--- In firstname.lastname@example.org
> I have been a member of this forum for years but have never been
> compelled to post, but I have enjoyed the discussions on the history
> of Gnosticism, I have definitely learned a thing or two from this
> place about historical Gnosticism (especially from PMCV - btw I am
> apart of The_Way forums and I participate often on there and I am
> apart of the Gnostic Pearl msn forum, where I am having a dispute
> an individual about Gnosticism). But I have a bit of an issue.
> from another forum, once told me this, "Zoroaster was the first
> historical personality to attain Gnosis." and how a person isn't a
> Gnostic unless they find agreement or are in harmony with what
> Zoroaster taught. He goes on to explain how Zoroaster influenced
> everything, and is pretty much where Gnosticism came from. Should I
> inform myself on Persian influence via Zoroastrism on Grecian
> and pretty much on Gnosticism in general to be well informed about
> While I will not ask this individual about it, because he has an
> with me and I don't believe Zoroastrism really is that much like
> Gnosticism, the little that I have read up on it (its essential
> themes). So I am asking here since many of the individuals here know
> their stuff and can shed light on the historical significance of
> Zoroastrism on Gnosticism. Admittedly I am not a historian or
> which is why if I Zoroastrism is that relevant as this individual
> claims, then I should really not say a word about Gnosticism.
Greetings, Ra. I notice no one has jumped in yet to respond to you.
Perhaps they feel as I do in that I don't want to become involved
here in a dispute occurring in a different forum, particularly when
one member apparently has a very strong belief about which historical
personality was the first to attain gnosis.
That said, I see no problem in investigating influences that
contributed to the various syncretistic historical Gnostic groups.
I'm going to throw the ball back in your yard. You say you've read a
little about Zorastrianism. As far as our interest in this forum, on
one hand, how closely did any various historical Gnostic groups
identify themselves with Zoroaster? To what extent did they
find `agreement' with what Zoroaster taught? On the other hand, upon
examination, what types of Zoroastrian influences do you find in the
ancient Gnostic sects, their cosmologies, etc.? And in what ways do
Anyone care to bounce around some ideas or offer some readings we can