Loading ...
Sorry, an error occurred while loading the content.

RE: [CALBIRDS] Apparent Eastern Whip-poor-will at Aptos in Santa Cruz County

Expand Messages
  • Lance Benner
    All, I agree that this doesn t sound like a Mexican whip-poor-will. For comparison, I recorded a Mexican whip-poor-will at Green Canyon in the San Bernardino
    Message 1 of 2 , May 26, 2013
    • 0 Attachment

      I agree that this doesn't sound like a Mexican whip-poor-will. For
      comparison, I recorded a Mexican whip-poor-will at Green Canyon in the
      San Bernardino Mountains on Tuesday night (May 21) and uploaded one of
      my files to Xeno-Canto at:


      You can listen to it for comparison with the bird that David just
      reported. The two birds sound distinctly different. That said, when I
      generated a sonogram of Alex Rinkert's recording and compared it with a
      sonogram of the Eastern Whip-poor-will on the Stokes Eastern Birds CD,
      they aren't a perfect match, but the bird near Santa Cruz sounds MUCH
      more like an eastern whip than a Mexican. After poking around a bit
      with recordings of Eastern whips on Xeno-Canto, it's clear that there's
      some variation in the cadence and structure of eastern whip calls.

      Really nice find and a very, very nice recording!


      Lance Benner
      Altadena, CA

      On Sat, May 25, 2013 at 11:26 PM, David Suddjian wrote:

      > Birders,
      > Last night I was alerted by Melanie Wirtanen to the presence of a bird
      > thought to be a Mexican Whip-poor-will in Aptos. The bird had been
      > present
      > for at least a week, and maybe several days longer than that, and had
      > been
      > noted as unusual by Melanie and her husband, and Patti and Graham
      > Bubb, and
      > Melanie was able to determine it was a whip-poor-will. This evening
      > (May
      > 25) I went to hear it with Alex Rinkert, John Garrett and Lois and
      > Wally
      > Goldfrank. We were expecting to encounter a Mexican Whip-poor-will.
      > The
      > bird began to call in the distance at 8:32 pm. At first it was far off
      > and
      > hard to hear, but later we heard it very well and began to realize
      > that the
      > call did not match that of Mexican, but thought it might be an Eastern
      > Whip-poor-will! We listened to it as it called in bouts for over an
      > hour
      > and eventually heard it at fairly close range and Alex obtained some
      > recordings of the call on his camera (and I some lesser quality
      > recordings
      > on my lesser quality camera). After we got back in cell reception we
      > compared what we heard and Alex's recording to some recordings on line
      > and
      > we believe it is an Eastern Whip-poor-will (which if accepted would be
      > the
      > 2nd CA record, I believe). We welcome informed opinions.
      > Alex's recording from his video is here:
      > http://www.flickr.com/photos/bdmanzanita/8837432778/
      > Generally speaking, this bird's call had a fairly clear 1st note, a
      > 2nd
      > note with a quaver or slight burr, and a highest 3rd note that seemed
      > say
      > 'will' and had a slight down inflection. In contrast, the Mexican has
      > 1st
      > and 2nd notes that are both burry (and much more so than the Aptos
      > bird),
      > and the third note is more a 'wee' and does not have a down
      > inflection.
      > The bird is located along a private road which requires passage
      > through a
      > combination gate. Fortunately, Patti and Graham Bubb are extending to
      > birders some very hospitable access through June 2, after which time
      > they
      > will be away. Patti invites birders to call her to arrange permission
      > to
      > visit. 831 689-0331. We hope everyone will be courteous and
      > respectful.
      > Call first for permission, but here are the directions to get you
      > there.
      > Take Freedom Blvd from Highway 1 and go 0.9 mile to Valencia Road. Go
      > left
      > on Valencia Road for 1.1 miles to Cox Road. Go right on Cox Road for
      > 1.0
      > mile and veer left onto a private drive at a bank of mailboxes located
      > on
      > the left side. Here you enter Valencia Creek Ranch. After about 0.1
      > mile
      > you come to a gate with a keypad combination, which can be obtained by
      > calling Patti Bubb. After passing through the gate, you immediately
      > pass a
      > white house on he left, then a low red barn-type structure, and park
      > near
      > the barn, There is a house with a redwood board fence immediately
      > ahead.
      > The bird has been heard right near that house, but tonight we heard it
      > west
      > of that house, across the nearby drainage which is Valencia Creek. The
      > road
      > forks just pass the house and the left fork dips down to cross the
      > creek
      > and doubles back as it climbs out of the creek. We were within 75
      > meters of
      > the bird about 200 meters after crossing the creek. It was calling
      > from a
      > patch of scrub that is upslope. Patti reports that it calls most of
      > the
      > night. She thought it began at 8:15 last night, but tonight it was at
      > 8:32
      > pm.
      > David Suddjian
      > Capitola
      > [Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
      > ------------------------------------
      > Unsubscribe: mailto:CALBIRDS-unsubscribe@yahoogroups.com
      > Website: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/CALBIRDS
      > Listowners: mailto:CALBIRDS-owner@yahoogroups.com
      > For vacation suspension of mail go to the website. Click on Edit My
      > Membership and set your mail option to No Email. Or, send a blank
      > email to these addresses:
      > Turn off email delivery: mailto:CALBIRDS-nomail@yahoogroups.com
      > Resume email delivery: mailto:CALBIRDS-normal@yahoogroups.com
      > Yahoo! Groups Links
    Your message has been successfully submitted and would be delivered to recipients shortly.