Bill,
I was not satisfied with the stock filter in the Pro3. After a
few weeks of use, I bought the INRAD mod and had it installed. Now I don’t
have the pumping action when you and Bill W7GKF are violating my rightful place
on whatever band I choose to operate. After all, you guys have amps and I don’t.
(tongue firmly in cheek)
73 Paul NG7Z
From: William Trippett
[mailto:w7vp@...]
Sent: Tuesday, July 14, 2009 8:43 AM
To: wwdxc@yahoogroups.com
Subject: [wwdxc] Re: pro 3, or FT-2000
Mark:
Au Contrare
The real question is if you want to buy a radio that was unfinished when it was
first released and still is subject to a number of serious deficiencies that
have resulted in a serious decrease in its sales price.
The FT-2000 is the subject of a substantial controversy. You can read my
complete review of the problems tha led to me selling mine on the eHam foums.
One has to be very careful who to listen to regarding the FT-2000. The oiginal
forum called the ft-2000 group became a place where anyone who offered any
criticism of the rig was subjected to insufferable flaming and slander. Even
one of the original moderators of that group, a highly respected RF engineer,
finally became so disgusted he quit. As a reault unless you are simply an ESSB
fan you will not get any honest evaluation of the FT-2000 on that forum and
virtaully all of those who are technically qualified have abandoned it.
A second open forum called the FT2000_new was formed where serious criticism
and evaluation of the rig has taken place without the flaming that was the
hallmark of the original forum. Several of the participants in that forum are
incredibly gifted techs and rf engineers.
While Yaesu has offered a series of software and firmware updates to the
fT-2000 you can read the reuslts on the FT2000_new forum to the effect that
when one lump is pushed down another pops up. So some of those who are serioulsy
trying to overcome the original limitations of the rig have resorted to mixing
and matching the releases - a daunting task indeed. Moreover Yaesu has not made
any effort to resolve the hardware deficiencies in the rig.
For example, it was discovered early on that the 3 kHz roofing filter was
seriouly flawed and that the 3 Khz was measured at 3 dB down the profile
instead of 6 dB as is the industry standard. In addition, even with that
measurment deficiency the 2 kHz IMDDR was simply not state-of-the-art, even if
it was accepted as -68 dBm, which is also in doubt as confirmed by several
highly qualified techs including Rob Sherman. (Note even Sherman was flamed
when he reported his findings).
Recently several mods have been proposed and installed using INRAD filters and
another one is in the works with an even better filter design. Even with the
INRAD filter the 2 KhZ IMDDR was increased to over -80 dBm, which is much
better for contesters but still not as good as the K3 for example.
Many contesters have been very critical of the FT-2000, particularly those in
europe. Numerous problems with intermod distoriton have been reported with some
claiming that the rig was simply not usable in highly congested contest
situations.
In the end it depends on what you intend to do with the rig. I suggest you read
the messges opn the FT2000_new forum to get a better understanding of the
problems suffered by its owners.
I was very sorry to have to part with what is otherwise a beautiful rig. But
until Yaesu steps up to the plate (as they have with the 9000 it will be my
last Yaesu rig.
BTW, the rig I replaced it with is the ICOM 756 PRO III which I have set up in
an SO2R configuration with a Kenwood TS-940SAT. (My article on this setup is
sechduled to be published in the National Contest Journal Sept. Oct. issue).
73
Bill
W7VP
--- In wwdxc@yahoogroups.com,
"JAMES ROCKEY" <roccoj1@...> wrote:
>
> Well if you want a discontinued radio that cannot be updated, the Pro III
is
> it. I have the FT-2000 great radio. They have really improved it . It is
> firmware Updateable.
>
> JIM,WA7SRZ
>
>
>
> -----Original Message-----
> From: wwdxc@yahoogroups.com
[mailto:wwdxc@yahoogroups.com] On
Behalf Of Mark
> Tharp
> Sent: Tuesday, July 07, 2009 7:08 PM
> To: wwdxc@yahoogroups.com
> Subject: [wwdxc] pro 3, or FT-2000
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
> Anyone have pros, and or cons, on the two rigs, Looking to trade out the
old
> iron, and would like some feedback on the two radios.
>
> FT2000, not the D, so can run on 12 volts,
>
> and IC-756 pro 3.
>
>
>
> thanks..
>
> Mark
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
> Mark J. Tharp
> KB7HDX
> ARRL Section Mgr. EWA
> http://www.arrl. <http://www.arrl.org> org
>