I just returned from the American Bee Research Conference in Orlando Florida where a Bayer representative presented research using Movento on an orchard inMessage 1 of 5 , Jan 20, 2010View Source
RE: [beemonitoring] Judge Pulls Pesticide (additional articles and judge's order)
I just returned from the American Bee Research Conference in Orlando Florida where a Bayer representative presented research using Movento on an orchard in bloom with honey bee colonies in the field. His study showed no negative impacts by using Movento during bloom. His talk went right up to 15 minutes and left no time for questions, but requests for questions came from the audience, so at the end of the conference he returned to the podium. One, of multiple critical questions, came from a man, that I was told, was one of the co-operator/beekeeper's son. Not sure if that part is right, but this individual had visited these beehives recently and reported all but two were dead and asked why this was not included in the results. The Bayer representative said the study ended in October, at which time the hives were still alive. The hives died after October.
This evidence suggests to me that co-operators of the above 'study' are not in agreement of the methods or results.
The University of Tennessee
Phone: (865) 804-6486
From: email@example.com on behalf of Weber, Don
Sent: Wed 1/6/2010 11:52 AM
To: T'ai Roulston
Subject: RE: [beemonitoring] Judge Pulls Pesticide (additional articles and judge's order)
These additional articles have additional info:
and the judge's order:
Donald C. Weber, Research Entomologist & Lead Scientist
USDA Agricultural Research Service
Invasive Insect Biocontrol & Behavior Laboratory
Bldg. 011A, Rm. 107, BARC-West Beltsville, MD 20705 USA
[mailto:firstname.lastname@example.org] On Behalf Of T'ai Roulston
Sent: Wednesday, January 06, 2010 11:28
To: Stoner, Kimberly
Subject: Re: [beemonitoring] Big Win for Bees: Judge Pulls Pesticide
From my understanding it was not pulled because of its effects on honey
bees but because of improper protocol (lack of advance notice and public
comment). EPA will have to determine whether the acknowledged harm to
larval bees through direct exposure is likely to have an effect on
colonies in field settings. So if this is a victory for honey bees it
may be temporary.
On Jan 6, 2010, at 10:42 AM, Stoner, Kimberly wrote:
Hi Bee Monitoring group:
I don't know how much overlap there is between this group and the
Pollinator list, where this already appeared, but I thought this would
be of interest. This is a very unusual event - to have a pesticide
pulled from the market because of its effects on honey bees - and so
quickly! Movento just went on the market on a large scale last year.
Big Win for Bees: Judge Pulls Pesticide
NEW YORK (December 29, 2009) - A pesticide that could be dangerously
toxic to America's honey bees must be pulled from store shelves as a
result of a suit filed by the Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC)
and the Xerces Society. In an order issued last week, a federal court
in New York invalidated EPA's approval of the pesticide spirotetramat
(manufactured by Bayer CropScience under the trade names Movento and
Ultor) and ordered the agency to reevaluate the chemical in compliance
with the law. The court's order goes into effect on January 15, 2010,
and makes future sales of Movento illegal in the United States
Bayer 'Disappointed' in Ruling on Chemical That May Harm Bees
By Alan Bjerga
Dec. 29 (Bloomberg) -- A Bayer AG unit is "disappointed" by a U.S.
judge's ruling that may prevent distribution of its spirotetramat
insecticide, a spokesman said. Environmental groups say the chemical
causes harm to honeybees.
U.S. District Court Judge Denise Cote on Dec. 23 ordered the
Environmental Protection Agency to rescind approval for spirotetramat,
which inhibits cell reproduction in insects. Cote said the EPA didn't
properly seek comments or publicize the review process. The judge in
New York ordered the ruling stayed until Jan. 15 and sent the matter
back to the EPA.
Spirotetramat, sold under various names including Movento, was
approved for use in the U.S. last year, even though the agency was
aware of its potential harm to bees, Cote said. The Natural Resources
Defense Council, an environmental organization in New York, and the
Xerces Society, a Portland, Oregon, a wildlife conservation group,
challenged the EPA's actions.
The insecticide is fit for use and the ruling is based on EPA
processes rather than product safety, Jack Boyne, a spokesman for
Bayer CropScience LP, a unit of the Leverkusen, Germany-based company,
said in a statement. The chemical "has shown excellent performance
with regard to bee safety," he said. Bayer is "evaluating our options"
on how to respond to Cote's ruling, he said.
Pest killers have been linked to honeybee colony collapse disorder, or
mass deaths of the insects, which have been reported since 2006. Bees
pollinate $15 billion of U.S. plants each year, according to the U.S.
Department of Agriculture.
Viruses, mites, pesticides and poor bee treatment have been suggested
as primary causes of the disorder, which has been reported in at least
35 states, as well as in Europe and Asia. The Bayer insecticide was
approved in Australia in August, and the company said at the time that
it also had been cleared for use in Canada and Austria.
National Pollinator Outreach Coordinator
The Xerces Society for Invertebrate Conservation
Tel: 608-628-4951 Fax: 503-233-6794
Email: eric@... <mailto:eric%40xerces.org>
Assistant Professor of Extension
University of Minnesota - Department of Entomology
Email: made0002@... <mailto:made0002%40umn.edu>
The Xerces Society is an international nonprofit organization that
protects wildlife through the conservation of invertebrates and their
habitat. Our Pollinator Conservation Program works to support the
sustainability and profitability of farms while protecting pollinator
insects. To join the Society, make a contribution, or read about our
work, please visit www.xerces.org <http://www.xerces.org> .
Pollinator mailing list
Curator, State Arboretum of Virginia
Research Assoc. Prof., Dept of Envi. Sci.
University of Virginia