More Fukushima
      Dear Friends,
      The campaign initiated by the Coalition for Disarmament and Peace(CNDP) against the India-Japan nuclear agreement, which has been in pipeline for several years and is likely to be culminated during the Japanese Prime Minister Mr. Shinzo Abe’s upcoming visit to New Delhi, has recieved extremely encouraging response from people all over the world, especially in India and Japan. For us, this support vindicates our firm belief that this nuclear agreement is anachronistic, absurd and unacceptable to people in Japan who are witnessing a still unfolding disaster in Japan, and people in India who are brutally silenced by their government indulging in nuclear expansion misadventure. It is heartening to see that this camaign has received solidarity from people across the world who realise the risks of nuclear energy in a post-Fukushima world.
      Mr. Abe will be India’s chief guest during the Republic Day ceremony on 26th January 2014 and he will be in India during 25-27th January. To raise our voice during this period, we have given a call to people, urging to pose with a poster that says “NO More Fukushima / Mr. Abe, you are welcome to India, Nukes are Not / No to India-Japan Nuclear Agreement”. A large number of people have sent their self-portraits with the poster, translated into many Indian languages and also Japanese. Besides eminent Indians like Admiral L. Ramdas and Lalita Ramdas, renowned filmmaker Anand Patwardhan and Prof. Achin Vanaik, hundreds of individuals have sent their self-portraits. Fisherfold in Jaitapur, a site of strong grassroots movement against Areva’s proposed project for the world’s biggest nuclear power park, organised a meeting and have sent collective pictures. Similar individual and collective pictures have come from the Friday protests in Tokyo where Japanese citizens have been protesting at their PM’s residence every week. Such self-portraits with message of protest and slidarity are being recieved from Germany, US, France and several other countries.
      These self-portraits, collected till 23rd January, would be used for a large collage and will be displayed prominently in various cities in India during Mr. Shinzo Abe’s visit. In India, the collage will be launched by children in Idinthakarai village in Koodankulam, where a massive peaceful movement against Koodankulam nuclear power plant has been underway after Fukushima, and has faced violent repression by the state in which 2 people were killed in 2012. The entire village is under seige and absurd charges of sedition and war against the Indian state have been levelled against the villagers for protesting against nuclear project. Eminent citizens and groups in India and Japan would also release an open letter to the Prime Ministers of both countries on the occasion.
      We are strongly against the India-Japan nuclear agremeent for three basic reasons:
      - This agreement is absurd in a post-Fukushima world for both India and Japan. We want that the two Asian countries should have closer relations and work together on renewable and sustainable energy sources, paving way for a better and safer world after Fukushima. Mr. Abe is facing severe and justified criticism in Japan for mishandling Fukushima accident even further and trying hard to reverse the policy of nuclear rollback.
      - This deal would fuel the Indian government’s insane nuclear expansion drive, which it is doing in complete denial of lessons from Fukushima. With a very poor record on nuclear safety, a toothless regulator and an entirely non-transparent and unaccountable nuclear operator, India is importing untested reactors from France, the US and Russia and endangering its people’s lives, particularly the rural poor who are being disaplaced and dispossessed in the name of development that these projects would bring for the urban sections.
      - Both the Hiroshima and Nagasaki declarations last year highlighted that this agreement would be an extremely bad precedent for global nuclear disarmament and would mean legitimising India’s nuclear weapons when the world is grappling with new potential proliferators. India is a non-signatory to both the NPT and CTBT and it conducted nuclear tests in 1998 in brazen contempt of the international opinion and the country’s own traditions of peace and non-violence. Since the nuclear tests, security situation in South Asia has only worsened and India has become world’s largest arms importer.
      Japan would probably not sell any reactors to India directly, but a mutual agreement is necessary for the French and American reactor projects to take off in India – because both US companies Westinghouse and GE have a majority Japanese ownership now and crucial components for Areva’s reactors are manufactured by Japanese suppliers. These countries have denied abiding with the Nuclear Liability Act in India and have been pressurising the Japanese government to have the agreement at the earliest.
      Along with other organisations and people’s movements, we have decided to declare 25th January as the National Day of Protest against the India-Japan Nuclear Agreement. Protests actions would be organised on that day in various corners of India.
      We urge more friends to send their self-portraits, posing with the protest poster, and raise voice against this agreement which reflects the attempt by the strong vested interests in reversing the human lessons of Fukushima. We also urge the media and bloggers to help us spreading the message.
      The pictures can be posted directly on the facebook event page: https://www.facebook.com/events/262774790547186/?fref=ts or sent to cndpindia@...
      With warm regards,
      Kumar Sundaram
      Coalition for Nuclear Disarmament and Peace
      New Delhi, India
      cndpindia@... | +91-9810556134

      Peace Is Doable

      Peace Is Doable

    • Show all 14 messages in this topic