... This point, of course, is a valid one. Fortunately for Mark G., however, today's leading scholars who actually argue for Q (e.g. Tuckett) do in fact argue...
3671
Ron Price
ron.price@...
Feb 1, 2000 12:37 pm
... What sort of argument is this? Something you think is "likely" appears in your eyes to render my argument null and void. Surely I am allowed to put forward...
3672
Brian E. Wilson
brian@...
Feb 1, 2000 4:07 pm
Ron Price wrote - ... But which Q are we talking about? Is it the Q of the 3SH held by Ron Price, or the Q of the 2DH held by Tuckett, or the Q of the Boismard...
3673
Antonio Jerez
antonio.jerez@...
Feb 1, 2000 5:35 pm
... Blessings on you, Mark Goodacre! This response of yours is in my opinion a perfect example of how rewarding it can be to use sourcecriticism,...
3674
K. Hanhart
K.Hanhart@...
Feb 1, 2000 5:49 pm
... L.S. Re. "order" There are two main options: (a) Papias (in Asia Minor), ill-informed of the three other Gospels, naturally opted for "the order" of John,...
3675
Mike MacDonell
sendero@...
Feb 1, 2000 6:14 pm
Dear Brian: ... You are absolutely correct! You have expressed the concern of many of us, that by invoking Q, virtually any argument can be justified. Q has...
3676
Yuri Kuchinsky
yuku@...
Feb 2, 2000 5:13 am
... Karel, I admit that I'm somewhat puzzled by some of the things you're saying. What makes you think Papias was ill-informed of the three other Gospels, for...
3677
Stephen C. Carlson
scarlson@...
Feb 2, 2000 5:53 am
... I think that it is indeed proper to ask, as you have done, to ask which possibility is relatively more likely, but in this case I cannot determine which...
3678
K. Hanhart
K.Hanhart@...
Feb 2, 2000 9:26 am
... Yuri, As I admitted in advance, my arguments were too tersely stated. Of course, Papias knew all four Gospels. I formulated my point (a) above with some...
3679
Ron Price
ron.price@...
Feb 2, 2000 12:17 pm
... Stephen, I will concede one thing about this statement, namely that it is a widely held view. But it is much more than that. This (incorrect) view is at...
3680
Jim West
jwest@...
Feb 2, 2000 3:31 pm
I realize this is most likely an odd question- but of late I have been enjoying a little reading related not at all to Biblical Studies (a rarity for me)....
3681
Yuri Kuchinsky
yuku@...
Feb 2, 2000 5:32 pm
... Stephen, If so, then obviously Tuckett and other leading Q scholars are wrong. They are wrong if only because Matthew and Luke's independence from one...
3682
ll
louis@...
Feb 2, 2000 6:10 pm
... This is also a rather difficult assertion to maintain considering the fact that there is virtually no evidence for the existence of codified written...
3683
Brian E. Wilson
brian@...
Feb 2, 2000 8:59 pm
Jim West wote - ... Jim, Yes. It is possible if we allow that the writer intended that the structure of his book should be interpreted allegorically. On the...
3684
Stephen C. Carlson
scarlson@...
Feb 3, 2000 1:38 am
... I am hopeful, with the publication of THE GOSPEL FOR ALL CHRISTIANS, that more scholars will begin to recognize and appreciate this point. ... Which of...
3685
Maluflen@...
Feb 3, 2000 11:58 am
In a message dated 2/2/2000 12:42:05 PM Eastern Standard Time, yuku@... writes: << So to assume that the community of Lk was unaware of or out of ...
3686
Ron Price
ron.price@...
Feb 3, 2000 12:21 pm
... No. But these verses do not have so much weight as an indicator of what Au_Matt really thought because they were copied from Mark. ... None of the other...
3687
Stephen C. Carlson
scarlson@...
Feb 3, 2000 2:45 pm
... This example from physics is more apt than you realize. Yes, there was a controversy between Huygens's wave theory of optics and Newton's corpuscular...
3688
Maluflen@...
Feb 3, 2000 4:07 pm
In a message dated 2/3/2000 7:27:10 AM Eastern Standard Time, ron.price@... writes: ... No. But these verses do not have so much weight as an indicator...
3689
Yuri Kuchinsky
yuku@...
Feb 3, 2000 6:36 pm
... Karel, In my view, Papias was a supporter of Jn, and he supported Jn because he favoured its chronology. ... Yes, as connected with later liturgical...
3690
Yuri Kuchinsky
yuku@...
Feb 3, 2000 7:01 pm
... Louis, Yes, "haggadah"; was probably not the right word. Karel probably meant something closer to "liturgy". ... Yes, it may sound odd, but Goudoever...
3691
Yuri Kuchinsky
yuku@...
Feb 3, 2000 7:18 pm
... Let's hope so, Stephen. ... I'm pretty sure he talks about this in his ORIGINS OF THE NEW TESTAMENT. I remember I posted about this a while back, probably...
3692
Maluflen@...
Feb 3, 2000 8:43 pm
In a message dated 2/3/2000 2:23:38 PM Eastern Standard Time, yuku@... writes: << ... [Yuri] I'm pretty sure he talks about this in his ORIGINS OF...
3693
Brian E. Wilson
brian@...
Feb 3, 2000 9:55 pm
Yuri Kuchinsky wrote -- ... The idea of "drinking the blood" seems to be present in the writing of Paul in I Corinthians 10.16 - "The cup of blessing which we...
3694
Jack Kilmon
jkilmon@...
Feb 3, 2000 10:20 pm
... In my journeys through Aramaic, lachma (bread) is encountered as an idiom for teaching so that "eating of the bread" of a teacher is learning what he had...
3695
ll
louis@...
Feb 3, 2000 10:55 pm
... Fair enough. ... They are one and the same festival. ... Agreed. However, I do not wish to make this alone or even the key argument in my contentions. If...
3696
ll
louis@...
Feb 3, 2000 11:04 pm
... Hmmmm. Another possible reading of lachma, and you can take this for what you will, is flesh. Both lachma and lechem, when talking about the lachma of an...
3697
Jim West
jwest@...
Feb 3, 2000 11:46 pm
Colleagues, A year ago I inagurated the Biblical Studies Resources web page- in hopes of providing a little spot on the web where students especially could...
3698
Stephen C. Carlson
scarlson@...
Feb 4, 2000 5:09 am
... On page 321 of his ORIGINS OF THE NEW TESTAMENT, Loisy assigns a date of 140 at the earliest for the canonical edition of Matthew, but then on page 322,...
3699
Maluflen@...
Feb 4, 2000 5:04 pm
In a message dated 2/4/2000 12:14:19 AM Eastern Standard Time, scarlson@... writes: << On page 321 of his ORIGINS OF THE NEW TESTAMENT, Loisy...
