Re: [Distillers] Re: Flash Distillation
- My biggest problem is that one group says it can't be done and a second group that has an opposite opinion, so who is correct? Are they both correct in their own right? I'm not a science geek. so part of my problem is that I don't speak geek. Here is my un-geek thought.We distill wash in a pot still or reflux still, and we use evaporation to remove and consecrate alcohol in a central point. The question here is can we do this process faster? Can we evaporate (separate) alcohol from water in minutes rather than hours? We heat up gals of liquid to increase evaporation, so why not heat up small amounts of wash compared to a gallons. It is much easier to to increase evaporation in 1 or 2 oz per second than say 2.5 gals in hours. My whole idea is to substantially increase evaporation there by collecting and concentrating alcohol into a collection point much faster. Keeping chamber heat below boiling point of water should maximize evaporation, while not turning all liquids into a vapor.From what I can tell, my way does the same thing as pot and reflux stills but faster, and it uses less energy to do that function. If I can partly strip, my 2.5 gals in 35 min., there is still time to re-run wash and evaporated wash several more times. In 1 hr, it should be possible to condense 2.5 gals to 95% abv. That should also cover Zbob's evaporation reference.My idea should work to increase evaporation faster, but it will take time to work out any bugs. The reason I am looking into this is that I broke (pits) a second so called SS pot, so I need a new still that will not keep breaking on me.Robert
From: Fredrick Lee <fredrick@...>
To: "Distillers@yahoogroups.com" <Distillers@yahoogroups.com>
Sent: Sunday, March 10, 2013 11:29 AM
Subject: Re: [Distillers] Re: Flash Distillation
If I am correct, pumping room temperature wash into a heated chamber should be a enough of a shock to cause the separation of alcohol and waterRobert, that's where you are incorrect, alcohol is miscible in water and what you are trying to do is mechanically induce two discrete phase changes.Because alcohol/water mix is azeotropic, it won't ever do what you suspect it will.Read the Wikipedia article on azeotrope, it will explain this phenomenon.http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Azeotrope
- I just wanted to tell someone since I dropped the flash distillation subject on Distillers.
I figured out how to use it for stripping, and how to use it for making cuts. It will cost around $1,000 to build though. Now the subject is officially dead for me.
From: "Distillersemail@example.com" <Distillersfirstname.lastname@example.org>
Sent: Monday, March 11, 2013 9:40 PM
Subject: [Distillers] Re: Flash Distillation
Message from Management to "last2blast"
Your posting privileges have been demoted to "moderated".Reason:
Due to excessive badgering by you of both the Y!D forums, re your "new distilling idea".Whether it works or not, isn't the issue.
Harassment is the issue. Harping on unfounded and untested notions is the issue.You've had more than a fair hearing in BOTH groups. Now it's time for you to "put up, or shut up". When you are ready with the results, post 'em. Mods will see if you're contributing to the distilling topic, or just continuing to blow steam. Your post will be dealt with on that score.Footnote:Part of The Charter for this group states..."It is a 'given' that you are familiar with basic distilling."I strongly urge you to get educated re Distillation before you continue. Else you're gonna do yourself a mischief.
The ManagementPS for other posters.
Kindly trim out all the unnecessary previous posts when sending messages to these Distilling groups. Help us to help you.