Re: Language, Translations and Niryn out to get us all
- Romanian hassomething we call "polite pronoun" for second and third
person. If talking to/about a friend, we use "tu" (2nd pers.) /"el"
(3rd pers. masc.)/"ea" (3rd pers. fem.). If talking to someone who
outranks us, we call them "domneavoastra" (2nd pers.) /"dumnealui"
(3rd pers. masc.)/"dumneaei" (3rd pers. fem.). Same goes for
pluralform. We also have something called "fake polite pronoun".
--- In Flewelling@yahoogroups.com, "summershadows_winterlight"
> Language pondering out of frustration:
> Frustration, frustration. After changing a character's background
> relation to another character after two chapters, I had to changetwo
> chapters' conversation due to the fact German uses two differentkinds
> of `You'.who
> We have the friendly `You' (=Du) for friends, family, and people
> know each other for longer time, and the formal `You' (=Sie/Ihrlike
> depending on setting/time) for everyone else. In English it isn't
> that, or never saw it before. I know French has it, too. What elseSeries.
> languages use the two different `You' forms?
> Beside that I just started wondering when the translators of, for
> example Lynn's books, change the You. *laughs* I guess next time I
> read translated books, I'll have a look at that.
> (ranting mode: Boo! Bad german translators for the Nightrunner
> (BDT in opposite to that was mostly nice, HW isn't out yet here, Iand
> only read it in English) Boo! Note to self: check 'you problem' in
> different book and read Lynn's books in English only, where names
> locations and terms won't change every ten chapters. Chase Niryn atkilled
> them! Chase them at Niryn! Ranting mode off.)
> Now I better go and correct my two chapters `You'.
> P.S.: Excuse my constant mentioning of Niryn. That guy nearly
> my sanity. Deep wish to strangle him. A successful bad-character.
> Lynn, aren't you sometimes afraid he pops up to get you and your
> family? X_x;
- Yes, it happens. Actually, In Spain, it even happens between people
that is not inmigrants. Every year we have women killed by husbands,
boyfriends, exs... It´s happened for a long time even if it wasn´t on
the news. But affected people has started to react, now is the momment
This kills is partly a result of a culture and a series of old
believes. Women are rised believing they must submit to men and as a
part of it they allow beating and being ordered around. Women and men
have believed it to be right for a long time, they´ve believed it was
their fault and the men were right to do that. The mentality of this
people is very far away from ours. I´ve had a friend in a familly like
that, they didn´t considered they really needed help. Comments like
"your father has no right to make you clean after him and your
brothers and then get angry if you don´t do it, you´re not their
slave, you´ve got things more important to do right now" only got me
an angry friend.
It can´t be broken suddenly. Women and men who thinks this is wrong
can´t just break in, it doesn´t really help. The first changes and
reactions have to come from women themselves. Wich in case of those
certain sectors of spanish population is now happening. Now we can
help them because now the women believe they have a right to be
treated better, now they want the help. To me that´s the way of doing
things well. Things have to follow their own natural path and
evolution, you can only try to fasten that path, but taking measures
and forcing them into acting acording to ideals they don´t have can
only provoque resentment. IMO you can´t help people againts their
ideas, even if you mean well.
All this is, of course, my oppinion. I´m just 25, I don´t pretend to
have the truth of the world in my hands.
On Thu, 3 Mar 2005 20:17:12 +0100, Firesong <Firesong@...> wrote:
> Of course that is true. I was simply shocked by the evidence that there
> have been "honour killings" in Germany, not only recently, which was
> big in the press, but apparently it has happened before more than once.