Loading ...
Sorry, an error occurred while loading the content.

Grade crossings, far from perfect, are here to stay

Expand Messages
  • Gino's Railpage
    Grade crossings, far from perfect, are here to stay Wednesday, April 5, 2006 By TOM DAVIS STAFF WRITER Many of the nation s railroad crossings are old and lack
    Message 1 of 1 , Apr 5, 2006
    • 0 Attachment
      Grade crossings, far from perfect, are here to stay

      Wednesday, April 5, 2006

      By TOM DAVIS

      Many of the nation's railroad crossings are old and lack gates and
      other warning signals that protect motorists.

      If federal officials had their wish, the 250,000 at-grade railroad
      crossings would disappear. It's a safety issue, they say.

      But local government and railroad officials say they'll keep the
      ground-level intersections -- and old-fashioned warning signals --
      that motorists have been crossing for more than a century. Although
      many grade crossings could be improved, the accident rate is very low,
      officials say. A significant upgrade or complete reconfiguration of
      the intersections would cost millions of dollars.

      Monday's deaths of two landscaping workers whose truck was crushed by
      a train in Oakland did little to change officials' minds -- largely
      because driver error may have played a role.

      "As long as lights are flashing, people have enough sense to stop,"
      said Oakland Councilman Donald Burns.

      Eyewitnesses said driver Philip Salvatoriello ignored flashing lights
      and bells as he tried to beat the oncoming New York, Susquehanna and
      Western Railway train. It was the first accident at a grade crossing
      in Oakland in 33 years.

      Colleagues of Salvatoriello and passenger Anthony Cuccio, however,
      believe they would have survived if the crossing was gated. Burns, in
      turn, agreed that the borough could request an upgrade -- as long as
      it's cost-effective.

      Steve Kulm, spokesman for the Federal Railroad Administration, said
      his agency provides $220 million each year to help communities and
      railroad systems improve or replace their grade crossings.

      How to pay for it, however, is a local decision, Kulm said. "You can
      use state dollars. You can use federal dollars," he said. "In some
      cases, you can use some percentage of railroad dollars."

      The funding helps the FRA move closer to its 15-year goal of reducing
      the number of grade crossing nationwide by a quarter. The agency is 72
      percent of the way toward its goal, Kulm said.

      Many of the closings occur because a train company abandons old lines.
      But the FRA does encourage the closing of grade crossings -- and, if
      possible, replacing them with an overhead trestle.

      "There is no question that the safest grade crossing is the one that
      does not exist," Kulm said.

      But Thomas O'Neil, a spokesman for the New York, Susquehanna and
      Western Railway, said upgrading a grade crossing isn't always
      necessary -- as long as there is some warning signal.

      "In a densely populated state like New Jersey, there are just lots and
      lots of grade crossings," said O'Neil. "[Replacing them] would be like
      building the Interstate Highway System on the railroads."

      O'Neil pointed to a $5 million project in Hackensack to raise the
      River Street trestle by 2 feet. The scope of the project would be
      typical of rebuilding a grade crossing, he said.

      NJ Transit, meanwhile, says its safety record at grade crossings is
      "excellent." All of them have bells, flashing lights and gates, said
      Dan Stessel, a spokesman for the agency.

      In 2005, there were six accidents and one fatality involving a train
      and a motor vehicle at NJ Transit grade crossings, Stessel said. There
      are none so far this year.

      Municipalities, meanwhile, say they haven't felt the need to push for
      upgrades -- other than routine maintenance, such as filling potholes.

      "We do stay on top of it to make sure all the safety precautions are
      in place," said Stephen Lo Iacono, Hackensack's city manager.

    Your message has been successfully submitted and would be delivered to recipients shortly.