With professor Longstaff's permission, I am sending to the list a response to my questions about this passage which he sent to me offline. Since his pointed...
... some form in the much larger Matthew, makes it far >>more likely that Matthew was copying from Mark and not vice versa. Think of them as two editions. In...
... Leonard, That's good of you. ... in theory, are valid? You mentioned, for instance, that Mark may well have intended to add a dramatic dimension to...
Dear Jeffery, As you might expect, I am fascinated by the content of your post. <<<According to some synoptic scholars, the association of the synoptic...
... Mark, We've been here before, so evidently my attempts to explain Occam's razor appear to have failed. :-( Let's try a different tack. It seems rather...
The Columbia Encyclopedia, Sixth Edition. 2001. Synoptic Gospels (snp´tk) (KEY) [Gr. synopsis=view together], the first three Gospels (Matthew, Mark, and...
pardon the cross posting, but i wanted to pass along a web adress that everyone will find valuable. i cant describe it other than to say that it contains...
... Leonard, I've already hinted at one possibility, i.e that Matthew wrote the ... Yes. James had been denigrated by being virtually written out of Mark's...
(With apologies for the double posting to folk on both Synoptic-L and XTalk.) The following summary information compares Q (the hypothetical source of the 2ST)...
In a message dated 5/28/2002 5:07:30 PM Eastern Daylight Time, ron.price@... writes: << Leonard, The name [James] wasn't taken from a hat. My argument...
Jeffery Hodges wrote: <Do you -- or anybody -- know anything about this?> I have been following the discussion. Unfortunately, I do not have much time to...
Just an added note to my earlier messasge. RUAH appears 572 times in the Qumran literature which provides ample opportunity for the type of symbolism some...
... Leonard replied: > Not only so, but we would not in the least suspect the existence of a Markan > source at the time of the writing of these two gospels....
... Hello Dr. Longstaff I have never argued that we need a "completely satisfactory solution" to anything, as I do not believe that such a happy outcome is...
Since it has not been mentioned here yet, here is some fresh, new evidence with possible implications for Synoptic hypotheses: A new papyrus has been found in...
Thanks, Wieland Willker, for introducing this interesting subject. If convenient, perhaps you, or others, would describe (and maybe also evaluate) the...
... Stephen, I don't know of any study along these lines. ... I don't have easy access to Hawkins. But if we look at the more recent Davies & Allison _Matthew...
... I recognize that we are, to some extent, talking past one another, as you and I do not even begin by agreeing on what exactly constitutes "Q" in the first...
It's fashionable these days to downplay the importance of doublets as an argument for a written sayings source behind Matthew and Luke. But this fashion seems...
... Brian, Your comment misses my point. Do you not think that those who propose a hypothesis have an obligation to test it? The 2DH implies that the double...
shalom Horace Jeffery, ... You can get a rough and ready answer to that by looking up the quote. Is the quote in Aramaic? Not. It would be safe to say that the...
... Ron replied: > I don't understand the relevance of framing here, or why it's an > exception to your disclaimer. > Anyway I must disagree about 2DH...
In _Excavating Q_, p.89, Kloppenborg presents Mt 10:24-39 as ten Q sayings, claiming this text is a clear example which demonstrates that: "It should be...
... I too have long favored that the author refers to Paul when writing about the "disciple whom Jesus loved". He does this in just three (!) passages (13,23; ...
... From: Goodell, Donald (Donald) Sent: Thursday, May 09, 2002 2:28 PM To: 'K.Hanhart@...' Subject: Beloved Disciple Karel: I'm just back from leave,...
I have, on occasion, talked about some aspects of my research on this list (I'm the one who's been looking at the unfortunate influence of Hegel's racial...
I have argued based on the 3ST that the sayings source (sQ) was in Aramaic. In support of this I have found that over 3/4 of the texts commonly quoted as...
... Dear Mark, I find this definition amusing, because most opponents to the 2DH arguments object to the 2DH claim that the minor agreements could be the...
