On Thursday, March 29, 2007 at 17:09, Sacha Griffin wrote:
> Perhaps years ago.. Anything "years ago" concerning software is irrelevant.
Well, scanning gets more and more irrelevant...
> I'd advise you to check out their demo software. Very nice.
Why should I. I would have to redo all of my workflow I spend years
to develop for Vuescan, and still am not sure whether I can do
anything I need with silverfast. Frankly: I don't think it is
possible to get better results from my scanner than I get now.
And I don't like their price policy: For any feature and any scanner
you need a different version. To store f.e. scan files with 16
bit/channel you need "Silverfast HDR" (bah - 16 bit isn't HDR). And
they still don't save the IR channel that my scanner has (to enable
IR based dust and scratch removal) like Vuescan does.
Now, in version 6.5 they announce as a major feature "Multi Exposure"
- something Vuescan did for ages. But what they don't say is that
multi pass multi scan isn't worth anything for a film scanner, you
need one capable of single pass multi scan.
And so on...
Vuescan gives me all I need for all scanners, all bit depth, all
specials and unlimited upgrades for a fraction of the price of one
silverfast product. And I successfully suggested numerous features to
Ed Hamrick (programmer of Vuescan) whereas I didn't get Silverfast
even to send me a correct serial number (until Karl-Heinz Zahorsky
Copyright (c) 2007 Erik Krause
Verbatim copying and distribution strictly forbidden
except those allowed in wiki.panotools.org/User_Guidelines