'Christian Conferencing' Follows Demonstration
By Linda Bloom*
May 1, 2008
FORT WORTH, Texas (UMNS) Relationships established before the 2008
United Methodist General Conference began helped temper a May 1
response to that body's decision not to change the denomination's
current positions on homosexuality, according to some participants.
During a press conference after a "witness" was made on the General
Conference floor by supporters of lesbian, bisexual, gay and
transgendered people, Bishop Gregory Palmer, president of the United
Methodist Council of Bishops, said he had a "deep sense of gratitude"
for both how the witness was handled and how delegates and bishops
The 15-minute demonstration was in reaction to the April 30 decision
to retain the denomination's decades-old proscription describing
homosexual practice as "incompatible with Christian teaching." One
protester, Audrey Krumbach, read a statement declaring that the
"anti-gay policies of The United Methodist Church are wrong and sinful
in the sight of God."
Afterward, 16 bishops met with the witnesses advocating for full
inclusion and created a table for Christian conferencing and
acknowledgement of the pain felt by some church members. "We went into
a time of discussion, speaking from our hearts as much as our heads,"
said Bishop Sally Dyck.
Team-building eased tension
The Rev. Troy Plummer, executive director of the Reconciling
Ministries Network, noted that "today was a better day than
yesterday." He thanked the team from JUSTPEACE, a mission of the
church for mediation and conflict transformation, for helping
participants in the discussion to "overcome some sticking points."
"In shock" over the outcome of the April 30 vote, Plummer said it was
only the team-building which occurred before General Conference that
prevented a response of civil disobedience.
Bishop Scott Jones said he had only joined those conversations today
as a volunteer for the Council of Bishops, but supported the effort
because he has "a ministry of bridge building."
On May 2, the last day of General Conference, those involved in the
conversations will focus on how to proceed, according to Dyck. "We do
want to build on relationships and trust so we can use this as an
opportunity for new hope to emerge," she said.
The Rev. Gail Murphy-Geiss, chair of the Commission on General
Conference, addressed the concern over the fact that the demonstration
appeared to be cut off from the live Internet feed of that plenary
session. "It was definitely an accident," she said. "The plug was not
Even though it was not shown live, Murphy-Geiss said the event was
recorded and has since been uploaded to the General Conference Web
Decision 1032 still troubles some
Plummer said that he was most troubled about the vote to let stand
language in the Book of Discipline regarding pastoral authority over
church membership, even though a majority report of a legislative
committee recommended the congregation change the language to make it
clear that pastors and congregations "are to faithfully receive all
persons who are willing to affirm our vows of membership."
Controversy has occurred over a 2005 decision by the United Methodist
Judicial Council No. 1032 supporting the Rev. Ed Johnson of
Virginia who denied membership to a man who was in an openly
homosexual relationship. The council reinstated Johnson after he had
been placed on involuntary leave by the Virginia Annual (regional)
"It's very dismaying to leave this General Conference with 1032 still
in place. That's a grief for our people," Plummer said, adding that he
hoped the new Judicial Council "might somehow be asked to reconsider
Jones said that 1032 and a similar case cited "are in my experience,
isolated cases" and he believes that 99 percent of the church does not
discriminate in this way.
*Bloom is a United Methodist News Service writer based in New York.