858Re: Topic Heroes
- Jan 1, 2007Good points to all and I think that for the most part, people either
fall into two categories. 1. Shocked briefly and then continue on with
life or 2. Shocked, think about it, and then get outraged before they
possibly cry out about it on some personal level.
I fall into the first category for the most part and I've been reading
comics for over 20 years so there really isn't much that they can do
at this point to shock or surprise me to a great extent. It is like
going to the movies... you know that most of them will have 'happy'
endings (depending on the movie) vs the ones from overseas where
whatever the ending has to be, will be.
Comics are different though as they are continuous stories in progress
otherwise there wouldn't be any more stories to tell and that'd end
the comic. Some comics can't have endings and there are some that get
shut down before they can come to an ending for some reason or another.
So you could say that comics are either more like real life, unending
and to quote Quantum Leap "Every life you touch, touches another life
and that life touches another..." So, in that respect each life a
character touches in the comic has a effect on everything and everyone
around them. Case in point... Superboy/Kon-el's passing touched a
bunch of lifes and spread out to include others that you thought would
never get anywhere near it. The other way is like any other
illustrated story telling like Manga where even most of them don't
ever really 'end' such as Ranma 1/2 just because there's a happy
ending doesn't mean that life will stop at that point, it just means
that is where we've chosen to stop paying attention and go on to
something else... content that we're satisfied that from that point
everything will go right for that person(s) in the story.
So, whether a character changes religion peacefully, gets transformed
into a demon by trickery, or suddenly announces their sexual
preference... it should all be taken as what it really is. People
choosing through their own mind to be what they want to be, not
because they thought *you* would want them to be that way.
I've heard stories of people striking soap opera actors because of
some role they played, so I certainly hope that no one would do that
to a comic book character should they become flesh somehow, someday
just because of something that some writers decided they should do...
Silly huh? :) I know we all will become immersed in their roles and
lives, and because they've been around for so long it feels as if the
characters are real and that we should have some say or reaction to
what happens to them or what they say. And I totally agree, as there
are dozens of characters in comics and tv shows that I would hate to
see anything negative happen to them and would write strong letters to
those in charge (which would be like writing to a god if anything
happened to our loved ones or friends) to change things for the
better. So yeah... religion and life and existance all go hand-in-hand
but don't ever let things get too out of control. That's all I'm saying.
--- In DC_Comics_uncensored@yahoogroups.com, "Richard J."
> I'm in about a half dozen comic book groups, and this seems to be the
> only one that gets posts defending Saddam Hussein and looking for
> other gay comic book readers and looking for other swinging comic
> book readers (wow, that's a thought) and for Supergirl and Wonder
> Woman to fight to the death.
> Interesting, I must say, so let's try a different approach.
> Now we get the bulk of our heroes, considerably pampered, so young
> readers can imagine their own lives thru the hero, or we get those
> ridiculous "I'm from the wrong side of the streets, I've had hard
> knocks all my life" heroes, who likewise turn around and get taken in
> by a mysterious financial benefactor.
> Heroes (even thirty years ago and before that) have always been free
> to ascend their soapbox and spout their doctrine.
> "Freedom for all! Treat Everyone the same! Say 'no' to
> discrimination! Everybody has the same right!"
> Basically stuff as light and fluffy as Ward and June Cleaver's world.
> Yes, its nice to say let's treat everyone the same, but we know we
> don't do it!
> We disliked classmates in school, we dislike our bosses on the job,
> we really dislike that person in the car who just cut us off.
> We harbor resentment and disdain for other person's behavior and
> Before I ask this, I want everyone to bear in mind that the bulk of
> my 'ground-breaking characters' were nothing more than tokens in my
> For every black character, there were a 1000 whites.
> For every female, there were a 1000 males.
> Every female spouting feminism would be swept off her feet by a
> bulking male hero, who would make her titter, or she would bitch at
> him in an incredible manner that suggested it was her time of the
> I was going to propose political heroes or religious heroes, but
> unfortunately, 100% of these characters are written by non-religious
> writers who go online to get information about the religion or they
> offer a self-parody of politics.
> But then we wouldn't want Jerry Falwell to offer up his own comic
> book super team, would we?
> If it was well written, wouldn't we be in a quandry?
> Back in the 1970s, both Archie comics and Dennis the Menace would
> offer religious comic books. Neither caused any harm.
> I wouldn't have minded comic books with fleshed out characters,
> explaining Buddhism, Islam or Hinduism, or even Judaism.
> I wouldn't have minded comic books offering characters who are
> Catholic as well as Lutheran or Baptist.
> Before someone starts spouting off characters who did fit this bill,
> they were flashes in the pan, the shock mentality didn't last, and
> the convictions proved ineffective to the stories.
> When I was in school, I drew two storybooks, like comic books,
> ridiculing church going, in a light-hearted way. Growing up
> fundamentalist (Envision Aunt Esther on 'Sanford & Son') I thought
> nothing about drawing characters worshiping with arms uplifted, but
> it didn't dawn on me others didnt share this faith.
> Ironically, the first book I drew didn't focus on how the characters
> worshipped, and the second one did, and I was puzzled when several
> persons told me they liked the first one more (the universal language
> came thru better with no depictions of how the characters
> I wouldnt have minded religion in comic books, of any kind, actually,
> but I understand the need to promote freedom to choose (how many
> years since I last darkened the doorway to a church) and I know there
> are those who feel religion is best left out of comic books, but
> again, the Archie books and the Dennis the Menace books did no harm.
> I'm more dismayed by sudden decisions to make characters Jewish like
> Ben Grimm in the Fantastic Four, whether his creators were Jewish or
> not, it seems ridiculous to me to suddenly alter this character as
> Any chances Bruce Wayne will suddenly be revealed to be Buddhist?
> If Diana Prince converted to another religion aside from the greek
> Mythology, would she lose her powers?
> I could go on about how Marv Wolfman seemed to write every goddess in
> the New Teen Titans as a living goddess, and then we learned that
> they all actually were at one time or another a living person. I used
> to think, well, that doesn't make them much of a goddess, now does it?
- << Previous post in topic Next post in topic >>