A few corrected facts about Calbirds
- When this poll started, I had hoped that it would be pretty straight
forward about it's intentions, and people would just vote on it. But
some have started to mis-quote, name call, and do other wierd things,
so I will try and straighten up some things for all.
Calbird (Not Calbirds) was started by a former California birder
named Hank Brokin back in the early to mid 1990's (I believe). It was
started so that California birders could share information about
rarities and other birding type things in California (correct me if
I'm wrong Hank).
When Hank and Priscilla moved to Southeast Arizona, Hank handed
control of Calbird over to Christopher Taylor (teenage son of bird
photographer Monte Taylor) who was a birder at that time in his life.
As with all teenagers, his interest went other places.
When Calbird completely failed to operate. Steve Sosenky and I (no
one else was involved) started Calbirds on the Yahoo Groups. We
invited Joe Morlan to become a Moderator to help us, as we figured
with his experiance and being from Northern California would balance
out the two Moderators in Southern California. I had already been
running SDBirds since the early 1990's on different Listservs before
migrating the list to Yahoo.
To start off on the current matter. This action was not started by
the "Elitist". I am not a member of the CBRC, and will never see an
invite from them to join it. So get that out of your heads. This is
not an attempt to keep any non advanced birder down!!!.
We as Moderators, do not operate Calbirds with a Heavy hand. We
merely hold people to the guidelines and rules that have long been
established, and you folks have no clue, how many attacks (Spam,
viruses, & other things) attempt to make it to you all through
Calbirds. One regional group, just had to start another list, all
over because they were being knocked out by spammers.
Being that Calbirds is the senior list in California, a discussion
was started by me, on the Bird Group Moderators List. Last fall, I
discovered that many rare or unusal birds were being reported to the
different regional list, and not to Calbirds. I asked for all of the
Bird group owners to help out in getting information about rarities
in their areas reported to Calbirds. I basically asked that if
a "really good bird" (translated- a rarity) shows up in your area,
and it's reported to your list, but not Calbirds, then please pass
the information along to Calbirds. Guess What folks? out of the 20
plus list in California, only 5-6 groups stated that they would help
out. You'd be surprised who did not respond, and then they have
written E-mails here stating that they do not want Calbirds to change.
For the mis-information that is starting to pop up, my original E-
mail stated "that if Calbirds does change (by vote only), then except
for the bird species reported to Calbirds, NOTHING ELSE would change".
I hope this clarifies some of these discussions. It's okay to shake
things up once in awhile, but do it with facts-"only the facts".
San Diego, CA
I greatly appreciate the work that you do to make
this list a go. Calbirds is not only a place where I
can share and learn about "of the moment" bird
sightings throughout California, but an interesting
community of like-minded individuals. If folks are up
at arms, it is because they care, and don't want to
lose this wonderful community, one established over
many years and through many changes.
I feel priviledged to be a part of Calbirds, and I
hope to see it continue, in whatever form it takes,
for many more years. California is a great big place,
and it takes many voices and perspectives to hear and
see the big picture; Calbirds has provided a unique
and timely window into the fascinating world of
California birds and birding.
aguillard2469 <doug@...> wrote:
> When this poll started, I had hoped that it would be
> pretty straight
> forward about it's intentions, and people would just
> vote on it. But
> some have started to mis-quote, name call, and do
> other wierd things,
> so I will try and straighten up some things for all.