Greetings APPA members and friends, Attached you will find some questions that you might find of interest. My best to each of you, Pierre Grimes also at...
Dear colleagues: My name is José Barrientos and I am professor at Vasco de Quiroga University and I am research at University of Sevilla. I have been working...
Hi CArlo, If I ask you, or your doctor asks you, "How are you feeling?", can you answer this question? You might not say the same thing tomorrow as you do...
Peter Raabe
Peter.Raabe@...
Oct 31, 2009 11:43 pm
1309
Hi Peter, well can they be serious ? - it's possible for "doctors" to "measure" the severity of "depression" using 21 questions ??? as a philosopher I can't...
Hi Carlo, Which part do you think is a joke? And why? Peter ... I took a quick glance at the link you gave and I noticed this sentence --> "Doctors measure...
Peter Raabe
Peter.Raabe@...
Oct 8, 2009 7:22 pm
1307
I took a quick glance at the link you gave and I noticed this sentence --> "Doctors measure the severity of depression using the "Hamilton Rating Scale of...
Hi Shlomit, Our articles combined give a rather bleak picture of anti-depressant medications: They don't work and they give you lots of side effects. Hmmm......
Peter Raabe
Peter.Raabe@...
Sep 29, 2009 3:24 pm
1305
Interesting, but it is not very strong on the real harm done by these medications (something I could observe in several persons I met). The following urls are...
Hi all, Have you seen the study on anti-depressants at the link below? http://www.plosmedicine.org/article/info:doi/10.1371/journal.pmed.0050045 Peter ...
Peter Raabe
Peter.Raabe@...
Sep 28, 2009 3:58 am
1303
You raise very important questions. Whatever are the answers of various pcs, it is certainly not part of the mainstream of Westerrn philosophical tradition,...
Ora Gruengard
orag@...
Sep 20, 2009 4:58 pm
1302
Hi all, i want to invide you to the Colloquium of the International Society for Philosophical Practice (ISPP / IGPP) in Wuppertal/Germany. Title: "Sokrates auf...
Michael Niehaus
niehaus@...
Sep 20, 2009 7:24 am
1301
Arto, excuse me if I sounded offended. I am sorry as well that I will not answer your long list of questions posted on this list. But as my personal hint: I...
Shlomit, please do not get offended by my remarks. The basic issue was the difference between a goal-oriented style of PC and the so-called free and open...
arto tukiainen
artotukiainen@...
Sep 18, 2009 4:29 pm
1299
My reference to "mirroring" was just a way of saying that some sort of self-knowledge and self-understanding is on the agenda of most philosophical counselors....
arto tukiainen
artotukiainen@...
Sep 18, 2009 4:11 pm
1298
It is an analysis of psychic contents and attitudes, but Freud would not have allowed to calii it psychoanalysis. Ora psyche ----- Original Message ----- From:...
Ora Gruengard
orag@...
Sep 18, 2009 3:51 pm
1297
It is in Being and Nothingness. I do not think he ever practiced that, but Lacan seems to have borrowed some aspects: the idea of a universal anxiety because...
Ora Gruengard
orag@...
Sep 18, 2009 3:37 pm
1296
Carmen, you can read at the below link in context that Achenbach thought/thinks that PP is psychoanalysis and a critique of it. (pp 39 of PP:AC&P) ...
Interesting Ora. Why did Sartre use the word psychoanalysis then, and not another word? (hahaha, that was a joke) I really had no idea. I will read about it. ...
Carmen, As far asI know the idea of a "philosophical psychoanalysis" is borrowed from Sartre, and has more or less nothing to do with Freud's psychoanalysis or...
Ora Gruengard
orag@...
Sep 18, 2009 2:52 am
1293
Hi Shlomit, I read in your new website that your work as a Philosophical Counselor and as a Philosophical Psychoanalyst. ("Professional activities :...
Philosophical counselors should not pretend yo be therapists, nor assumes a priori that their clients need therapy. Epicurians and Stoics indeed assume that...
Ora Gruengard
orag@...
Sep 17, 2009 10:41 pm
1291
Arto, I explained before that to me, pc has something in common with Rogers in that it respects the client as a type of friend and that there is a dialogue...
Maybe there's a continuum between two kinds of philosophical counselors. There are those who have a fairly well articulated idea of what they want to offer in...
arto tukiainen
artotukiainen@...
Sep 17, 2009 3:45 pm
1289
Arto, Everything we havw read xan be relevant, and the counselee normally does not ask for a course in the history of ideas, but as [hilosophers it is not our ...
Ora Gruengard
orag@...
Sep 17, 2009 12:50 am
1288
Ora, I think it is obvious that PC is not teaching. But I feel that familiarity with a wide range of alternative philosophies of life enhances one's ability to...
arto tukiainen
artotukiainen@...
Sep 16, 2009 3:57 pm
1287
Arto, I have nothing against listening to remote cultures: They can offer new (or re-newed) perspectives, which enlarhes our horizons. I'm less enthousiastic ...
Ora Gruengard
orag@...
Sep 15, 2009 9:31 pm
1286
Hello, Shlomit: "Concerning re-inventing PC: the aims and the ways of the ancient were quite different." Well, perhaps not that different. There's a lot to be...
arto tukiainen
artotukiainen@...
Sep 15, 2009 9:37 am
1285
Peter, your paper includes many interesting points. One of them is that "mental disorders" of various kinds are often referred to as causes of symptoms, while...
arto tukiainen
artotukiainen@...
Sep 15, 2009 7:06 am
1284
Arto, Independly of Shlomit's and Ran's opinions, openness should not mean that other traditions should (unlike mine own tradition) be beyond criticism just...
Having problems with message search?
Fill out this form to ensure your group is one of the first to be migrated to the new message search system.
