Dear Dr. Head, Just a few quick replies: PH: ... "It is insufficient in this connection since it is about Codex Sinaiticus!" Ach; sleepy me. Still, taking...
Marginally relevant: There is a novel by Paul L. Maier called "A Skeleton in God's Closet" where a sentence is discovered at the end of Vaticanus Mark 16 using...
Most of you will probably recall the recent articles in the popular media about new imaging techniques being used on the Oxyrhynchus papyri, and the more...
The following book. How useful is it. Ehrman, Bart D. The Orthodox corruption of scripture : the effect of early Christological controversies on the text of...
Hello, Group Though I'm a complete novice (if not ignoramus) re: textual criticism, I have a question or two pertaining to the subject, if I may. I have read...
The papyrus has been published already in 2000: DC Parker "A new Oxryrhynchus Papyrus of Revelation: P115 (P. Oxy. 4499)", New Testament Studies 46 (2000), pp....
802
Gie Vleugels
gvleugels@...
May 3, 2005 6:50 am
Bart Ehrman is a very able scholar, and the data that are presented are well documented. However, Ehrman is so keen to prove his point - namely that the...
... Can you give me a reference on that? ... Firstly, the Byzantine manuscripts differ. Some process of copying led to this situation. Now how are you going to...
Additionally one might add that scholars are sometimes biased from their perspective. When you have studied the Byzantine MSS for a long time you have seen...
... I couldn't have said it better. This is one of the books where the footnotes and references, of which there are many, are the most interesting part. Worth...
... When I looked into this issue a while back, it seemed to me that another explanation is that the monks had so memorized the standard text that they...
... Yes. The arguments are often (I might even say usually) rather precarious. There are many interesting points in it. But reading the book requires a lot of...
I am assuming this is a variant, anyone got any ideas which reading it the correct one? Jer 52:12 WBAXODE$ HAXAMIY$IY BE`F&OR In the fifth month and 10th...
One of the main problems with Ehrman's thesis is that the throughly developed, theologically intone OT, from which the NT authors drew their theological...
It seems to me that the Byzantine priority position, ably defended by Maurice Robinson, works best in verses where the textual data are difficult to estimate, ...
Dear Scott, You wrote: "1. Byz and MajT defenders will often appeal to the 'doctored' nature of the Alexandrian text--I'm speaking grammatically, not...
Malcolm, you should aim for more objectivity. You speak from a camp 100% as much as Robinson and everyone else, so why do you tell someone else not to? Acts...
Ron wrote: "Malcolm, you should aim for more objectivity. You speak from a camp 100% as much as Robinson and everyone else, so why do you tell someone else...
Kelton Graham wrote: <<I am assuming this is a variant, anyone got any ideas which reading it the correct one?>> Jer 52:12 In the fifth month on the 10th...
On Tue, 3 May 2005 10:32:16 -0400 (EDT) "Stephen C. Carlson" ... Scott] Thank you for responding, Dr. Carlson. As I understand things, the Lake, Blake and New...
On Tue, 3 May 2005 09:01:24 +0200 "Wieland Willker" ... Scott] Thank you for your reply, Dr. Wieland ! May I ask a follow-up question ? ...Which came first ?...
Here's some data about those asterisks, or four-dot marks, in 2427 (Archaic Mark, Chicago MS 972). (Maybe technically they're not asterisks but I'm going to...
... Which list are we talking about? ... This seems like muddled thinking to me. If all the Kx manuscripts contain a particular error (and all Byzantine...
On Tue, 3 May 2005 14:06:02 -0700 (PDT) malcolm robertson <mjriii2003@...> writes: <snip> Scott was posing questions from the 'pro-Byzantine perspective'...
... I think it depended based on time and place, and all of these suggestions may have each been the local standard at the appropriate times. There is still a...
Please answer the specific questions asked by Scott Ogden. We had those *general* discussions about the Byzantine text in the past, it leads to nothing and we...
... Genetic relatedness among MSS and overall similarity are different issues. In stemmatics, manuscripts are identified as being relate if they show the same...
