186Re: [ISO8601] Re: Clarifications: 184.108.40.206
- Jul 16, 2001P A Hill & E V Goodall writes:
> [snip]How about the last paragraph in 4.1.
> In fact, the standard before the first truncated format in the
> opening paragraph of 220.127.116.11 says "In each case hyphens that
> indicate components should be used only as indicated or shall be
> That to me hints that some of choices are arbitrary, so don't play
> around with them. Also, there is no place that states that all
> formats are mutually unambiguous from each other. As I was reading
> I was looking for just such a statement or examples that violated
> the idea. I found neither, but that is no proof.
I agree that the choices seem arbitrary. There may be some logic
behind it though. My guess is that the rules are something like
Replace an omitted component in a truncated format with a hyphen.
Component may be century (first two digits of a four digit year)
or decade (first three digits of a four digit year) or last two
digits of the year or month or week. The term component is not
defined as such but the components are listed for each of the
Remove hyphens if the result is unambiguous.
4.6 para 1 states that a hyphen may be necessary to represent an
omitted component. That implies to me that the hyphen should not
be used if possible.
(The above two rules may also be expressed as: Components may be
omitted, if the result is ambiguous then use a hyphen to stand for
the omitted component.)
Add hyphens where a format is ambiguous. This is bound to be
arbitrary: if two formats collide one must be chosen to get the
Note that omitting hyphens by these rules is a separate issue to
18.104.22.168. I take the latter to mean that the communicating parties
agree that, for example, two digits alone mean a month rather than
using four characters of 22.214.171.124.e proper.
Pete Forman -./\.- Disclaimer: This post is originated
WesternGeco -./\.- by myself and does not represent
pete.forman@... -./\.- opinion of Schlumberger, Baker
http://www.crosswinds.net/~petef -./\.- Hughes or their divisions.
- << Previous post in topic Next post in topic >>