... I am having difficulty finding exactly where this is made clear. The closest passage I could find equates to the second part of your stipulation: that...
Mr. Christopher Plane...
cplaneau@xxxxx.xxxx
Jan 2, 1999 3:28 am
29
... Not "someone" Bernard ... "you!" The ranking I assign in your tone is an impression from our never ending exchanges on this matter based on Aristoteles...
Mr. Christopher Plane...
cplaneau@xxxxx.xxxx
Jan 1, 1999 10:53 pm
28
... This is not the issue. You are definitely a sly one. The issue was/is: you deliberately and basely misrepresent what I do, as if treating Platon as an...
Mr. Christopher Plane...
cplaneau@xxxxx.xxxx
Jan 1, 1999 7:31 pm
27
On Thu, 31 Dec 1998 08:41:01 -0500 (EST), Mr. Christopher Planeaux ... That you and "scholars" do it doesn't the least prove it is waranted and that it is what...
Bernard F. SUZANNE
bfsuzan@xxx.xxxx
Jan 1, 1999 4:55 pm
26
On Wed, 30 Dec 1998 11:03:26 -0500 (EST), Mr. Christopher Planeaux wrote: [BS] ... [CP] ... Mine is that all he cares for in stressing the "first" occurrence...
Bernard F. SUZANNE
bfsuzan@xxx.xxxx
Jan 1, 1999 3:46 pm
25
Guten Tag George. I hope you enjoyed your holiday. ... This use of 'all'ei dokei' is interesting - I hadn't heard about it before. Also, I can certainly...
Angela Cembrola
angela@...
Jan 1, 1999 3:13 pm
24
Best wishes to all for a happy, healthy, thoughtful and mutually respectful new year. -- Lance Fletcher, President The Free Lance Academy Foundation for...
lance@xxxxxxxxxxx.xxx...
lance@xxxxxxxxxxx.xxx...
Dec 31, 1998 2:28 pm
23
... Lots. I'm about to get on a train, however, to visit my mother for New Year's. I'll start responding when I return. If you are really impatient, however,...
lance@xxxxxxxxxxx.xxx...
lance@xxxxxxxxxxx.xxx...
Dec 31, 1998 2:26 pm
22
... I do not think this is the most appropriate question to ask, and it skews what my posts, as well as what other scholars such as (e.g.) AE Taylor and...
Mr. Christopher Plane...
cplaneau@xxxxx.xxxx
Dec 31, 1998 1:41 pm
21
... I only have my own interpretive hypothesis to offer to suggest that knowing the exact day is not that important (which is probably worth nothing as it has...
Bernard F. SUZANNE
bfsuzan@xxx.xxxx
Dec 31, 1998 6:33 am
20
... That is fine, my readings are all provisional, I have been tricked by Plato too many times to state the one true interpretation. ... I was perhaps unclear....
emile nowis
enowis@xxxxxx.xxx
Dec 30, 1998 8:00 pm
19
Well, shoot, I should get to Bendis soon enough, but first ... ... And this issue, I opine, will never be fully resolved to everyone's satisfaction. I whole...
Mr. Christopher Plane...
cplaneau@xxxxx.xxxx
Dec 30, 1998 4:58 pm
18
... Literally speaking, I must concur with Bernard on this one point. Nevertheless, what this statement means is far less clear than what many may assume. Of...
Mr. Christopher Plane...
cplaneau@xxxxx.xxxx
Dec 30, 1998 4:03 pm
17
... The main reason for caring what day it was has to do with the Timaeus. The Timaeus opens with a reference to a conversation that took place "yesterday"...
lance@xxxxxxxxxxx.xxx...
lance@xxxxxxxxxxx.xxx...
Dec 30, 1998 7:38 am
16
On Tue, 29 Dec 1998 13:27:25 -0500 (EST), Mr. Christopher Planeaux ... IMHO, Plato doesn't care much for a calendar date, 4th of July or 19th of Thargelion, as...
Bernard F. SUZANNE
bfsuzan@xxx.xxxx
Dec 30, 1998 6:47 am
15
Hello all, I am working to put together a brief expose on Bendis as per Lance request. But first, a brief interlude ... ... And I whole heartedly agreethat...
Mr. Christopher Plane...
cplaneau@xxxxx.xxxx
Dec 29, 1998 6:27 pm
14
Dear Lance ... Please less restraint. I for one am delighted that you may now have the time to contribute. ... position ... I would enjoy at least a brief...
emile nowis
enowis@xxxxxx.xxx
Dec 29, 1998 4:35 am
13
Hello Christopher ... Not such a bad thing. I see more in it each time. What a beautiful dialogue! ... I was trying to read without much anticipation of later...
emile nowis
enowis@xxxxxx.xxx
Dec 29, 1998 4:32 am
12
... Yes, I know that well, having at other times contributed heavily to our dwelling at length on that opening. And I have been restraining myself a bit on...
lance@xxxxxxxxxxx.xxx...
lance@xxxxxxxxxxx.xxx...
Dec 23, 1998 6:21 pm
11
Hello Emile, ... So do I, but then again it seems that whenever we begin this reading that we can never get beyond the opening few moments! <smile> In fact,...
Mr. Christopher Plane...
cplaneau@xxxxx.xxxx
Dec 23, 1998 1:22 pm
10
unsubscribe busby@......
Busby, Eric
Busby@xxxxxxxxxx.xxxx
Dec 23, 1998 8:46 am
9
... I shall take your excellent slowing considerations into the Schwarzwald for a week. Merry Christmas, George...
George Gregory
gw.gregory@xxxxxxxxx....
Dec 23, 1998 8:45 am
8
Dear Politeans We are reading the Republic slowly, but still for me quite fast. I hope we rest a while on the pre-Kephalus stage. I read "KatebEn xthes eis...
emile nowis
enowis@xxxxxx.xxx
Dec 23, 1998 3:48 am
7
Hello, ... Yes, I think it might well seem that way. But can we isolate those features which make it seem that way? I.e., what do we take account of which then...
George Gregory
gw.gregory@xxxxxxxxx....
Dec 21, 1998 9:39 pm
6
... Perhaps I should have added 'on this occasion', as I did not mean to imply that Socrates lacks the ability to persuade! Also, as I think Socrates is...
Angela Cembrola
angela@xxx.xxxxx.xxxx
Dec 21, 1998 5:35 pm
5
... Two small points: 1. What are the exact words by which Socrates has "shown himself incapable of using persuasion?" 2. What do you mean by describing...
lance@xxxxxxxxxxx.xxx...
lance@xxxxxxxxxxx.xxx...
Dec 21, 1998 3:50 pm
4
... The conversation with Polemarchus and Adeimantus (327c-328b) does seem structured so as to show Socrates as a *recipient*, not an *agent*. He does not...
Angela Cembrola
angela@xxx.xxxxx.xxxx
Dec 21, 1998 12:20 pm
3
(This is a reseond to the new server. If it is a duplicate, my apologies.) ... The main narrative, I guess, seems to begin with Socrates' discussion with...
George Gregory
gw.gregory@xxxxxxxxx....
Dec 17, 1998 5:24 pm
2
Mindnmind1@... wrote: (this is re-send to the new server. If it is a duplicate, my apologies.) ... Perhaps you have heard or know of those persnikkity...
George Gregory
gw.gregory@xxxxxxxxx....
Dec 17, 1998 5:01 pm
1
i just wondered if this thing was working or not, please pardon the intrusion... brian...
Having problems with message search?
Fill out this form to ensure your group is one of the first to be migrated to the new message search system.
