Re: [Distillers] Re: Flash Distillation
- View SourceIs it really the best way?Robert
From: Brendan Keith <bkeith@...>
Sent: Sunday, March 10, 2013 10:36 AM
Subject: RE: [Distillers] Re: Flash Distillation
It's almost as if...after hundreds of years of inspiration, experimentation and refinement, the process that we use today is the most suited to our goals.Go figure.--BK-----Original Message-----
From: Distillers@yahoogroups.com [mailto:Distillers@yahoogroups.com] On Behalf Of tgfoitwoods
Sent: Sunday, March 10, 2013 4:02 AM
Subject: [Distillers] Re: Flash DistillationOk, I had to read up on flash distillation to be certain that I understood it, but mostly what I found was flash evaporation of a mixture of a volatile liquid and a non-volatile solid, as in a water desalinization plant. In that case all of the volatile liquid is vaporized and re-condensed as product, while the non-volatile dissolved solids remain in the flash chamber.
As beverage distillers, we are trying to change the relative concentration of a mixture of volatile liquids, especially to increase the concentration of ethanol, and only incidentally leaving the solids behind.
Unless I'm terribly mistaken, when you "flash" a quantity of a mixture of volatile liquids, you vaporize all of that quantity, and aside from some loss of solids, the concentrations of the volatile liquids going out to be condensed should be identical to the concentrations going in, which would be useless to us as beverage distiller.
Robert, it sounds like you are saying that so long as you hold the flash temperature below the boiling point of water at that pressure, the ethanol will vaporize and the water won't, and that puts us back in the realm of believing that a mixture of volatile liquids has multiple boiling points, that by controlling temperature we can control which volatile liquids vaporize, and which don't. That's just not true and never has been, although it's often cherished by new distillers.
The simple immutable truth is that such a mixture has one single boiling point at a specific pressure. If you hold the temperature below that, you'll get relatively slow evaporation of ALL volatile compounds, in a ratio determined by Roualt's law of partial vapor presures. If you get the temperature to that single boiling point, and keep inputting the latent heat of evaporation, you'll get relatively quick evaporationf all volatile compounds, again in that same ratio determined by Roualt's law of partial vapor pressures.
I don't see any method utilizing flash evaporation that lets us increase the the ethanol concentration, even though it's great for de-salinization of sea water. Am I missing something?
Zymurgy Bob, a simple potstiller Making Fine Spirits
- View SourceI just wanted to tell someone since I dropped the flash distillation subject on Distillers.
I figured out how to use it for stripping, and how to use it for making cuts. It will cost around $1,000 to build though. Now the subject is officially dead for me.
From: "Distillersemail@example.com" <Distillersfirstname.lastname@example.org>
Sent: Monday, March 11, 2013 9:40 PM
Subject: [Distillers] Re: Flash Distillation
Message from Management to "last2blast"
Your posting privileges have been demoted to "moderated".Reason:
Due to excessive badgering by you of both the Y!D forums, re your "new distilling idea".Whether it works or not, isn't the issue.
Harassment is the issue. Harping on unfounded and untested notions is the issue.You've had more than a fair hearing in BOTH groups. Now it's time for you to "put up, or shut up". When you are ready with the results, post 'em. Mods will see if you're contributing to the distilling topic, or just continuing to blow steam. Your post will be dealt with on that score.Footnote:Part of The Charter for this group states..."It is a 'given' that you are familiar with basic distilling."I strongly urge you to get educated re Distillation before you continue. Else you're gonna do yourself a mischief.
The ManagementPS for other posters.
Kindly trim out all the unnecessary previous posts when sending messages to these Distilling groups. Help us to help you.