Re: OFFICIAL? VUCC will not be offered via LOTW anytime soon
- Well, I dont think screen dumps are going to be the solution. I
happened to have a conversation with someone this afternoon who is
familiar with the issue and a part of the ARRL field organization. He
said it was the intent to have LOTW track and submit ALL ARRL awards
and they have been dragging their feet to get it going. He believes,
as I do, it will not require a major software change to implement
VUCC since grid squares are a parameter in the system. It just take
some programming changes to have grids recognized as "entities".
Awards via LOTW are a benefit of ARRL membership. The amateur
community should be able to take full advantage of the benefits of
using LOTW. As K3KO noted he was also told "no" last year, at a
minimum the ARRL should implement a plan to implement VUCC and other
awards in atimely and reasonable manner. It is a win/win situation
for both sides: LOTW users save money on postage/printing costs and
the ARRL makes money off of the credits purchased for awards.
I am awaiting an official answer from my division director which will
take a few days Im sure. I will keep the thread updated.
--- In ARRL-LOTW@yahoogroups.com, "Robert Chudek" <k0rc@...> wrote:
> If the ARRL starts accepting screen dumps for verifications, you
might as well throw the entire LoTW security system out the window.
> This screen dump concept came up a while back. I proved to the
fellow that *I* worked the particular DX station he was submitting,
not him. I used simple PDF editing tools, removed his callsign and
inserted mine. This is no smoke and mirrors, just everyday graphic
> What the ARRL is telling you is the way to get VUCC credit right
now is to exchange a printed QSL card. The CQ awards manager... well
that's a different organization with a different level of security.
> 73 de Bob - KØRC in MN
> ----- Original Message -----
> From: Brian Alsop
> To: ARRL-LOTW@yahoogroups.com
> Sent: Friday, June 29, 2007 3:36 PM
> Subject: Re: [ARRL-LOTW] OFFICIAL? VUCC will not be offered via
LOTW anytime soon
> I got the same answer last year.
> Perhaps it is not worth the programming effort. However, there
> be some way to get credit-- even if it is a hokey.
> I proposed to the local VUCC checker that I make a copy of the
> screen dump for each LoTW QSL.
> They can all be put into a single Word or WordPerfect document.
> put that on a CD and mail it to the checker.
> If that wouldn't be secure enough, I offered to sit down with the
> checker and show him the LoTW QSL's while logged into LoTW. He is
> checking with ARRL on this.
> I understand CQ checkers accept such screen dumps for their
> I have 125 grids, many new, already confirmed via LOTW and they
> currently worthless.
> 73 de Brian/K3KO
> cord72501 wrote:
> >I sent an email to the ARRL asking what the timeframe is to
> >via LOTW. They referred me to one of their programmers. He
> >replied "There are no present plans to offer VUCC via LoTW." OK,
> >him some more questions and this is what I get:
> >I didn't say it would never happen, it's just not in the present
> >It's certainly something we are interested in, but given our
> >resources, the costs involved, and the anticipated level of
> >taken together, VUCC via LoTW just hasn't made it into the plan
> >the other things we have on our plate.
> >This reply only opens up more questions to ask what the holdup
> >Additionally, it appears the ARRL is underestimating the number
> >VHFers who are waiting for VUCC to become available via LOTW. I
> >going to ask my division director for a better answer.
> >Stay tuned.
> >Cord KD5J