Search the web
Sign In
New User? Sign Up
theos-talk · discussion list to go with THEOSOPHY WORLD
? Already a member? Sign in to Yahoo!

Yahoo! Groups Tips

Did you know...
Show off your group to the world. Share a photo of your group with us.

Best of Y! Groups

   Check them out and nominate your group.
Having problems with message search? Fill out this form to ensure your group is one of the first to be migrated to the new message search system.

Messages

  Messages Help
Advanced
Re: Theos-World Re: Dr. Vernon Harrison on the Hodgson Report and t   Message List  
Reply | Forward Message #8408 of 53315 |
Bart's Latest Statement

Bart, you wrote:

"When Hodgson took 'samples' of Blavatsky's handwriting and Mahatma
Letters to a handwriting analyst, it appears that they were not
originals; they were copies that Hodgson made himself. No wonder his
analyst said they came from the same person."

Bart, as far as I can ascertain, your statement is wrong and somehow
you have been misinformed.

Both Netherclift and Sims saw and examined the originals of certain
Mahatma as well as certain Blavatsky letters.

For example, on pp. 282-283 of Hodgson's Report, we find Hodgson
writing as follows:

"With the incriminating Blavatsky-Coulomb letters which were
submitted to Mr. Netherclift, were also submitted some specimens of
the K.H. writing, viz., several small slips which were forwarded from
India with the Blavatsky-Coulomb letters proper, a K.H. document in
blue ink submitted by Mr. Massey, and a K.H. document in blue pencil
sumbitted by Mr. Myers. Mr. Netherclift, in the first instance, came
to the conclusion that these K.H. documents were not written by
Madame Blavatsky. . . . In the meantime we had obtained from Mr.
Sinnett eight specimens of the K.H. writing, which represented, some
of them at least, consecutive periods of time, beginning with the
earliest letter received by Mr. Sinnett. . . . I therefore re-
submitted to him the K.H. writings belonging to Messrs. Massey and
Myers, which we still had in our possession, together with the series
forwarded by Mr. Sinnett. . . .The result was that Mr. Netherclift
came to the conclusion that the whole of these documents were without
doubt written by Madame Blavatsky. Mr. Sims, of the British Museum,
similarly changed his opinion after inspection of the documents
furnished by Mr. Sinnett."

Further down page 283, Hodgson again writes about ". . . the series
of K.H. Letters lent by Mr. Sinnett. . . "

As far as I can tell, we are dealing with the originals LENT by
Massey, Myers and Sinnett. All three of these gentlemen lived in
England.

The same can be said of the relevant Blavatsky letters. Netherclift
and Sims saw and examined the originals.

It is true, I believe, that the reproductions of the Blavatsky and
Mahatma letters in the 2 Plates in the Hodgson Report were traced
from the originals. I would have to verify that statement to be 100%
certain.

This will have to suffice for now.

Daniel










Mon Nov 4, 2002 1:33 am

danielhcaldwell
Offline Offline
Send Email Send Email

Forward
Message #8408 of 53315 |
Expand Messages Author Sort by Date

... When Hodgson took "samples" of Blavatsky's handwriting and Mahatma Letters to a handwriting analyst, it appears that they were not originals; they were...
Bart Lidofsky
bml07646
Offline Send Email
Nov 3, 2002
11:10 pm

... Mahatma ... The "experts" (one of whom was not an expert by any standard of assessment) were badgered by Hodgson into making those statements. It was...
Steve Stubbs
stevestubbs
Offline Send Email
Nov 4, 2002
1:25 am

Henry S. Olcott Simla, India October 4, 1880. ... Then Major Henderson asked her [Madame Blavatsky] to explain the science of it, but she said she could not,...
Daniel H. Caldwell
danielhcaldwell
Offline Send Email
Nov 4, 2002
2:27 am

Brian: Count Witte Blavatsky's relative wrote Blavatsky used to run an ink and paper store. And J. Godwin who wrote the famous book "The Theosophical...
brianmuehlbach
Offline Send Email
Nov 12, 2002
2:52 pm

... an ink ... ******* Brian, I thought you were leaving? Well, glad you changed your mind. Or maybe you said you would not waste any more time trying to ...
netemara888
Offline Send Email
Nov 13, 2002
3:05 am

netemara: Anyway, where is the reference, what book has this reference that Helena used to run an ink and paper store? Was it in Russia? In russia yes, and it...
brianmuehlbach
Offline Send Email
Nov 13, 2002
4:41 pm

Netemara: here the actual reference from Count Witt's Diary about Blavatsky's inkschop ans special writigsckils: "She was next heard of from Odessa, where she...
brianmuehlbach
Offline Send Email
Nov 13, 2002
4:56 pm

Brian/Brigitte writes: ". . . here the actual reference from Count Witt's Diary about Blavatsky's inkschop ans special writigsckils. . . . " Actually Brian...
Daniel H. Caldwell
danielhcaldwell
Offline Send Email
Nov 13, 2002
5:11 pm

Brian you make me laugh. Now, how could anyone dislike someone that versatile, talented, and dare say I influential? Netemara **************- ... settled ... ...
netemara888
Offline Send Email
Nov 14, 2002
1:22 am

Steve: It was Besant who said Blavatsky disguised her handwriting for mahatma letters. In the case of the Prayah letter she did not disguie her handwriting,...
brianmuehlbach
Offline Send Email
Nov 4, 2002
12:12 pm

Steve, You wrote: "It was Besant who said Blavatsky disguised her handwriting for mahatma letters." Steve, can you please give us your source for...
Daniel H. Caldwell
danielhcaldwell
Offline Send Email
Nov 4, 2002
6:20 pm

Caldwell: But why should we accept what Mrs. Besant said about this? What did Mrs. Besant actually know about this matter? Brian: A lot, Blavatsky lived at...
brianmuehlbach
Offline Send Email
Nov 4, 2002
6:31 pm

... Of course I can. OK, OK, I'll tell you. I found this statement in the book THE THEOSOPHICAL MOVEMENT. This is from memory, Besant accused Judge of ...
Steve Stubbs
stevestubbs
Offline Send Email
Nov 4, 2002
7:24 pm

Bart, you wrote: "When Hodgson took 'samples' of Blavatsky's handwriting and Mahatma Letters to a handwriting analyst, it appears that they were not originals;...
Daniel H. Caldwell
danielhcaldwell
Offline Send Email
Nov 4, 2002
1:33 am
Advanced

Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Inc. All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy - Terms of Service - Guidelines - Help