Brian Wilson wrote: The existence of "Q" in the Two Document Hypothesis is pure ... Brian, I am really not doing this to be awkward - but if you said that...
Graham Hamer
G.Hamer@...
Feb 1, 1999 9:29 am
1823
Brian, Thank you for your response. ... I am sorry Brian, I am just going to have to disagree with Millard, while accepting that he has more experience of...
Jeremy Duff
Jeremy.Duff@...
Feb 1, 1999 9:54 am
1824
Stephen Carlson wrote - ... Stephen, I would like to dub your listing the "Carlson Classification". Perhaps others on Synoptic-L would want to do the same? ...
Brian E. Wilson
brian@...
Feb 1, 1999 1:08 pm
1825
Graham Hamer wrote - ... I agree. But any hypothesis goes beyond the available evidence, otherwise it would be just a string of data. What matters is whether...
Brian E. Wilson
brian@...
Feb 1, 1999 2:32 pm
1826
... never thinking. ... to the points made by the previous poster. Pehaps you intended this as sarcasm. It should have been clear that my response was to his ...
antonio.jerez@...
Feb 1, 1999 3:01 pm
1827
Message text written by "Stephen C. Carlson" ... hypotheses into solution types that, in its normalized form, disregard "supernumerary" hypothetical documents...
David C. Hindley
DHindley@...
Feb 1, 1999 3:20 pm
1828
Message text written by INTERNET:K.Hanhart@... ... the old priestly calendar and the Pharisaic calendar for the beginning and ending of Shavuoth.< ... ...
David C. Hindley
DHindley@...
Feb 1, 1999 3:25 pm
1829
... Your surmise is warranted, Thomas. I suppose I was somewhat troubled by the implication that Peter M. Head, the author of "Christology and the synoptic...
Yuri Kuchinsky
yuku@...
Feb 1, 1999 4:09 pm
1830
... Thank you, David. This was not my idea of course. I came across it a few times in various places, but haven't seen any detailed defence of it as yet,...
Yuri Kuchinsky
yuku@...
Feb 1, 1999 4:09 pm
1831
... I think a number of issues come into play here. When we look at the DSS, the number of fragments that are from codices are very few and those being the...
Jack Kilmon
jkilmon@...
Feb 1, 1999 5:42 pm
1832
Can anyone comment on the use of codex in the civilian world? I believe Julius Caesar began to prefer them, and introduced them to Roman use. Regards, Tony...
TonyProst@...
Feb 1, 1999 5:46 pm
1833
... First reference to literature in codices is Martial Epigrams 14.184-192 (mid-late first century AD). Beforehand (Caesar etc.) they were used for jottings. ...
Jeremy Duff
Jeremy.Duff@...
Feb 1, 1999 6:42 pm
1834
An early codex, or caudex, was essentially two wax tablets bound together like a book, or two ivory or wooden slates with wax. I am interested in the what ms...
Jack Kilmon
jkilmon@...
Feb 1, 1999 7:39 pm
1835
Papyrus codices came first, on the whole, not vellum. I wouldn't be surprised if some of the earliest extant codices are the biblical ones from the second...
Jeremy Duff
Jeremy.Duff@...
Feb 1, 1999 8:19 pm
1836
Jack Kilmon wrote - ... Jack, It is vitally important to distinguish codices used for notes, accounts, documentary records and the like, from codices used for...
Brian E. Wilson
brian@...
Feb 1, 1999 8:52 pm
1837
In my understanding, after the wax tablets, the term was applied to books of this format made of papyrus, vellum, or parchment. Although papyrus usually...
Jack Kilmon
jkilmon@...
Feb 1, 1999 9:01 pm
1838
According to Jack Finnegan in LIGHT FROM THE ANCIENT PAST(1946). The scroll was used primarily in the first century while the codex became popular for...
David Hall
quentino@...
Feb 2, 1999 2:35 am
1839
Not being on the Synoptic list, I am wondering 1) if someone has kept a log of the discussion on codices, and\or 2) whether the list is archived; and 3) the...
TonyProst@...
Feb 2, 1999 5:27 pm
1840
... early ... lists ... This subject has been explored in recent decades especially by the late Colin Roberts (e.g. Manuscript, Society and Belief in Early...
TonyProst@...
Feb 2, 1999 5:30 pm
1841
Karel Hanhart wrote- ... Karel, How do we know that Mark did not copy every instance of KAI EUTHUJ, the historic present, and PALIN from a documentary source...
Brian E. Wilson
brian@...
Feb 2, 1999 9:52 pm
1842
Friends, For the sake of completeness, I've uploaded a 226K file listing all 4972 viable documentary theories (with up to two hypothetical documents), with a...
Stephen C. Carlson
scarlson@...
Feb 3, 1999 5:40 am
1843
On Jan 3 1999 Yuri Kuchinsky wrote: ... Dear Yuri, 'Clarify' will take up too much space and time. Most of my argumentation you may find in my book put out by...
K. Hanhart
K.Hanhart@...
Feb 3, 1999 7:12 am
1844
... You will find the relevant addresses in the signature below. The Synoptic-L home page provides details about the group and the Synoptic-L archives are at ...
Mark Goodacre
M.S.GOODACRE@...
Feb 3, 1999 8:52 am
1845
In connection with some recent discussions, brought to my attention by the omni-present Dr. Goodacre (are you sure this is not a pseudonym?): You certainly...
Peter Head
PeterH@...
Feb 3, 1999 11:29 am
1846
... Dear Antonio, I'm still waiting for you to visit Belize again so that we can meet face to face! In May we here at St. John's College lost all connection...
Fr. Donald Murphy
donmurphy@...
Feb 3, 1999 11:57 am
1847
Stephen Carlson wrote- ... Stephen, You write "supernumerary hypothetical documents" above. Why? Why not just "supernumerary documents"? I would suggest that...
Brian E. Wilson
brian@...
Feb 3, 1999 12:03 pm
1848
... Brian makes an important point about the potential for bias even in an apparently objective statement of theoretical relationships. However, I think there...
Graham Hamer
G.Hamer@...
Feb 3, 1999 2:34 pm
1849
... What a surprise! Welcome to the list, Peter. Judging by the quality of your book synoptic-L will certainly be strengthened by your presence. And hopefully...
Antonio Jerez
antonio.jerez@...
Feb 3, 1999 6:24 pm
1850
... Dear Donald, and I would very much want to meet you in Belize. These dark wintermonths here in Sweden I have been daydreaming quite a lot about the...
Antonio Jerez
antonio.jerez@...
Feb 3, 1999 6:27 pm
1851
Graham Hamer wrote - ... Graham, OK, except that I would add at the end of your statement that any relationship between any two synoptic gospels and/or...
