Right of Reply: Our suffering should be the basis for cooperation, not
By BARRY RUBIN <mailto:editors@...
While I have great respect for Efraim Zuroff, I disagree with several points
in his "Of insult and mockery" (December 23). He should continue his
worthwhile battles, but other voices and viewpoints should also be heard.
Lithuanian Foreign Minister...
Lithuanian Foreign Minister Vygaudas Usackas rekindles the Eternal flame at
the Hall of Remembrance at Yad Vashem, Jerusalem, Thursday.
Central to Zuroff's argument is the claim that any emphasis by Central
European countries regarding their own suffering during World War II -
especially if it focuses on the oppression of the Stalinist USSR - is
somehow a challenge to the uniqueness and importance of the mass murder of
Jews in those countries. Indeed, it is implied that this effort borders on
or even exemplifies anti-Semitism.
This argument is fallacious and a strategic mistake. It is never a good idea
to conceal history. Due to the existence of the Soviet Union and Soviet Bloc
until 1991, the truth about the terrible oppression of Lithuanians,
Latvians, Poles, Ukrainians and others was hidden away from the world until
recently. As part of their national reassertion, these peoples want to
highlight what happened to them and the full horror of their sufferings.
They have every right to do so. And why should we oppose this, as long as it
does not come with the ignoring or justification of the Holocaust? Instead,
we should fully participate, as Jews and Israelis, in this process for
several good reasons.
ONE FACTOR is that many Jews were among the victims of Soviet repression. In
the Lithuanian museum in Vilnius, housed in the former KGB headquarters, it
is pointed out that about 10 percent of those deported by the Soviets in
1940-1941 were Jews. One of them was Menachem Begin. Although being sent to
Siberia saved those who survived those camps, this was not the intention.
Almost 1,000 Jews were massacred by the KGB in the Katyn forest, along with
thousands of Poles. Is the blood of these Jews and of the tens of thousands
who perished in the Soviet gulag of lesser value than those murdered by the
Indeed, even if it came a distant second to the Nazis, the Stalin regime
also targeted Jews and greatly contributed to their suffering. If it had not
been for the Soviet-Nazi alliance, Hitler might not have been able to start
the war in the first place. Stalin turned over some Jewish leaders to the
Nazis, and being a Zionist was a criminal offense under the Soviet regime,
including in the countries conquered by Moscow during the war.
A second reason we should join with Central Europeans in commemorating and
revealing the true extent of this repression and mass murder is to help Jews
and others understand today that anti-Semitism is not a monopoly of the
political Right. This is of high importance at a time when the main source
of anti-Semitism, along with hatred of Jews and Israel in the West, is from
a Left that justifies itself by claiming that it is immune to that
Third, the idea that Jews should only deal with Central Europeans nowadays
by demanding they endlessly proclaim their guilt over the Holocaust is
counterproductive, likely to produce resentment rather than acknowledgement
of responsibility and true repentence. Taking such an approach while
refusing to heed their historic suffering at the hands of others is setting
up a conflict exploited by anti-Semitic elements. We should engage in a
dialogue in which we respect their historical experience, which is also that
of many Jews. On this basis of solidarity against totalitarianism, we can
stand together as friends.
In fact, these are precisely issues on which we need to cooperate today. At
a time when nationalism is viewed as an unacceptable evil, we should affirm
the importance of our shared belief in the preciousness of our peoplehood.
We share, too, the experience of knowing that the threats of those who would
wipe us off the map must be taken seriously.
THESE ARE complex issues. To cite my family's experience, the Soviets
imprisoned my Zionist uncle in a cell with members of the Polish and
Lithuanian anti-Soviet resistance; some relatives were deported to Siberia,
others were saved from the Nazis by Polish collaborationist police who were
secretly members of the Polish nationalist underground; still others were
turned in by their Polish neighbors; and some were murdered by Lithuanian
security police units; while others were saved by Red Army partisans but
then kept as prisoners in the USSR for 12 years.
Zuroff ridicules the Lithuanian foreign minister for asking, "How could it
be that while some Lithuanians were risking their lives to save their Jewish
neighbors, others were committing crimes by sending them to death?" Zuroff
is right in saying that far more were committing crimes than saving
neighbors. But the foreign minister is asking a central question: How did
people in each of these countries choose sides, and what can we learn from
FINALLY, THERE is the question of the Jewish communists, some of whom
tortured and murdered locals - including other Jews - in the service of the
Soviet secret police. Anti-Semites use this to stir up anti-Jewish hatred,
just as the Nazis did (a point well made in Latvia's museum on both the
Holocaust and the oppression by Germans and Soviet occupiers). By refusing
to deal with this issue, we only help them do so. We should discuss this
issue honestly. Just as the action of Nazi collaborators did not turn whole
countries into war criminals, all Jews should not be held responsible for
the deeds of a tiny minority. Moreover, these people did not act as Jews but
as enemies of the Jewish people.
It is an important lesson for Jews to understand how some of their number
betrayed them. Jewish communists led the way in destroying the Jewish
religion, language and culture in the Soviet Union and satellite states.
This is an important lesson for today, when Jewish extreme leftists smear
Israel and endeavor to hurt or destroy it.
In short, it is in our moral and political interest to join with Central
Europeans in seeking to understand the truth about the past and its
significance for the present. That includes acknowledging their suffering
from both the Nazis and Stalinists during World War II, and the latter for
the half-century thereafter.
The writer is a columnist for The Jerusalem Post.
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]