A further thought on this. In the triple tradition pericope the Transfiguration, Mt 17.1-8, Mk 9.2-8, Lk 9.28-36, the material in Lk 9.34(b) -- "and they were...
Brian E. Wilson
brian@...
Dec 1, 2001 8:38 am
7081
I'm sure they had to make some judgment calls. This difference between 112 and 002 is, after all, just a matter of degree. A paragraph by only Luke is 002, and...
David Gentile
GentDave@...
Dec 1, 2001 3:12 pm
7082
... Of course, it reveals the decisions of the editors about the relationship between the synoptic gospels. The main question, however, is whether and to what...
Stephen C. Carlson
scarlson@...
Dec 1, 2001 6:06 pm
7083
Thanks for the further clarifications and explanations. If I may come back with further perhaps misguided questions as I try to get my mind around this: ... ...
Mark Goodacre
M.S.Goodacre@...
Dec 2, 2001 12:35 am
7084
... Would I have expected 222 and 221 to look a lot alike? Yes. That 222 looks nothing like expected is the one result I found very surprising. I sort of...
David Gentile
GentDave@...
Dec 2, 2001 5:22 am
7085
I thought I'd find some specifics to help figure this out. Now, I'm getting out of my area, so your thoughts will be greatly appreciated. The 3 most...
David Gentile
GentDave@...
Dec 2, 2001 7:49 am
7086
Dave, What surprises me about this whole discussion is that you have been trying to make sense of a set of results which represents a small proportion of the...
Ron Price
ron.price@...
Dec 2, 2001 10:47 am
7087
Looking at GINOMAI in the triple tradition (where nobody has a zero) The number of time the word occurs is: M - 24 K - 39 L - 45 It's percentage of total words...
David Gentile
GentDave@...
Dec 2, 2001 10:58 am
7088
Hello Ron, Thanks for the suggestion. I was planning to do exactly that, once I got the next batch of data entered. I'm not sure how soon that will be. Dave...
David Gentile
GentDave@...
Dec 2, 2001 11:03 am
7089
In a message dated 12/2/2001 5:53:02 AM Eastern Standard Time, GentDave@... writes: << 122 - 4.54% - Hmm. Luke must have kept it more often when...
Maluflen@...
Dec 2, 2001 3:18 pm
7090
... In this regard, it occurs to me that the 95% level of assessing significance is far too generous. 95% implies that one in twenty may be wrong, but in our...
Stephen C. Carlson
scarlson@...
Dec 2, 2001 3:35 pm
7091
Hello again, I agree 95% is very generous. I used that in reporting "Delta" because there was little data. With "Alpha-Delta" I reported 99%. (And lost one...
David Gentile
GentDave@...
Dec 2, 2001 5:32 pm
7092
Hello Leonard, You could well be correct about the ordering. I've not looked into it carefully. I tend to think Mark had 2 sources, one more Matthew-like and...
David Gentile
GentDave@...
Dec 2, 2001 6:13 pm
7093
Brian Wilson wrote -- ... Stephen Carlson replied -- ... Stephen, But the aim of the game is to discover the relationship between the synoptic gospels, not the...
Brian E. Wilson
brian@...
Dec 2, 2001 6:13 pm
7094
... If you (or anyone else) could produce such a computer program, I'd be very impressed. However, one cannot even identify a parallel without supposing some...
Stephen C. Carlson
scarlson@...
Dec 2, 2001 7:34 pm
7095
... (where Matt supports Mark's order, Luke frequently departs from it, but where Matt abandons Mark's order, Luke religiously adheres to it -- and vice...
Ken Olson
kaolson@...
Dec 3, 2001 12:20 am
7096
Mahlon, I agree with much of what you note about the pattern-recognition process and false positives. This will lead two scholars with the same data and shared...
Horace Jeffery Hodges
jefferyhodges@...
Dec 3, 2001 3:42 am
7097
Brian Wilson wrote -- ... Stephen Carlson replied -- ... Stephen, I do not understand your argument here. The occurrence of parallels between Mark's healing of...
Brian E. Wilson
brian@...
Dec 3, 2001 11:25 am
7098
... This question may be seen in fact as the source of renewal for Boismardian study of synoptic problem, during the 90's. The ground studies are "Le texte...
Emmanuel Fritsch
emmanuel.fritsch@...
Dec 3, 2001 12:56 pm
7099
A few years ago I read a comment on Mk 14.22 in which it is said that Jesus broke bread and gave this to his disciples with the words, "This is my body". The...
Brian E. Wilson
brian@...
Dec 3, 2001 8:58 pm
7100
I gave Yesterday to David Inglis some redundant information, yet given by Leonard. I apologize, and give some other precisions. Some information about Boismard...
Emmanuel Fritsch
emmanuel.fritsch@...
Dec 4, 2001 12:00 pm
7101
Some questions to David. 1] Why a substraction and not a division ? ... Why do you use the substraction, and not the division, for that operation ? Your...
Emmanuel Fritsch
emmanuel.fritsch@...
Dec 4, 2001 12:03 pm
7102
... I see some different biases in an automatic process : - Brian pointed out that a gospel may be selected, and the priority of this gospel (typicallly :...
Emmanuel Fritsch
emmanuel.fritsch@...
Dec 4, 2001 12:03 pm
7103
As I look at these results more, they are proving difficult to interpret. Mark Goodacre seems to have been correct, in that the impact of the editors is hard...
David Gentile
GentDave@...
Dec 4, 2001 12:06 pm
7104
Hello Emmanuel, Comments in-line. ... not ? ... We've all ready done one division to get to frequencies. I'm not sure what impact your idea would have....
David Gentile
GentDave@...
Dec 4, 2001 12:35 pm
7105
Hello again Emmanuel, I thought about your first suggestion here, a little more. ... ? ... division. ... subtraction. ... The current method gives more weight...
David Gentile
GentDave@...
Dec 4, 2001 11:19 pm
7106
Following Ron Price's suggestion, I'm looking at the E-I data by itself, to check for consistency. It's not as stable as I though, but it's not that bad ...
David Gentile
GentDave@...
Dec 4, 2001 11:45 pm
7107
... OK. But in that case, what is the purpose of this substraction ? I still not understand it. a+ manu Synoptic-L Homepage:...
Emmanuel Fritsch
emmanuel.fritsch@...
Dec 5, 2001 9:50 am
7108
Dave Gentile wrote -- ... Dave, I am still finding this fascinating. I am wondering whether the above was intended to be a summary of the state of play now...
Brian E. Wilson
brian@...
Dec 5, 2001 12:30 pm
7109
Hello Brian, ... That's not a complete list, I'll put that together at some point. Everything else was pretty much consistent with the 2SH, so I just reported...
