9648existential psychology (and: Re: Great book--Buddhist, yet not)
- Aug 4 11:26 PMKen,
I couldn't agree with you more, I worked in Pharmacies for 20years,
my father, brother, and cousin are Pharmacists, and my other brother
in a Naturopathic doctor.
Some people actually need medication, and some people are over
medicated, and some people could be cure with alternative medicine, or
no medicine at all.
I have a few pet peeves. One of my peeves is that the drug companies
make T.V. commercial touting their drug over other drugs in the same
category, and doing so to the point where people walking into doctors'
offices and demanding the drug that they saw on T.V. Whether the drug
is the right drug for them or not. Doctors are handing out Rx's for
statin drugs like they were candy, just to name one.
Medical drugs are being pushed onto society, and things end up where
everyone thinks that there is a pill for everything. There is not a
pill for everything. We are in a world of suffering, and these past
few generations do not know how to handle suffering even to the
slightest level. We are a nation of wimps. We whine and cry over a
stuffy nose, and think its the end of the world.....
In my opinion, the big drug companies are (and have) set up a scenario
to lead our nation into becoming "A Drug Dependant Nation" Be it
either Rx's or OTCs.
We are a magic pill society
--- In Buddhism_101@yahoogroups.com, ken <gebser@...> wrote:
> -----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
> Hash: SHA1
> It was apparent to me and, I think, everyone here that you weren't
> making a blanket statement for everyone. Even doctors cannot and would
> not prescribe medications or change prescriptions without consulting
> personally with the individual needing help.
> In my previous email on this topic (from some time ago... but that's
> fine... one of the great things about email) I disparaged pills quite
> strongly. I did so because I see a lot of people taking pills when much
> less hazardous and more healthy alternatives are available. And it
> wasn't too long ago that my physician prescribed for me antibiotics for
> treatment of an influenza virus. I asked him if the antibiotic would
> have any effect on the virus (I knew that it wouldn't) and he didn't
> reply at all... but he did cancel the prescription. I worked at a
> number of children's social service agencies and saw psychotropic drugs
> prescribed to children who obviously didn't need them. A friend of mine
> who is a nurse has told me of many cases she knows of where, based on
> her experience of multiple decades, prescribed medication was
> unnecessary. Another friend of mine has been taking blood pressure
> medication for years. Due to a pause in his business, he finally had
> time to do something he truly enjoyed. He went to work on a car which
> has been waiting for him in his driveway for more than a year. After
> just a few days of working on it, his blood pressure went down to almost
> normal levels. And in the week or so since then he's lost so much
> weight that he can't wear the same pants he used to. Who knew that his
> doing something that he enjoyed, that he could and wanted to give his
> full and undivided attention to, would be more effective in lowering his
> blood pressure than the medication was able to? His doctor certainly
> didn't. But then how could he, trained as he is in pharmaceutical
> solutions so much more than in the healing power of the mind?
> On the other hand, I had a good friend who, after an extreme psychotic
> episode, was prescribed lithium. She took this regularly, but after
> awhile said she wanted to reduce it. Reasoning with her that at times
> she might not be the best judge of her own condition, I had her promise
> me that she wouldn't do this unless I agreed. We both agreed that she
> could reduce from four pills a day to three and see how things went.
> Instead she reduced the dosage to two. Then, again against my advice,
> she went off the lithium completely three weeks later. During this time
> she also refinanced her home against my advice, signing on to an
> adjustable rate mortgage (ARM) of the kind that has helped topple our
> economy and which has led to many people losing their homes. Then I
> stopped hearing from her except for terse replies that she didn't want
> me to contact her anymore. From this, it's obvious to me that there
> certainly can be cases where medication is warranted.
> So I've seen problems coming from both sides: people taking medication
> when it wasn't necessary and other people not taking it when it was.
> I'd like to see the day when medication is not necessary for anyone, but
> that day isn't here yet. With medical care in the US so deeply
> influenced by commercial concerns, with our predilection for quick and
> cheap fixes, together with our general misunderstanding and
> underestimation of consciousness, medication is too often the first and
> sole solution sought for maladies of all sorts. Still, all we can say
> at this time is that there is no single, all encompassing recommendation
> which can be made for each and every person. Rather every situation
> should be assessed individually, and re-assessed frequently. Friends or
> family members in whom you can trust and confide can and in some cases
> should be called upon to help in making assessments and decisions. And
> while professionals' expertise should be valued, each of us is
> ultimately responsible for our own well being. Everyone else can only
> try to help.
> - --
> Please note that I will be changing this email address soon. The PGP
> signature should ensure for everyone that, though the email address
> will be different, I will be the same person.
> On 08/03/2008 07:42 PM Tamara wrote:
> | Hi all,
> | I must have sent a wrong impression--I was never suggesting that I
> | (or anyone for that matter) should ever just drop meds. I was
> | actually responding to someone else who'd suggested that meditation
> | practice could help some mental illnesses. Indeed it might, but not
> | mine or at least not so far. The only time I've stopped my meds was
> | when I changed jobs and did not have insurance for a while with my
> | new job, and even then I carefully weaned myself off my old meds.
> | That experience, though not a choice of mine (due to $$$) was
> | negative and scary enough I'll not forget it. I was intending my post
> | to not just be a description of my experience with this, but also so
> | others would not read what someone else had posted and just drop
> | their meds thinking that meditation would/could be the answer. It
> | may be, but one should be very careful and under the care of a doctor
> | while doing so.
> | Sorry for the misunderstanding...
> | Tamara
> | "It is a great and potent and dangerous thing we do, this loving of
> | dogs." -- Jack Voller
> | --- On Sun, 8/3/08, greyhabit <greyhabit@...> wrote:
> | From: greyhabit <greyhabit@...> Subject: [Buddhism_101]
> | existential psychology (and: Re: Great book--Buddhist, yet not) To:
> | Buddhism_101@yahoogroups.com Date: Sunday, August 3, 2008, 9:03 AM
> | Hi Tamara,
> | As an ex Paramedic, army and civilian, I have to firmly agree with
> | John on this issue. My understanding of Clinical Depression is that
> | at its worst it can be a living Hell for the sufferer. Meds are most
> | often the only reliable way, at present, to deal with the chemical
> | and electrical imbalances in the brain which cause these bouts. Do
> | not under any circumstances come off your meds without careful
> | medical supervision, the dangers to you, and others, should not be
> | treated with anything other than extreme caution.
> | On the plus side, our knowledge base is expanding all the time, and
> | who knows what exotic cures could be found over the next few years !
> | If you haven't already done so, try drawing up a list of the
> | negatives and positives in your life, and through calm and creative
> | reflection,and perhaps with the help of a wiling and trusted friend,
> | try to find novel ways to ways to shift some of the negative
> | influences to the positives side of the list. Your aim is to end up
> | with more positives than negatives, eventually. This proess may have
> | to be repeated over several weeks or months before you achieve a
> | positive balance.
> | Please make sure you eat a well balanced diet rich in fruits, and set
> | aside regular periods during the day to have some simple fun, like
> | feeding the birds or gardening. Try taking up Tai Chi, or Hill
> | Walking, or Cycling. All of these help to exercise your brain as well
> | as your body, and will contribute toward better sense of well being.
> | I wish you lasting inner peace :)
> | Br Maximillian EFO
> | --- In Buddhism_101@ yahoogroups. com, John Pellecchia <pellejf@ >
> | wrote:
> |> Tamara,
> |> There are times when medication not meditation is essential to
> |> one's
> | well-being and practice. I would sincerely hope that anyone who is
> | prescribed medication by a doctor would consult with him or her
> | before attempting to go off an Rx. Even then I'm sure the doctor
> | would ween one off the meds while under their care and not suggest
> | stopping immediately. There's no reason that you should be "...too
> | scared to rely on my control of my mind...." The taking of medication
> | in many cases should be in consort with meditation not in lieu of
> | them. I believe any teacher of any lineage would agree with this.
> | [Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
> | ------------------------------------
> | Yahoo! Groups Links
> -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
> Version: GnuPG v1.4.0 (GNU/Linux)
> -----END PGP SIGNATURE-----
- << Previous post in topic