Apologies for crossposting. I've been given a tentative go-ahead from Paulist Press to produce a book on the LP for their _What Are They Saying About ..."...
3427
Ron Price
ron.price@...
Dec 6, 1999 12:34 pm
Brian, Thanks for your comments. I agree that the Sermon on the Mount and the Lord's Prayer are a problem for the Farrer Hypothesis. To me it is incredible...
3428
Jeffrey B. Gibson
jgibson000@...
Dec 7, 1999 1:34 am
In line with my recent request for List members to let me know what they think of my thinking on what should go into a "What Are They Saying About ..." book on...
3429
Jack Kilmon
jkilmon@...
Dec 7, 1999 2:37 am
... I have been leaning toward the posibility that the Matthean scribe used a "Greek Q" while Luke did his own translation of an "Aramaic Q." If this is true,...
3430
yochanan bitan
ButhFam@...
Dec 7, 1999 6:39 am
... what has ... not ... Goulder's latest ... JG>> So now I'm raising it -- the question of whether Matthew's so called JG>> expansions in the LP are really...
3431
Brian E. Wilson
brian@...
Dec 7, 1999 10:39 am
Ron Price wrote - ... I think you put this well. I would even go further, myself, and suggest that the whole idea of oral Jesus tradition in Greek (other than...
3432
Stephen C. Carlson
scarlson@...
Dec 7, 1999 1:53 pm
... Although I've been fascinated by Papias for many years, I've never read until now that Papias spoke Aramaic. What is the basis for this view? Papias did...
3433
Jack Kilmon
jkilmon@...
Dec 7, 1999 4:09 pm
... These parallels, in the Kaddish (or an early version) and other Jewish sources does not take those phrases out of the mouth of the HJ whose education and...
3434
Brian E. Wilson
brian@...
Dec 7, 1999 10:55 pm
Stephen Carlson wrote - ... Stephen, Thanks for pointing out my mistake. I now realize I was confusing Papias with Josephus. Sorry about that. Best wishes, ...
3435
Stephen C. Carlson
scarlson@...
Dec 8, 1999 1:48 pm
As you all may know, Augustine was the first to posit an actual literary basis for the composition of the gospels, stating that "Mark seems to have followed...
3436
Ron Price
ron.price@...
Dec 8, 1999 2:50 pm
Brian Wilson wrote: << I would suggest that the following two-fold repetitions in Luke have only one component parallelled in Mark - (1) Lk 4.43(b) // Mk 1.38,...
3437
Brian E. Wilson
brian@...
Dec 8, 1999 9:20 pm
Ron Price wrote - ... Ron, Nonetheless, they are all instances of duplication which Au_Luke allowed in his gospel. I think it is a hard task to try and show...
3438
John Christopher Poir...
poirier@...
Dec 9, 1999 12:26 am
The recent discussion about Bart Ehrman’s argument for Markan priority brings up the general trend of New Testament introductions. First, I should remind the...
3439
Jeffrey B. Gibson
jgibson000@...
Dec 9, 1999 3:22 am
... Brian, It would seem to me, given the above, that you MUST have some definite idea of what was in (at least a portion of) the Greek notes. For the...
3440
Brian E. Wilson
brian@...
Dec 10, 1999 8:47 am
Jeffrey Gibson wrote - ... Jeffrey, The Greek Notes Hypothesis posits that a rather repetitious writer wrote out a set of Greek Notes of Jesus tradition,...
3441
Brian E. Wilson
brian@...
Dec 10, 1999 8:47 am
Do the letters of Paul in the NT indicate that Paul knew the Christmas stories we find in Mt 1-2 and Lk 1-2 ? Best wishes, BRIAN WILSON E-MAIL :...
3442
Mark Goodacre
M.S.GOODACRE@...
Dec 10, 1999 9:53 am
I have uploaded a copy of my SBL Q Section paper temporarily to the web. I'd be grateful for any comments or criticisms as I attempt to revise it for...
3443
Mark Goodacre
M.S.GOODACRE@...
Dec 10, 1999 9:57 am
I am happy to announce a long overdue new addition to the Mark Without Q Web Site, a hypertext version of Michael Goulder's 1996 article in JBL entitled "Is Q...
3444
Jeffrey B. Gibson
jgibson000@...
Dec 10, 1999 1:34 pm
... Off the top of my head, no. So far as I can recall without doing any checking is that all Paul says is that is materially in any way parallel to anything...
3445
Thomas R. W. Longstaff
t_longst@...
Dec 10, 1999 1:54 pm
Indeed. It might also be that for such details as "born of a woman" one need not look for close literary dependence. trwl...
3446
Mark Goodacre
M.S.GOODACRE@...
Dec 10, 1999 2:22 pm
... It is an interesting question, and encouraging to see Goulder's critique taken seriously. One or two thoughts: (1) Of course Goulder's major point is the...
3447
Carl W. Conrad
cwconrad@...
Dec 10, 1999 3:03 pm
... Unless, of course, one remembers McDuff and the unjustified confidence of Macbeth that he had nothing to fear from a man "not of woman born." Carl W....
3448
Carl W. Conrad
cwconrad@...
Dec 10, 1999 3:53 pm
... My apologies to the list for a rather feeble effort to inject a bit of levity into the discussion. Perhaps others were as befuddled about what I meant as...
3449
Brian E. Wilson
brian@...
Dec 10, 1999 4:43 pm
... Jeffrey Gibson replied - ... I was wondering about - 2 Corinthians 8.9 - "For you know the grace of our Lord Jesus Christ, that though he was rich, yet for...
3450
Jeffrey B. Gibson
jgibson000@...
Dec 10, 1999 9:40 pm
... It only makes sense if and only if (a) this is not a referent to a fact that, despite what the Gospel tradition seems to imply, Jesus came from a well off...
3451
Brian E. Wilson
brian@...
Dec 11, 1999 9:40 am
Brian Wilson wrote - ... "I was wondering about - ... Does this make sense if Paul did not know something like the "Christmas story" of Matthew/Luke?" ... ...
3452
Jeffrey B. Gibson
jgibson000@...
Dec 11, 1999 2:25 pm
... Err... what? The issue at this point in 2 Cor is whether the Corinthian congregation is going to contribute to "the collection" for the saints in Jerusalem...
3453
Thomas R. W. Longstaff
t_longst@...
Dec 11, 1999 2:27 pm
... Yes, I think it does make sense (or seems to). For example: Although this discussion of Pauline theology is somewhat far afield from a consideration of the...
3454
Jeffrey B. Gibson
jgibson000@...
Dec 11, 1999 2:59 pm
... But as I have noted (in a post that just crossed yours), it does so **only** if 2 Cor 8:9 is a reference to the incarnation. But, as Dunn and others have ...
3455
Brian E. Wilson
brian@...
Dec 11, 1999 3:33 pm
Thomas Longstaff wrote- ... Your students are fortunate. I entirely agree with what you say. And I really do like the humorous touch at the end. Doesn't it...
