Pi: I guess with the YEC black and white mentality, I shouldn t be surprised you wouldn t see a difference between calling an argument lamebrained andMessage 1 of 1 , Sep 30, 2010View SourcePi:
I guess with the YEC "black and white" mentality, I shouldn't be surprised you wouldn't see a difference between calling an argument "lamebrained" and calling the person "lamebrained."
I don't agree with this "distinction without a difference." I can say "that's a stupid thing to say" or I can say "you are stupid for saying that."
Reminds me of the ESPN commercial about 10 years ago. Some coach-type guy is in a room full of journalists and one gets up to say "I have a stupid question to ask..." and the coach interrupts to say, "Wait Jimmie, there ARE NO stupid questions. Just stupid PEOPLE who ask questions."
Sorry...I think in the moment that a person makes a stupid comment, he is being stupid. Oh wait...is there a difference between saying "he is
stupid" vs. "he is BEING stupid"??? HMMMM.
Let's bring this back to the original comment that started the whole thing. David wrote:
".... I do want others who read these exchanges to see how lamebrained you are to think ...."
I responded by paraphrasing David with:
"They will also see how stupid you are to think ...."
David seems to think his comment was OK, but mine wasn't. HMMMMM.......
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]