DFD at the Salzburg Festival (Review)
- Copyright 2005 The New York Sun, One SL, LLC
All Rights Reserved
The New York Sun
August 23, 2005 Tuesday
HEADLINE: Once More for Fischer-Dieskau
BYLINE: By JAY NORDLINGER
DATELINE: SALZBURG, Austria
Last May, Dietrich Fischer-Dieskau turned 80, and the festival honored
that milestone with a concert on Friday night. The featured performer?
The great baritone had made his Salzburg debut exactly 54 years
before: on August 19, 1951. The conductor Wilhelm Furtwangler had
asked him to sing Mahler's "Songs of a Wayfarer." Up to his official
retirement from singing in 1992, Mr. Fischer-Dieskau sang 32 recitals
in Salzburg, in addition to all the orchestra concerts and opera
roles. It's fairly safe to say that Mr. Fischer-Dieskau is more
closely associated with the Salzburg Festival than is any other
singer. His only rival in this respect may be the soprano Elisabeth
He has not been idle in "retirement," has Dietrich Fischer-Dieskau: He
conducts, he teaches, he writes books. He also performs a good many
speaking roles, as he did on Friday night. The piece was Schumann's
"Manfred," a "dramatic poem with music." The text is Byron's,
translated into German, of course, and fiddled with by the composer
(who, in effect, acted as dramaturge). "Manfred" is a virtuoso
opportunity for a speaker, or actor, and Dietrich Fischer-Dieskau made
the most of it. He is still the summit.
Before he took the stage, the bells outside the Felsenreitschule rang,
as if in celebration. And then he appeared: slightly slow of step, but
immensely distinguished, and ramrod straight. Mr. Fischer-Dieskau
seems to have every follicle of hair he ever grew. And he is still
about the handsomest guy around. The critic sitting next to me broke
out into a kind of happy laughter. He said, "I never thought I'd see
him come onstage again." I think a lot of people in the audience felt
the same way.
As the music began - the overture is really the only thing we ever
hear from "Manfred" - the look of concentration on Mr.
Fischer-Dieskau's face was striking. He seemed to live and feel every
note, and he also did a little conducting with his head: That must be
irresistible to him.
The fabled singer proved himself an amazingly expressive speaker, with
every word having its proper effect. He riveted everyone in the hall.
You could have heard a pin drop. Frankly, I found Mr. Fischer-Dieskau
more emotional - more openly emotional, let's say - than I ever found
him as a singer. You almost literally rose and fell with him. And I'll
tell you this, too: I bet he can sing a little, still. You can tell,
by the sound of that voice, the sight of that posture, the confidence
and mastery that pour forth from him.
Leading the Salzburg Mozarteum Orchestra was Ivor Bolton, the English
conductor. This orchestra is no threat to the Vienna Philharmonic's
reputation, but it was adequate. And Mr. Bolton had the sweep of
"Manfred" in mind, and hand. The Salzburg Bach Choir was helpfully
sturdy and compact.
And there are four singing soloists in this piece, all of whom have
relatively brief parts. The soloist who sings the most is the baritone
(!), and this was Jan Buchwald, who has a fine instrument, and a good
sense of musical drama. The orchestra sometimes covered him, but this
was not ruinous. The young soprano, Nadine Lehner, has a superb
pedigree: She has studied under Mr. Fischer-Dieskau, Miss Schwarzkopf,
Julia Varady (Mr. Fischer-Dieskau's wife), Inge Borkh, the late Hans
Hotter, and Wolfram Rieger. She has a liquid, fast-running voice,
which she deployed accurately. Dorthe Haring, the mezzo-soprano, was
lovely and clear. Ferdinand von Bothmer, the tenor, completed this
After "Manfred" - and before the intermission - a local official
presented Mr. Fischer-Dieskau with the Golden Honor Award of the
Province of Salzburg. In doing so, he gave nearly a Castro-length
speech. Even the decorous Salzburg crowd had trouble sitting still. In
(finally) accepting, Mr. Fischer-Dieskau was economical and gracious -
his performer's awareness never fails him.
In the second half of the program, Mr. Bolton and the Mozarteum
Orchestra offered Schumann's Fourth Symphony. I was not able to stay
to hear this - but I can tell you a very interesting anecdote. It
comes from George Sgalitzer, a Seattle doctor who was born in Vienna
and is the festival's senior patron. He attended the very first
performance - on August 22, 1920. A 7-year-old, he was brought by his
grandparents. He has attended every summer since, except for the war
years. In any case, Dr. Sgalitzer once asked Herbert von Karajan how
many symphonies he knew by heart. The conductor responded, "One
hundred and three." Then Dr. Sgalitzer asked which was his favorite.
And do you know what Karajan said, out of all those symphonies - by
Mozart, Beethoven, Bruckner, and the rest? Schumann's Fourth.
So it's got that going for it.