Dear George Young: I'm not sure about what you are trying to say. If Scribe A and Scribe B are the same person, then the T. NAZ. in the margin at 16:6 is a...
Dear James Snapp: What I was intending to point out is that even Kirsopp Lake was unable to state definitively that Scribe A and Scribe D are two (2) different...
Dear George Young: Kirsopp Lake DID state definitively that Scribe A and Scribe D are two different hands: "The discrimination of D from A and B is easier and...
Dear James Snapp: Concerning the marginal notes in Sinaiticus, every textual critic should hold them in the highest regard. My understanding of the textual...
How many MSS of James and the Catholic Letters are available at the Institute for New Testament Textual Research and how many were used in the ECM and Text und...
In listing 4 commands that Jesus gives to his 12 disciples when he sent them out, this verse exhibits an interesting 3-way split between the Eclectic,...
... OED gives, both contrary to and in agreement (though concerning French rather than English) with your statement: 2. An original version of a manuscript or...
I've got two emails from list members that their messages did not show up on the list recently. I have no idea what happened. Please resent your lost messages...
Dear George Young: Repeating your statement that K. Lake did not state definitively that Scribe D exists will not make it true. I have already provided the ...
Dear James Snapp/TC List: Concerning the marginal notes in Sinaiticus, I hold them with great interest. My understanding of the textual apparatus in Sinaiticus...
... Thank you for that advice, Tommy. I'll respond later to your specific reading suggestions. But for now, just some points of clarification. I have a...
I don't know if people are aware of this, but I don't suppose that I am the only one with a little pile of these very philologically- oriented editions in a...
... From: sarban To: textualcriticism@yahoogroups.com Sent: Saturday, May 06, 2006 1:11 PM Subject: [textualcriticism] Codex Fuldensis ? Is the text of Codex...
Dear TC List: I understand that the received theory on Sinaiticus' Scribes is that first proposed my Tischendorf. If you have been following the debate between...
... Dear Andrew, Take a look at my web-site -- Best regards, Dave Smith. (B.A.2,1, Science & Technology, Open Univerity.) 168 Bristol Road, Frampton Cotterell,...
... Where can one get more information on the history of these marks and something solid on their interpretation (and possible historical misinterpretation)? ...
James, ... Probably not on the same page. I haven't had time to respond in detail. My advice was very general, i.e. some bibliographic references that I ...
... From: David R Smith To: textualcriticism@yahoogroups.com Sent: Sunday, May 07, 2006 12:46 AM Subject: Re: [textualcriticism] Codex Fuldensis ? Dear Andrew,...
Dear George Young: The most popular analysis of Sinaiticus' scribes is the one by Milne & Skeat, which I mentioned earlier. GY: "If we as textual critics take...
I'm just beginning to read whatever I can find on Gerd Mink's Coherence-Based Genealogical Method used in the production of the ECM volumes. Can anyone give an...
Dear Mr. Young: I have taken a good look at your examples posted on geocities, and I am puzzled by your second example: Quote: " In this second example taken...
Dear James Snapp: ... Not really. My gut feeling is that some contemporary textual critics ignore the critical signs in the ancient MSS saying, "they are all...
Dear Mr. Scrivener: The use of the Asterisk and Obelus in Sinaiticus seems to me to touch on several larger issues. Let me begin my reply with a quote from...
I was looking at your three examples and had the thought that these dimple marks seem to serve a similar purpose to our hyphen. In the 2nd and 3rd examples...
Dear George: It seems to me there are several possibilities, including some association to our hyphen. However, my initial take on the dimple marks is as...
I am looking for the bibliographical details of the editio princeps and any other published editions of the majuscule manuscript 0312 (Cambridge, De Hamel...
Scott, Here you have the first "preliminary report": http://rosetta.reltech.org/TC/vol08/Head2003.html According to footnote: "This announcement is based on...
