Re: [Asatru-U] Re: Introduction
- Heilsa Michael,
I don't think so. The lore is a tool that is used to
find out what it meant to be and can mean to us to be
heathen. If you make it into a 'holy book' then you
chance people making it holy, beyond debate and
question, which of course is ridiculous. Let's take
the Poetic Edda as an example. It was written by
Snorri not as a guide or a preservation of the heathen
ways, but as a preservation of a particular group of
people's style of poetry. There are many places in it
that are doubtful as being part of the original lore
or they are out of place. Instead it is believed that
Snorri himself added them or rearranged them in order
to make the meters sound more fluid. So what would we
be making holy? The unquestionable way of our
ancestors(which by the way didn't exist - much of it
was regional)? or a christian's attempt to save a
style of poetry? Which is which? Which lore is more
valuable? As a wife, mother and grandmother I doubt my
choices would be the same as yours. Who would get to
decide which lore to use? Believe me, each group or
organization would have their own idea on that one.
Think about it. The three subcategories - folkish,
tribalist, universalist - of heathenism trying to
decide who gets to decide. They would be arguing
about it until our children were old.
My 2 cents,
Judy (who did not intend to offend anyone and hopes
--- michael cole <michael5160@...> wrote:
> I agree. I would like to pose this question to the__________________________________________________
> group. Should our lore be compiled (and I hate to
> use this phrase but I cannot as such, see a better
> term) in a sort of 'holy book' or is this something
> you feel we should avoid like the plague?
> If we did do a sort of complilation, what should
> it include?
> And does anyone know of a good book on the
> havamaal out there?
> County of Orange
> Larisa Pole <larisapole@...> wrote:
> Thank You Manny! I could not agree more. I
> hope that my comments
> were not in offense. In regards to your statement, I
> would like to
> offer Asatru U something.
> We at Kenaz Kindred have been holding an in person
> Rune Workshop,
> but are now branching out to offer it online. It is
> an intense 7
> week course, that goes into detail about runes! If
> anyone is
> interested than please contact me, and I will inform
> you of the
> release date!
> --- In Asatru-U@yahoogroups.com, "Manny Olds"
> <oldsma@...> wrote:
> > I'm sorry to be slow, but apparently not all the
> group mail has
> > making it to my box. My OFFICIAL GROUP-OWNER
> comments below.
> > On 10/24/06, Michael Sanngetalsson
> <sanngetalsson@...> wrote:
> > > Greetings all!
> > >
> > > My name is Mike, frequent lurker in many groups
> until see a post
> > > the immediate one I'm replying to.
> > >
> > > Ancestry has EVERYTHING to do with Asatru and/or
> > > this may not conform to the pure education
> centered focus of
> this group.
> > >
> > > There are many people such as Lissa who believe
> this way and
> > > fine. I specifically cannot say whether this is
> a way of life for
> > > promoting tolerance and/or acceptance as I
> condone neither.
> > >
> > > And there are those such as myself who are
> strongly against
> > > known as PC-atru that alot of post-Wiccans hold
> > > Closet-Folk lovers who are not publicly proud of
> > > or folk.
> > Number 1: No name-calling on this list. Period.
> Stop it now, any
> > and all of you.
> > Number 2: The purpose of this group is to develop
> a curriculum
> > material as required) for online Asatru/heathen
> Period. I
> > allow "Hey, I'm a new heathen" posts in the hope
> it will lead to a
> > discussion of what those new heathens want or
> > The appropriate response to a disagreement is not
> to detail The One
> > True Way you follow, but to open a discussion
> about how to explain
> > differences between your One Way and the One Way
> of other heathens.
> > Pointing to useful source material is appropriate;
> urging others to
> > Repent, etc. is not.
> > I regret that my own life complications have kept
> my attention away
> > from this group for a while and I have been King
> Log. You don't
> > to see King Stork, though, so please cut this out
> and police your
> > behavior like responsible sapients.
> > Ár ok Frið,
> > Manny Olds
> Hail to the Æsir!
> Hail to the Asyniur!
> Hail to the bounteous earth!
> Words and wisdom give to us noble twain,
> and healing hands while we live
> [Non-text portions of this message have been
Do You Yahoo!?
Tired of spam? Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around
- I rely on history, archeology and the Havamal to base my beliefs on. I
have learned a lot about AsaTru and myself through the Havamal. If you
wish to learn more about AsaTru and yourself then you might consider reading
and meditating on the sayings of Hal. The sagas are also a good source to
learn about the Norse and their beliefs.
Just my two cents worth.
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]