Re: Horseshoe Mesa - now a two-nighter
- I guess that means a flight of stairs could be a class 4 ascent.
--- In Grand_Canyon_Hikers@yahoogroups.com, "oriska1964" <wayne.tomasi@...> wrote:
> Class 4 means 'not particularly difficult but has exposed and a screwup could be fatal'.
> Wayne Tomasi
> --- In Grand_Canyon_Hikers@yahoogroups.com, "dmarcus2@" <dmarcus2@> wrote:
> > Another take, per my 2002 trip report:
> > "The kids play around for a while, and then we organize a dayhike to try and climb the butte on Horseshoe Mesa. We get within one rock band of the summit, admire the view, and then descend. We end up circumambulating the butte, but not reaching the top."
> > However, the "kids" were 6, 7, 9, and 10 at the time.
> > --- In Grand_Canyon_Hikers@yahoogroups.com, "Bob Marley" wrote:
> > >
> > > It's been a long time ago Jan but I seem to remember going around to the North and east to get up. It was pretty much a scramble climb. Some use of hands. Very low rating. Good view on top.
> > > We were able to climb it with one of our nieces who was young but definitely not an outdoors person, she still isn't, so it can't be too difficult.
> > > Rope not needed. Technical skills minimal.
> > >
> > > --- In Grand_Canyon_Hikers@yahoogroups.com, Jan Swafford wrote:
> > >
> > > > I'm going to be on Horseshoe this May for the third time, and once asked the group about that and got no answer. What's the best route if you aspire to get up the mesa and have no technical skills or, for that matter, rope?
- I did the old grandview last may.
in my experience it will take at least 2 hours to go from cottonwood creek
to the bottom of the old grandview trail at the river - most likely longer
than that. just getting to the large cairn at the top of the tapeats - if
walking fast - is over half an hour (it took me well over an hour - but we
stop to look around a lot and take pictures). From there to the river is at
least 30 minutes most likely considerably longer than that.
in any case, from the bottom of the tapeats to the river is not the type of
trail you want to be moving too quickly. there are no maps that i found
that have that trail, so your route-finding capabilities are actually
cairn-finding capabilities (and knowing which ones are the correct ones to
I would say to give it at least 3 hours for going down and at least 2 hours
to return to cottonwood creek.
On Mon, Mar 26, 2012 at 1:47 PM, John <jge@...> wrote:
> > April 6: Head out to the Old Grandview and take it down to the river.
> Retrace our steps and take the west-side trail back up to Horseshoe Mesa
> and camp
> The old-Grandview doesn't really take that long, perhaps an hour each way
> if you have no route-finding mixups. So camping at Cottonwood, doing the
> old Grandview, and then back up to the Mesa, is a perfectly reasonable day.
Upload files to us: YouSendIt <http://yousend.it/eJ6e6N>
We use 1and1 <http://www.1and1.com/?affiliate_id=36066> for all our Web
*PCL Media Group*| Pinny Lew
382 Kingston Avenue, Suite 208
Brooklyn, NY 11225
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]